3 ms·
Well, let's add some actual context that the article lacks. 1. The live vaccine has significant practical benefits, which should not be overlooked as has happe
by tialaramex 6y ago
Well, let's add some actual context that the article lacks.
1. The live vaccine has significant practical benefits, which should not be overlooked as has happened here.
Yes it's cheaper, which is often the thing highlighted in text written by industrialised countries where the price for the killed vaccine is not an obstacle to using it. It's cheaper to make and it's cheaper to deploy in the field.
But it's also actually more effective at inducing immunity. There are at least two reasons for that, let's start with the most obvious - this is literally the virus (albeit attenuated) so it's the best possible template for what your immune system needs to fight. It's not just fragments, or a similar shape mimicked by something else. Next, it's ingested, your immune system will first run into it in your gut, which is exactly where a "real" viral exposure would begin - whereas the killed vaccine has to be injected into a muscle.
Having an oral vaccine also avoids objections to needles and similar interventions which may be a problem in some cultures - everybody eats and drinks.
2. This is currently considered important news in the industrialised north only because of coronavirus vaccine development, normally approximately nobody cares about polio cases in Sudan. But today I see several articles purporting that this is somehow relevant or has important lessons for us preparing for distribution of a COVID-19 vaccine.
But that's nonsense, Oral Polio Vaccine is a live vaccine, it always did this, it's been known it does this and that you need to figure out a plan for how to get from "No wild virus" to "No polio" possibly via internationally subsidised deployment of the killed vaccine for many decades.
In contrast there are no existing or planned COVID-19 live vaccines. This isn't a zombie movie, fragments of non-working coronavirus can't magically re-assemble into a working transmissible virus and infect people. A protein designed to be like the "spike" used by a coronavirus is not a whole working virus, any more than pebble shaped like a shark tooth is a whole working shark.
- macspoofing 6y agoYou're having a strawman argument with yourself. This has nothing to do with COVID-19, and COVID-19 virus or vaccines are not mentioned at all (AT ALL) ... and yet you're arguing some hypothetical. >Well, let's add some actual context that the article lacks. Why does it need more context? Or rather, why does it need the specific context that you're arguing for? The fact that one cannot even put together a factual article about something that really happened, without getting criticism that some larger narrative isn't constructed (either that vaccines are good, or that COVID-19 vaccines will be safe - unless administrated by the Trump administration) should provide a clue why news outlets are so distrusted by the large swaths of the public. To make it more personal: I don't need help to make up my own mind what this polio outbreak in Sudan means for my life, my choices, and my politics. Tell me what happened, give me good-faith context to understand the background of the events, and let me do the rest. If you don't, I just won't believe you because now you're not a journalist but an actor pushing politics or ideology that I may not agree with.
- extra88 6y ago> give me good-faith context to understand the background of the events By replying repeatedly to people providing context not in the article, you're indicating that reasonable people can't disagree with you regarding what's "good-faith context." Do you think the author of the AP article would react to feedback about it this way? Personally, I think more context comparing this polio vaccine to other polio vaccines is relevant and valuable, in part because of the general rise in unfounded fears of all vaccines. While we are in the midst of a pandemic for which we hope to have an effective vaccine soon, I don't think every story about any vaccine has to be related to COVID-19.
- macspoofing 6y ago>Do you think the author of the AP article would react to feedback about it this way? I have no doubt, regardless of the validity of the 'feedback', you can certainly bully the author or the news agency into pushing any narrative you want. All you have to do is frame this story as 'dangerous' and pushing 'misinformation' or 'undermining faith in vaccines'. >By replying repeatedly to people providing context not in the article, you're indicating that reasonable people can't disagree with you regarding what's "good-faith context." The question I posed is why one cannot have a regular fact-driven news article without pushing some other larger narrative (that has tenuous connection, AT BEST, to the actual story) and the 'good-faith' context that OP provided is ... pushing a larger narrative that has NOTHING to do with the actual story. I mean, he's trying to link it to a COVID-19 vaccine, which has NOTHIG to do with this polio vaccination effort. In other words, why is it critical for a story about Sudan to argue against American anti-vaxxers or opinionate on American COVID-19 policy, or other political goals you're trying to push in America. So what I meant by 'good-faith context' is context that is directly linked to understanding the facts detailed in the story, not context for larger narrative that pushes other policy and political goals. This article is actually quite good - it communicated an issue with polio vaccine and provided a larger and historical context of vaccine efforts in the region, and how it is viewed by public health authorities and the WHO. I got the gist of the story. >I think more context comparing this polio vaccine to other polio vaccines is relevant and valuable, in part because of the general rise in unfounded fears of all vaccines. What if the general distrust of authoritative sources and news media stems from precisely this kind of reasoning ... that you need tell people what to believe, play down or omit any countervailing facts and preferably tie it to national politics and policy as much as you can (for completeness). Let me turn it around on you: how is it that you are able to read this story and frame it in your mind within the larger context of vaccines, but others aren't? Why do you need to the writer to editorialize and push a point of view? You clearly understood that this polio outbreak does not mean all types of vaccines are dangerous.