7 ms·
What's the real reason Apple can design a higher performance device? Better fab process? ARM ISA is fundamentally faster? Graph conveniently omits AMD who now
by dboreham 6y ago
What's the real reason Apple can design a higher performance device? Better fab process? ARM ISA is fundamentally faster?
Graph conveniently omits AMD who now beat Intel using the same ISA but different process.
- redvenom 6y agoIt's also the fact that they are putting everything on one chip. With an Intel chip it's just the CPU.
- pfortuny 6y agoI guess their sharp focus on phones and tablets led them to think... Hey, this is so powerful we might... And they indeed could.
- jibcage 6y agoApple has a greater incentive to optimize their chips for power performance because of their smaller devices (not just the phone, but the watch too).
- fpoling 6y agoSamsung has the same incentives. But their CPUs are far behind Apple.
- p_l 6y agoSamsung chip division doesn't have guaranteed "buyer" or option to build SoC specifically for given product (even if usually you can bet on next generation Galaxy device as your target, you still have to design as if you were selling to open market - and that means less option to, for example, throw a lot of memory/cache resources that have been the main differentiator of Apple chips - which started from the same design as Exynos!)
- CountSessine 6y agowhich started from the same design as Exynos Apple was actually the one designing those cores in the Exynos - up until and including the Exynos 4000. That was when Apple decided to sever ties with Samsung and stopped designing cores for them and Samsung had to go back to stock ARM designs with the Exynos 5000. That was why the 5000 series sucked so badly - Samsung lost access to those Apple/Intrinsity juiced cores. It’s also what prompted Samsung to open SARC in Austin.
- CountSessine 6y agoI'm wrong about that - it was the Exynos 3110 that had the Apple designed core that also appeared in the A4. And after that, it was back to ARM's humble designs for Samsung.
- p_l 6y agoHummingbird in SGS2 (this was before rename to Exynos) and A4 in iPhone 4 stem from cooperation between Samsung and Apple (who previously used Samsung SoC in iPhone 3G and I think in 2G). The teams split before both phones reached maturity in design. From then on Samsung kept iterating on the Hummingbird design till I think quite recently - I'm not sure if my Note 10+ doesn't still have cores derived from that design.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> What's the real reason Apple can design a higher performance device? Motivation to do so. Intel had none.
- trevyn 6y ago>What's the real reason Apple can design a higher performance device? Everyone else with the immediate capability are professional ball-droppers.
- skohan 6y agoPart of it is that they're essentially using all of TSMC's 5nm capacity, right?
- ben-schaaf 6y agoMy guess until reviewers get their hands on the thing is that they've got some pretty good RnD alongside the massive process node advantage over Intel. AMD has already shown that there's a lot more performance in 7nm than we thought and the M1 looks like it'll be on-par with what you'd expect from zen 4, so I wouldn't say they've got any advantage from the architecture (as you'd expect)
- ivalm 6y agoRight, but zen 4 is a year away. If Apple is a year ahead then that’s a lot (even if it is because they are able to use 5nm node fab capacity first)
- dragontamer 6y agoIntel dropped the ball on 10nm and 7nm processes constantly for the last 5 years. Skylake was the "tick", then they couldn't "Tock" to 10nm, so they made 14nm+, then 14nm++, then 14nm+++... Intel's been stuck on the same process for half a decade now.
- qayxc 6y ago> Intel's been stuck on the same process for half a decade now. Even worse - the same architecture as well, which is why they have to backport their 10nm Ice Lake architecture to 14nm to even get anywhere.
- bredren 6y agoThis doesn’t come up enough: intel’s ceo had to abruptly resign in June 2018 due to a relationship with an employee. [1] That could not have come at a worse time for a company like intel. [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-intel-ceo-idUSKBN1JH1VW https://www.reuters.com/article/us-intel-ceo-idUSKBN1JH1VW
- joeryscript 6y agoHonestly? A lot of it has to do with the fact that they booked TSMC's entire 5nm production capability for some time. So they are working on a smaller process node than their competitors, and they used their market position to ensure that they will be the only ones using it for a little while. That gives them a significant leg up.
- cma 6y agoYep, like when Apple got an exclusivity deal with Toshiba on its tiny-sized harddrives for use in music players.
- jeffbee 6y agoI'm still waiting for my M1 to show up but from studying the details that other people have commented on, it's clear that Apple is slathering on the microarchitectural resources that both Intel and AMD are stingy with. Their core has a gigantic L1 instruction cache, rather a lot of L1 TLB entries (4x more than Intel), large(r) pages by default, and many other aspects. L1 TLB entries in particular are a well-known problem for x86 performance so it's a real mystery why Intel doesn't simply add more of them. x86 is probably married to 4K pages forever, because of god-damned DOS, whereas Apple can make the default page size be whatever they want it to be. People with high requirements can jump through a million hoops to get their x86 program loaded into hugepages, but on Apple's platform you're getting it for free.
- frogblast 6y agoApple’s core is very wide. But wide usually means very high power consumption. M1 apparently has much lower power consumption. So something else is going on other than “Apple is willing to spend more to make cores wider”.
- BlueTemplar 6y ago> M1 apparently has much lower power consumption. Even compared to similar manufacturing processes ?
- Miraste 6y agoThere are no similar manufacturing processes, Apple has paid for time-limited exclusivity on 5nm.
- tuatoru 6y agoThe manufacturing process is TSMC's, so probably not. To me the innovation is using phone-type SoC technology. A lot of the power (and die area) demand in modern chips is in the interface circuitry to drive the few centimetres of PCB trace between ICs. Put the RAM in the same package as the CPU and you eliminate that interface. That gives you die space and power budget for big buffers and lots of parallel execution. Interface transistors (and wires) are many times larger than the core compute logic transistors (and wires), so there is much more than a one-for-one gain.
- streetcat1 6y agoMy understanding is that there were a lots of bugs in the current processors. It was quality issues.
- Tuna-Fish 6y agoThey have access to a fab process that is ~2 full generations more advanced than what Intel is shipping most their products in, and 64-bit ARM has one advantage over x86 (fixed-width instructions) which allow them to make a very wide core. Of those two advantages, the process one is a lot more significant. Their chip loses in single-threaded performance to AMD's newest, which are still one node behind Apple, but appears to be more power-efficient. I fully expect that once AMD gets on the matching node they will take the crown back, even in a laptop power envelope.
- CountSessine 6y agoPart of it is just that Apple spent a bunch of time hiring the right people and making the right acquisitions. Another part of it is just that designing a CPU with good single threaded performance is hard and costs a lot of die area and no one else in the ARM world was incentivized to do this - who needs a smartphone with that kind of performance (I know, I know - all of us, now)? But Apple also makes IPads which are kind of a bridge device - mobile and battery-powered, but also big and something people might want to do real work on. I’m also going to say that I think Apple is still alone among the phone manufacturers in recognizing that smartphones are software platforms, not simply hardware devices. I think they have a special appreciation for the enabling power of a more capable CPU.
- pas 6y agoLook at these graphs: https://www.anandtech.com/show/16226/apple-silicon-m1-a14-deep-dive/4 https://www.anandtech.com/show/16226/apple-silicon-m1-a14-de... The 5 Watt iPhone CPU almost beats the 45 Watt AMD CPU. And the M1 will then simply obliterate the x86 incumbents. Why? The real reason is that Apple had/has the real advantage. It's size, resources, money, strategy, know-how. It's bigger than Intel. It has a better corporate culture than Intel, it has a vertically integrated market completely safe from any outside disruption for years, and will be for years. It had the opportunity to do this switch, so it had the motivation to develop this capability. Apple was able to hire the best semi designers plus benefit from the ARM platform. AMD is still too small and relatively spread thin - trying to cover multiple segments of the general market - compared to Apple, which basically has this one chip in two versions (mobile and ultra mobile).
- dboreham 6y agoWell ok but by that theory Dec Alpha or HP PA should have dominated?
- protomyth 6y agoBoth examples were chips that were basically bought by Intel. The Alpha was a monster, and the PA ended up being replaced by the Itanium.
- pas 6y agoNeither had the underlying single enormous vertically integrated market slice. Apple has and had the iPhone. Apple started using their own chips, the A5, about 10 years ago. (In 2011 March, starting with the iPad 2. And they used ARM before that too.) And since then Apple optimized the "supply chain", incremental steps, but when you are Apple every step can be almost revolutionary (and year after year Steve told exactly that to the believers, and it's basically true, just not on actual feature front, but on hardware and systems level - eg. Gorilla glass for the phones, power efficiency, the oversized battery for the MBP, milling, machining, marketing, design, and so on).