4 ms·
Per the link [1] the article refers to, if I understand correctly, Google isn't preloading ads. Google is making it possible for applications that show ads to
by crazygringo 6y ago
Per the link [1] the article refers to, if I understand correctly, Google isn't preloading ads.
Google is making it possible for applications that show ads to choose to preload them. And they're not preloaded hours/days in advance -- it's a UX pattern to load them a tap before.
So that part of the suit looks like it will fall apart. As for sending telemetry, it's $1/month in data assuming you never use Wi-Fi. Doesn't seem like a particularly unreasonable cost. Especially considering most people spend the majority of their time at work/home with Wi-Fi which means the real number is more probably more like $0.25/mo.
I think a reasonable person assumes any commercial OS is checking for push notifications, syncing info (like weather), communicating analytics, checking for updates, etc. in the background. The only question is whether it's unreasonably excessive, which in this case appears not to be. (Really the only main thing is that a device shouldn't download multi-gigabyte OS updates without asking first.)
[1] https://www.blog.google/products/admob/preloading-interstitial-ads https://www.blog.google/products/admob/preloading-interstiti...
- dsr_ 6y agoI think a reasonable person has never wondered if their OS is doing something in the background, is shocked when I tell them about it, and then shrugs and goes back to using it because the alternative is to learn something new.
- crazygringo 6y agoWhy would they be shocked? How else would their phone know there are apps to be updated, notifications received, etc.? (On a computer, anti-virus updates too.) How would it know the temperature or stocks as soon as it's brought up, even when there's no cell service? It's pretty common sense. And on iOS and Mac you prominently choose to enroll in analytics when you set up your phone, so the idea of analytics isn't a shocker either. I'm not sure if Android or Windows has the same setup choice.
- dsr_ 6y agoRule of thumb: everybody who has an HN account is an outlier compared to the general population. General people -- even those who are highly educated and use computers all the time -- do not think about their tools. They click on defaults without thinking about them. And Apple and Google and Microsoft know this and take advantage of it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- labawi 6y ago> As for sending telemetry, it's $1/month in data assuming you never use Wi-Fi. How much is it when you need to use mobile internet (email, messages, whatever) while roaming at 1+$/MB? I currently need to use roaming for work purposes at 200€/GB - luckily no android, so should be affodable. While I'm not saying the prices are appropriate, they are there and you can chat, email etc at an affordable price.
- TheKarateKid 6y agoA big part of the problem is that the data was sent, even when mobile data was turned off. If you were traveling abroad, there’s a good chance you’d get screwed with International Data fees. This is as bad as when Apple tried to keep Bluetooth on when you turned it “off.”