5 ms·
> Under active use, Android devices transfer about 11.6MB of data to Google servers daily, or 350MB per month, it's claimed, which is about half the amount tran
by izacus 6y ago
> Under active use, Android devices transfer about 11.6MB of data to Google servers daily, or 350MB per month, it's claimed, which is about half the amount transferred by an iPhone.
Interesting, so 350MB of data per month is abuse, iPhones 175MB per month isn't. I guess Google now has to half their data use for it to be at parity with Apple and we're all fine?
- detaro 6y agoIt doesn't say that, since it says the iPhone uses more. And it's a reference to a different test the article author added for context, not a claim about what's "ok".
- namdnay 6y agoErrr wouldn’t that be 700MB/month for an iPhone?
- izacus 6y agoHmm, I think it's a lapsus in the original text - the data clearly shows that iPhones transfer 50% LESS data than Androids.
- samoa42 6y agolikely depends on the settings. iphones i have set up use about 30MB per month for "System Services" dont know how much of that is from real usage vs. telemetry an stuff.
- dogma1138 6y agoYou have a breakdown of individual services also on iOS push notifications are accounted for in system services. If there is any OS level telemetry it would fall under general which for my iPhone is 105MB in total since I activated it about a year ago. In general over a year+ (11 Pro Max) its 2.5GB with software updates and document sync accounting for over half of it both of which can be explicitly set to use WiFi only same goes for most other services as well. Just to put things into perspective my total mobile data usage on this iPhone is 253GB, all system services is 1% of that.
- jsjohnst 6y agoKinda surprised to see “DNS Services” is the number three in my list of System Services’s data usage.
- alextheparrot 6y agoWhat they’re going to argue is that Google is using more than necessary when the phone isn’t actively being used. Maybe an amount is necessary, but they are comparing to Apple to provide a basis that Google’s amount is not wholly necessary. Under the claimed as similar static conditions, an iPhone uses an order of magnitude less than Google’s current amount. This provides the basis to say that 9/10th of Google’s amount may not be necessary and some lawyer is convinced he can argue that the terms don’t cover that usage by Google. I assume that the under active use category is covered broadly by the terms of Google, Apple, and any other application you’re using. While that may be an actual problem, it also might not be a legal problem given how the contracts are defined today. If you don’t like this, then you’ll need to advocate for actual laws. Otherwise, this is the best attack that can be waged against this type of behavior today and is why people appear to be “okay with” the current usage in the general case. You’re only going to see “not okay with” if a lawyer thinks they can actually win a case.
- Retric 6y agoThat’s not saying 175MB per month is ok, that could also be problematic. It’s saying 350MB per month is clearly excessive as demonstrated by a company using half that.
- emteycz 6y agoHow do you know the extent of the capabilities?
- wegs 6y ago350MB is clearly excessive, and so is 175MB. Neither helps make a point about the other, though. It's about what's transferred, and about permission. What I want now is an open source Android device where I have controls. The #1 things I want to control is app permissions. I should be able to shut them down. If an app "needs" my location, it should get a random spot in the world. If it "needs" my contacts, it should get an empty list. If an app "needs" my network, it should see that it's offline. The #2 thing I want to control is data going out. #3 is having security updates forever, rather than sudden EOL with no notice. I think someone should fork Android and do that. Ironically, I think several Chinese companies are well-positioned to do that, from a market perspective, but not from a cultural perspective.
- Gabrielfair 6y agoI use glasswire which kinda some some of this. In addition to your list I would also be interested in setting up my homelab to monitor and detect rogue traffic that would have caught my phone doing what was described in the article. Does anyone have any open-source suggestions for DIY deep-packet analysis?
- ignoramous 6y ago> Does anyone have any open-source suggestions for DIY deep-packet analysis? https://github.com/aouinizied/nfstream https://github.com/aouinizied/nfstream
- ignoramous 6y ago
- tomrod 6y agoAs others mentioned, you have the value backwards. That said, the right amount of auto transfer of content should be close to 0,a few bytes to notify of updates may be reasonable. Certainly we don't need to have books-worth of software and content transferred without the phone's owner agreeing with that agreement used with extremely narrow scope (I use the word owner here colloquially, as the user paid for the phone). Stop the abuse of "could" and begin questioning with "should."
- rm445 6y agoAt the user's preference, if they don't mind the data use, pre-loading content could improve the user experience. That kinda supposes it's content the user wants. But what if it's data, like ads, that the user doesn't exactly want but they're going to get anyway? I don't know where the lawsuit will end up, but I can see this ending up as a buried, default-on, setting that most users will never change.
- megous 6y agoWow, that would increase my monthly bill for a phone 5x if I was still not using a dumb phone.
- salawat 6y agoRealistically, expect innovation in the compression algorithm space as research shifts to communicating as much information with as few bits of user signalling as possible. Possibly innovation in encoding or extra contracts that make it possible for information to be encoded through background cell tower/wifi network traffic.
- Xelbair 6y agoeven a single bit is too much as long as it wasn't opt-in.
- as-j 6y agoBefore everyone grabs their pitch forks....as someone who does telemetry tracking devices, 350megs/mo is pretty easy to do and send nearly 0 data, if you do it wrong....let me explain: TLS connection setup is ~10k so if do an 1 HTTPS call/telemetry that's 48 calls home/hour. (11,600/10k = 1,160 https connections/day. There's 1440 minutes/day) Of basically calling home every minute and sending not much. Ok calling home every minute...but maybe when idle that's not bad for notification updates? We run long do running TLS connections using MQTT, this works for 5-6 figure of units. And our actual usage when we have good cell coverage is around 25megs/mo, including data. But when you have the qty Google and iOS have....maybe that's prohibitive?
- ignoramous 6y agoThat makes me wonder if its Google Play Services (mandatorily preloaded into every Android device) that connects frequently / keeps a connection idle to support things like Push Notifications?
- ggggtez 6y agoAlso, Google Play Services isn't Google Play. "Services" actually encompasses nearly every single app on the device, since it's more or less a library rather than an app. In which case the suit would incorrectly be blaming the store, instead of the real app that is sending the data.
- izacus 6y agoYes, it's the Play Services which handles push notifications and quite a bit of other APIs bound to Google servers as well (e.g. Nearby, Maps API, etc.)
- gentleman11 6y agoI didn’t know about the 175MB from Apple. That’s quite a lot