3 ms·
More importantly, there is a false choice between socialism + central planning on one hand, and capitalism + free market on the other. In fact, all mainstream
by tsimionescu 6y ago
More importantly, there is a false choice between socialism + central planning on one hand, and capitalism + free market on the other.
In fact, all mainstream socialists and Marxists today are in favor of some kind of free market. Also, none of the centrally planned, soviet style economies had any feature of socialism - they were capitalist societies, where all of the power was concentrated in the hands of those who controlled capital. Sure, workers were paid lip service, but their power and control over their work was in fact even less than in the European or American capitalist countries. They were just as much socialist countries as they were democratic - in that it was simply a title they assigned to themselves, void of any meaning whatsoever.
The main difference between an actual socialist market-based economy and the capitalist market-based economy that we have today would be that essentially all enterprises competing on the market would be co-ops, where workers democratically decide how the company is run and get to share the profits (and losses), instead of getting a pre-determined (sometimes negotiated) wage.
- zozbot234 6y ago> all enterprises competing on the market would be co-ops, where workers democratically decide how the company is run and get to share the profits (and losses), instead of getting a pre-determined (sometimes negotiated) wage. The problem with co-ops, partnerships and the like as a firm structure is that (1) they can't easily provide access to outside capital. Maybe they can issue debt, but that comes with a lot of drawbacks wrt. equity investment. (2) most workers have their job as their main source of income, so they don't actually want to incur the excess risk that's inherent in "sharing in the profit (and losses!) of their firm" because that literally means putting all your eggs in one basket. Outside investors can incur that risk more easily, whether by diversifying it away or by investing only part of their assets in a risky endeavor. "All enterprises as co-ops" is a nice idea but doesn't actually work in the real world. Co-ops and partnerships are totally fine for very low capital intensity businesses like law firms, but quite unsuitable elsewhere.
- tsimionescu 6y agoCo-ops have rarely been tried out, so you really can't say that with that authority. There are also many ways for a co-op to organize, the pure profit-sharing model is probably not the most popular for the reasons you outlined. For example, the largest company in the Basque region of Spain is the Mondragon corporation, a 12—billion euro yearly revenue, 60 years old federation of co-ops with about 81,000 members+employees, working in industry, finance, retail, and knowledge - hardly low-capital areas. They are currently the 10th largest company in Spain. They do have traditional employees as well as worker-owners, and there are concerns about the percentages of each, but overall they are a true co-op at a huge scale, proving that it can be done. If there were government policies to encourage this type of business, especially by providing better credit access, and if this was closer to the beaten path, I don't see any reason that it couldn't be at least a major part of the economic landscape, even if not easily becoming dominant.