14 ms·
A Modest Proposal in the New Age of DMCA Takedown Aggression
- akersten 6y agoI admit I kind of glazed over when I read through the action plan/pledge etc. I just didn't see a lot of concrete steps in there that would actually make a difference. The only thing that's going to make a difference is for someone to put their foot down and challenge §1201 in court. Code is speech. This is America. We can speak freely. §1201 should be struck from the DMCA on constitutional grounds. But no one has the pockets or the huevos to fight it.
- freedomben 6y agoIt seems like a pretty concrete step to me: Sign the agreement not to DMCA take down a FOSS project until they've had 30 days to comply. Sadly though I think you're right, it won't actually make a difference. Even if somehow he did get everybody to sign, they'd surely find some other way to attack.
- wmf 6y agoThe open source projects that I can think of that violate section 1201 are doing it intentionally, like DeCSS and now this Widevine crack. There's no way for these projects to comply and they don't want to.
- Thorrez 6y agoYes, and with GPL violations there's a path forward that doesn't involve shutting down: release your source code. With DRM breakers, there is no such path forward, the only way to get into compliance is to shut down.
- jchook 6y agoCan’t see any obvious benefit for the company’s signing the agreement other than a PR opportunity.
- nzmsv 6y agoThe EFF has had a case against it dragging on since 2016, and exactly on free speech grounds.
- throwaway2048 6y ago4 years to challenge a take down request, something that routinely get spit out by automatic scripts at a rate of tens of thousands a day. What a perfect encapsulation of the ridiculous asymmetry of the American legal system.
- sp332 6y agoThey're not challenging one takedown request made by one company, they're challenging the constitutionality of a law passed by our elected representatives.
- oysmal 6y agoWhen can this case be expected to wrap up?
- chrisseaton 6y ago> This is America. We can speak freely. America already has tons of enforced restrictions on speech for many reasons.
- atomi 6y agoCode is speech.
- jimbob45 6y agohttps://youtu.be/1Jwo5qc78QU https://youtu.be/1Jwo5qc78QU Tom Scott explains the situation and the solution best. Just shorten copyright to 20 years (instead of life + 70 years). .......that said, we did just strong-arm the world into matching US copyright law and I’m not sure we could do that now even if we wanted to.
- tptacek 6y agoIt's pretty funny, because, as a solution, it simultaneously (a) doesn't actually address the problem, because the content that DRM protects and that people want is stuff released within the last few months, and (b) can't happen, as it sets copyright length back below what it was in 1909, before Disney even existed. In fact: the 1970s extension to copyright (the one predating "Sonny Bono" was done to bring the US into compliance with Europe. People have weird thoughts about copyright.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zerocrates 6y agoDMCA 1201 is a whole different can of worms, one which isn't really affected by the copyright term. 1201's whole purpose is "anticircumvention": to ban tools for breaking DRM, not to actually punish infringement. That is, The Matrix being out of copyright tomorrow wouldn't change anything for DeCSS under 1201. The linked blog post here is actually quite strange: the post is talking about 1201 abuse, but the proposal is about copyright infringement and 512 takedown, neither of which are really related to 1201. So its hard to see how this would "blunt" 1201 at all. The recent high-profile situations have blurred the lines between the takedown provisions and the anticircumvention ones, especially as they just get listed in a "dmca" repository on Github, and the post even mentions this in the case of the Widevine takedowns, but the little technicalities do in fact matter here.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bleepblorp 6y agoThe modest answer for open source developers is to host projects that are at risk of being Americanized either on .onion sites or in jurisdictions (such as Israel or China) that don't have a huge fondness for American copyright law. Expecting domestic reforms is a sucker's game.
- bkuhn 6y agoNote there are DMCA-like provisions enforced by trade treaties. And hosting in China has its own set of problems.
- stevenicr 6y agoAny word from google and changes to how dmca's affect search results? Last I read they said something like "when a web site gets a certain amount of dmca complaints to us we will lower it's rank in the results, on top of removing pages that were takedown requested" - (purposely not explaining the number or percentage or time or whatever ) well I have a couple of sites that get "dmca emails" a few times a month- they are not legit - but I can see they are emailing multiple addys, and I assume google is one of them - I do take down stuff people request - but they do not need to threaten dmca to get it done - just ask - and with those sites things are deleted automatically in time anyway.. But I wonder if google is adding a negative to those sites for that - I assume no way to find out.
- miyuru 6y agoI got a few notices as well from non US companies on behalf of a movie studios via google. I can clearly see the google traffic drop after a notice and after a while it slowly comes back up. My solution to serve JavaScript validation notices for popular hosting ASNs and block lot of bots via cloudflare has worked well so far.
- roca 6y ago> We in fact tried, and mostly succeeded, in boycotting DRM when it was cumbersome, full of bugs, and annoyed users in the early 2000s. I wonder what the author could possibly be talking about. The only boycott that could be effective is customers saying, en masse, that they will not watch some specific, otherwise-popular content because it is only available via DRM. I don't believe this has ever happened. I don't think even the hardest-core anti-DRM people I've ever known would simply refuse to watch a movie they think they would like on these grounds. For example, Firefox refusing to support DRM would have been completely ineffective because essentially all users, on encountering video they want to watch that requires such DRM, would simply switch to Chrome to view that video.
- zerocrates 6y agoThe early 2000s is right on the steep upslope of DVD sales, famously encumbered by DRM. Depending on your definition of "early" it's also the time of iTunes's initial growth, which also had DRM in those days. Video games also merrily rolled along while requiring various DRM schemes in this period. Regardless, the post does realistically allow that no such boycott would be forthcoming now.
- axiolite 6y ago> The early 2000s is right on the steep upslope of DVD sales, famously encumbered by DRM. DVDs had weak DRM that was cracked in 1999. It was perhaps less of an encumbrance than the hassle and degredation of analog VHS tape, plus Macrovision. >it's also the time of iTunes's initial growth, which also had DRM in those days. iTMS DRM stood out as less restrictive than all other downloadable options up to that point. Apple's refusal to license their DRM and the popularity of iPods forced the music industry to offer DRM-free downloads. Many CDs had various attempts at DRM at that time as well.
- zerocrates 6y agoThose aren't really arguments in favor of the existence of a boycott, though. iTunes a closer case since they did get rid of it. The disastrous attempts at CD DRM, the Sony rootkit and so on, those are legit though. One of the DMCA's many problems is that it doesn't really matter if the protection is easily broken: the legal jeopardy for doing so remains.
- stdbrouw 6y agoFWIW, Jonathan Swift's original modest proposal, was a proposal for eating poor children and the title was satire.
- voltaireodactyl 6y agoI wrote an updated version a few days ago, if you’re into that kind of thing: https://willmckim.com/a-conservative-proposal https://willmckim.com/a-conservative-proposal
- rbecker 6y agoGoogle is using Widevine to control the browser market. Can't make a competitive browser without their permission. That is the purpose of DRM, and it works.
- woofie11 6y agoI suspect this is why Google lawyers were so lackadaisical in the Oracle Java case. Tactical loss. Strategic victory.
- xyzal 6y agoRelated question: what is the best way to publish code so it is censorship resistant?
- Fnoord 6y agoI don't claim to have the solution to your question but here's my proposal: Release it in two ways simultaneously. One, public, going for maximum exposure. This causes (short-term) availability. Assume this channel can get compromised at any time. Ie. clearweb. Two, at the same time, a more censorship resistant solution such as Tor or IPFS. Ie. darkweb. At the very least you should research the second option beforehand. I'd say though, if you already include the address in say your GitHub, then this allows caching beforehand hence a smoother transition. I saw this recently applied in alt-right movement. People getting banned from Twitter and Facebook already mentioning their contact info on darkweb beforehand cause they saw it coming.
- Snawoot 6y agoYep, this is exactly how we publish patch suite which unlocks NVENC sessions and NvFBC on Nvidia drivers: https://github.com/keylase/nvidia-patch https://github.com/keylase/nvidia-patch IPFS mirrors: Site: https://ipfs.io/ipns/QmYTEwv2GjQhtdN9bDfpLfQrVD7YLb1Sbh8igX8cEe9hHF/ https://ipfs.io/ipns/QmYTEwv2GjQhtdN9bDfpLfQrVD7YLb1Sbh8igX8... Git: git clone https://ipfs.io/ipns/Qmed4r8yrBP162WK1ybd1DJWhLUi4t6mGuBoB9fLtjxR7u nvidia-patch
- chrisseaton 6y ago> A Modest Proposal I don't think this means what the authors think it means. The idea is that the 'modest' proposal is actually an insane one, reducing to absurdity. This seems to be a genuine proposal?
- bkuhn 6y agoAs the author, I can confirm I'm fully aware of the etymology of “A Modest Proposal” — my undergraduate degree included the Honors program in the Humanities and there are many professors who would be aghast if I'd forgotten. I chose the title because the proposal should be not a big deal — especially given that these companies already demand that copyleft projects grant these 30 days — however, it's ultimately an untenable proposal. Just like the original Modest Proposal, it's made to a ruling class who don't realize their policies are completely unreasonable.
- tyingq 6y agoIt's crazy to me that the way the DMCA works is that the filer of the complaint faces no consequences for a frivolous action. Yet the receiver has really no easy recourse other than paying for a lawyer and going to court.
- swiley 6y agoI could have sworn frivolous filing was supposed to result in perjury. If it doesn't then yeah the whole law is completely broken.