2 ms·
> There's no such thing as natural herd immunity. I disagree. I just think the humans most severely vulnerable to the flu died off during the first few waves.
by umvi 6y ago
> There's no such thing as natural herd immunity.
I disagree. I just think the humans most severely vulnerable to the flu died off during the first few waves. Consider small pox. It was a novel virus for the Native Americans, who had no "natural herd immunity" and they got eviscerated by small pox. Colonists, despite not having vaccines, and despite still being able to get small pox, were not eviscerated since the virus wasn't able to spread and/or kill as well due to their natural immune systems.
What do you call this if not "natural herd immunity"? If you kill off all the weak and vulnerable, leaving only survivors and survivors' offspring who are virus-resistant... then you now have "natural herd immunity".
- tsimionescu 6y agoHerd immunity has a clear meaning: people who are individually vulnerable to a disease being protected from it by virtue of everyone around them being immune. What you're describing is simply a disease running its course and killing everyone who is not naturally immune/resistant or not strong enough to survive despite being sick. There is no herd immunity aspect. At best you could call it natural selection.