5 ms·
Authoritarianism lowers the bar for the effort that it takes this kind of thing to happen though. It takes a lot more money and effort to do it in a system wher
by bobthepanda 6y ago
Authoritarianism lowers the bar for the effort that it takes this kind of thing to happen though. It takes a lot more money and effort to do it in a system where power is less concentrated than one where it is centralized since there are more actors you have to coordinate with.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- georgeplusplus 6y agoThis simple fact is constantly overlooked by people who wish To expand government to stamp out corruption when the corruption lies in the centralization of power.
- not_kurt_godel 6y agoAnd it's likewise often overlooked by those who oppose regulation who fail to recognize when power is centralized by corporations which are even less accountable than a democratic government.
- roenxi 6y ago> which are even less accountable than a democratic government. I've never seen a politician 'held accountable' for doing something I don't like in a democracy. I'll pick out George W. Bush who (with massive public support) charged in to the Middle East, glassed one or two countries, set the US up for 20 years so far of ruinously expensive wars. He served two full terms. I might have seen an article sometime recently that he had taken up painting and is pretty good at it. What level of accountability am I expecting him to be held to for that? I think those may have been some of the worst political actions taken in my lifetime. When you say "less accountable" - what do you think shows a democratic government being held accountable? I like democracy, but I don't think the government is accountable. Corporations are actually held accountable. If they screw up, the owners can lose out massively. Executives too through incentive programs.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoGWB didn't act alone or in a vacuum. 9/11 provided a lot of political leeway. That said, the US does have term limits to at least blunt the damage when the balance of power and even impeachment don't suffice.
- roenxi 6y agoOk sure, but that poster said - quoting again - "which are even less accountable than a democratic government" So you're arguing that we don't need to hold GWB to account. Fair enough, there were mitigating circumstances. But then in what sense is the government accountable for anything? Corporations and government are both held to account through the courts, I suppose. But the government will often change the rules so it isn't accountable (eg, wiretapping scandals), so that is a weaker form of accountability than a corporation faces. Is there an actual meaty argument to the idea that governments are more accountable than corporations? Because I'm drawing blanks on the times when a government was held to account for anything in a manner that wouldn't also apply to corporate actions.
- matt_kantor 6y agoI think the idea is that we don't vote for people like Bezos, but they have a lot of power over us all the same (even if we don't directly give them our money).
- roenxi 6y agoBezos has developed a corporate behemoth that distributes goods at good prices, at absurd convenience, and as an encore provides web infrastructure for countless other businesses. I don't really have any stats, but it seems plausible the logistic chains he oversees saved a fair number of lives in the current pandemic because it reduces the need for people to contact each other. Given that record, I think there is a better argument for putting him in charge of the US healthcare system than putting the people in overseeing the healthcare system in charge of Amazon. Bezoscare written by Bezos would likely be much more effective than Obamacare written by the US Congress. And I still don't see the argument that the US government is somehow more accountable than he is.
- georgeplusplus 6y agoDeregulation spurs competition which your centralized corporations hate and actually fight in favor for all the time. The chief lobbies for Obamacare was healthcare monopolies like Blue Cross. Not to mention they don’t have the threat of jail, military, police, and other coercion to use against you. Truth is the two work hand in hand. Big corporation loves big government
- etherwaste 6y agoThat is not how commodity production works. The evolution of the commodity form has been one of competing commodity producers, where one will always lose out and have to sell their wage labor to the winning commodity producer and the existing commodity producers absorb the labor power, means of production, and continue expanding in a way which someone starting from 0 can not overwhelm. This is the economy of scale. You can cherry pick "disruptive" technologies all you want, but if you look at who holds most of the wealth in the world (a handful of billionaires), and their control over various industries, what I'm saying becomes extremely apparent. More info: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25091137 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25091137
- emmelaich 6y agoTwo mobs are better than one.
- smsm42 6y agoExpanding the government to fight corruption is like drinking vodka to stop alcoholism.