18 ms·
I'm going to say something probably unpopular, given the tone of many of the suggestions popping up, but philosophy is one case where I actually prefer to stay
by jerf 16y ago
I'm going to say something probably unpopular, given the tone of many of the suggestions popping up, but philosophy is one case where I actually prefer to stay away from the so-called "primary sources". They are typically extraordinarily long and verbose for what they have to say, and if the idea some source is groping for is genuinely new, the fact that they are only in the beginning phases of grappling with it tends to show in the presentation. Plus they will tend to use quirky nomenclature that was not necessarily settled on later. If I'm after an actual understanding of philosophy and not merely enjoying some work for its own sake, it's better to read something that has been distilled over the years to its essence and stripped of its ornamentation, so you can contemplate the essence of the idea on its own.
I scare-quoted "primary source" because in a way, the ideas belong to humanity as a whole and the first person to "discover" a particular school of thought is not always its best advocate; it's primary more in the sense merely of first rather than the journalistic sense of authoritative. I would say the journalism or scientific drive for the "primary" sources is much less important here. To me it would be like insisting the only way to tour the Americas is to follow Columbus' precise route and anything else isn't really seeing the Americas.
I say this not because they are worthless or even a bad idea, but that I really do consider them a bad place to start.
Frankly, you could do a lot worse than to just cruise Wikipedia, and drill down in what you find interesting from there. (Don't skip the drilling down. I'm not saying Wikipedia is a full education on the topic. I'm just saying, it's really not a half-bad way to start.)
- te_chris 16y agoCruising wiki has been the source of most of my philosophical knowledge since leaving university, just looking for some well regarded sources that cover the topics in a little more depth. Agree completely about your position on primary sources too, though of course there is lots of insight to be gleamed from reading the original texts, I've always preferred reading their interpreters.
- Arun2009 16y agoThe early modern texts site (http://www.earlymoderntexts.com/f_why.html http://www.earlymoderntexts.com/f_why.html) contains works that have been translated to contemporary English which could alleviate the archaic language problem. From the link: <QUOTE> My versions are faithful to the content of the originals, but are plainer and more straightforward in manner. I could have made them even plainer, but that would have taken them further than I wanted to go from the stylistic feel of the originals. I love the original texts, and am glad to have spent years wrestling with them in their pristine form. I do wish, though, that through the years I could also have read them sometimes with all my energy going into the philosophy. </QUOTE> To the OP, two overviews of Western Philosophy (of the analytic variety) I'd suggest are Russell's "The Problems of Philosophy" (http://www.ditext.com/russell/russell.html http://www.ditext.com/russell/russell.html) and Nagel's "What Does It All Mean?: A Very Short Introduction to Philosophy".