4 ms·
I wonder if it would have been easier back in 1848 when the communist manifesto was created than today. Consistently meeting people’s basic needs for food, cle
by Retric 6y ago
I wonder if it would have been easier back in 1848 when the communist manifesto was created than today. Consistently meeting people’s basic needs for food, clean water, and shelter would have been a step up for most of the world back then where today the standard of living for most people is dramatically past that point.
Both China and Russia experienced a famine shortly after becoming communist, so at least initially it seems to make things worse.
- titanomachy 6y agoThose needs could be met in an agrarian model, but you'd get swept away by the industrialized nations in pretty short order. Meeting those basic needs wouldn't be enough for long in a competitive global landscape.
- Retric 6y agoI am not suggesting a hypothetical economy which only did those things. Governments need to build militaries and roads etc. I am rather suggesting 170 years ago the yardstick for success may have looked very different. Something that is obviously flawed today may have seemed far more reasonable to people at the time and even somewhat worked. Hell the US still had slavery back then, it was simply a very different time period. Which kind of makes me think what biases someone in 170 years in the other direction aka 2190 would have thinking about our time period.
- 082349872349872 6y ago... and back then one of the arguments for keeping slavery was "if you (bostonians) start attacking the right of property (in people), you're going to wind up with communism!" It's funny how little the slippery slopes differ from the pre-internet (pre-telephone!) era to our own.