3 ms·
If the argument is "authoritarianism is bad for big private businesses" then sure (although even that is debatable considering how much protectionism can help l
by paxys 6y ago
If the argument is "authoritarianism is bad for big private businesses" then sure (although even that is debatable considering how much protectionism can help local industries at the expense of multinational ones), but looking at China's economic growth over the last few decades and how many people it has lifted out of poverty, I can't see how you can call it a failed economic system.
- onepointsixC 6y agoThat happened under an purposeful period of liberalization. Xi Jinping has been pretty clearly walking that back. Moving towards a more authoritarian direction isn't going to cause the Chinese market to fail overnight, but here we have a pretty clear example of how it is impeding growth.
- lefrenchy 6y agoOr he’s trying to avoid the pitfalls of western liberal democracies. You may not agree with the means, but saying that the Chinese market is slowly failing is a pretty grand claim to provide no evidence for.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoDidn't he basically make himself dictator for life last year by removing any term limits for him "as long as the party voted him in". If you oppose him now there's a good chance you're kicked out of the party, and that's the least of the punishments.
- flurben 6y agoThe CPC drove its own people into poverty in the first place, after WWII. Liberalisation and foreign trade is what brought them out of poverty over the past 30 years.
- z2 6y agoKind of, in the sense that yes, growth was stunted and even reversed for decades. But the starting point was low. The war with Japan and earlier revolutions to overthrow the Qing government weren't kind to economic activity, and the population basically limped into the 1940s with barely functional physical and financial infrastructure.
- flurben 6y agoAs I responded to someone else : --- China was actually quite wealthy under the Qing Dynasty, and fluctuated between 10% and 35% of global GDP. In 1949, when the PRC was formed, they represented 9.5% of the global economy. In 1990, after 41 years of Communist Party rule, China was 1.59% of the global economy. ---- So while it is accurate to say that China's economy did poorly in the 19th and early 20th century, it is also true to say that the CPC proceeded to drive the nation into abject poverty.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- platinumrad 6y agoHmm, I wonder what happened between the fall of the Qing Dynasty and 1949. Do you have a source for this 1.59% figure that you're posting everywhere? I've honestly looked and can't find one.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoAlways ignored in similar discussions, in 1950 the US convinced the UN to establish an embargo against China lasting for twenty years. Mao's economic policies were undoubtedly terrible, but the Western destruction of the Chinese economy did not stop in 1949.
- flurben 6y agoThat was a direct consequence of the PRC's decision to attack the UN coalition army in Korea, and is the result of another failed policy of the PRC.
- blackrock 6y agoWow. You totally ignored what happened before that, which led to the CCP takeover. How about the fact that the British and the Americans and all the other western governments were shoving opium down their throats? And they were making a pretty penny from all of it. The criminal British empire made their riches from drugging China with opium.
- flurben 6y agoChina was actually quite wealthy under the Qing Dynasty, and fluctuated between 10% and 35% of global GDP. In 1949, when the PRC was formed, they represented 9.5% of the global economy. In 1990, after 41 years of Communist Party rule, China was 1.59% of the global economy. You cannot blame that on opium or the west, that is the result of Communist policies like the Cultural Revolution and the Great Leap Forward, to say nothing of the ruthless control and censorship of information.
- free_rms 6y agoThe qing dynasty ended in like 1910ish. And 1949 is a weird time to try and measure economic output numbers. Half the world in ruins, and China itself being mostly illiterate peasants.. you have a cite for that number? Does it have a dollar figure per capita?