3 ms·
It's astounding that a supposedly free country won't even allow Apple to tell us how many illegal and unconstitutional warrantless data seizures the US governme
by sneak 6y ago
It's astounding that a supposedly free country won't even allow Apple to tell us how many illegal and unconstitutional warrantless data seizures the US government has compelled them to comply with.
Abridging the 4th amendment rights of users wasn't enough: they had to abridge Apple's 1st amendment rights to even say how many times it happened.
These are the people who voted to suspend the constitution and due process in the USA:
https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/115-2018/s12 https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/115-2018/s12
- chungus_khan 6y agoThe US constitution has a very long history of being selectively enforced whenever it is convenient for those in power, be it on issues of civil rights, the HUAC, various CIA and FBI programs exposed in the 70s, mass surveillance and "national security", etc. It needs to stop, but those in power seldom want their own powers curtailed.
- goodluckchuck 6y ago> Abridging the 4th amendment rights of users wasn't enough: they had to abridge Apple's 1st amendment rights to even say how many times it happened. The other (potentially more important side) of Apple's 1st amendment rights to speak are the subjects' and everyone else's 1st amendment rights to hear / receive information. In telling Apple that they cannot reveal the identity of these requests, they are saying that I am not allowed to learn whether I was subjected to ones of these searches. Without being allowed to know, I cannot challenge the search, etc. The same contra-positive-analysis is helpful with claims of "foreign interference" in elections, where I may have little concern for a foreign adversary's right to speak, but also take serious issue with the idea that I should not be allowed to learn about matters that may be important to and relevant to my vote.