3 ms·
Utilitarianism seems appealing, but arguments like this dismiss it so thorougly that I'm surprised it still receives so much attention. Where utilitarianism re
by jfengel 6y ago
Utilitarianism seems appealing, but arguments like this dismiss it so thorougly that I'm surprised it still receives so much attention.
Where utilitarianism reproduces intuition, it's redundant. Where it contradicts intuition, it doesn't do any good to say "Well, under utilitarianism, that's just fine". It's a good framework for discovering and analyzing our internal contradictions, but it's often treated as a pragmatic construct, and I don't know how well it serves there. You still need to check all of your conclusions against intuition, so it hasn't saved you any effort, and you risk being able to say "The model says this I'm going to follow it slavishly", leading to Repugnant Conclusions.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mere_addition_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mere_addition_paradox
Even if a perfect utilitarian model existed, we don't possess it. So as appealing as utilitarianism is, I think of it more as a useful academic strawman rather than a real engine for moral conclusions.