3 ms·
Employees working from home should pay tax to support those who can't
- giantg2 6y agoI'm I missing the satire or joke with this article? "...yet are still leading a full economic life." What's wrong with that? How is taxing the people working from home going to create a full economic life the people who aren't? Seems like we would be dragging more middle-class people down than actually elevating the poor (the rich make most of their money through capital, so this won't have a big impact on most of them). You would have to restructure how we treat labor and capital in the ownership and compensation models in society if we want to actually address inequality. These short-sighted taxation ideas are only addressing symptoms, not the root problems. It will only get worse. "The report says the tax should only apply outside times when the government advises people to work from home" They only want this to apply when not under the current conditions of today. Sounds like they are using today's data and problems to propose a "solution" that won't actually be in effect when needed most. To me this sounds like they didn't have data to support this tax under the prior conditions, but now they have the right data to cherry-pick.
- maxharris 6y agoInstead of penalizing change, why not encourage it? When you work from home, you don't put anywhere near the carbon into the atmosphere that you would commuting. You also spend a lot less on lunch, and you don't need to put your children into state-run schools that are really there to function as daycare centers as much as they are to educate. If all of that office space in downtown areas stays dark, and the zoning laws are altered or removed, it can be redeveloped into housing that's actually affordable. We really are running into a wall on the methane crisis, and we we simply don't have the time to integrate these changes at a slower pace. Let's focus on changing our regulations that prohibit building neighborhoods for pedestrians. Let's work on getting homes with solar roofs and big batteries. Let's get drone delivery everywhere. Let's electrify the transport system with electric cars, electric trucks, eVTOL aircraft. Let's tunnel underneath and between cities and connect them with hyperloops. Let's connect people in rural areas with low-cost, low-latency satellite internet access. Doing these things will directly provide a great number of jobs for a great number of people. It will make a great number of new jobs possible. It will improve the natural environment. I think this is a much more positive direction to take than to try to slow things down.