5 ms·
Charging for storage is becoming silly. Its essentially free. Storage is growing faster than humanity can fill it, and at an ever-spiraling decreasing price. I
by JoeAltmaier 6y ago
Charging for storage is becoming silly. Its essentially free. Storage is growing faster than humanity can fill it, and at an ever-spiraling decreasing price.
It'd be like charging for windows-up or windows-down on a taxi ride.
- coldtea 6y ago>Charging for storage is becoming silly. Its essentially free. Storage is growing faster than humanity can fill it, and at an ever-spiraling decreasing price. And yet I can't find a cheap host for 2-4TB that's not like $10/month or so... even with Glacier it's $16/4TB/month...
- tyingq 6y agoKS-3 Server - Atom N2800 - 4GB DDR3 1066 MHz - 2TB SATA $9.99/month https://www.kimsufi.com/us/en/order/kimsufi.xml?reference=1801sk14 https://www.kimsufi.com/us/en/order/kimsufi.xml?reference=18... No RAID, but it's in your desired price range.
- coldtea 6y agoYep, it's possible with a dedicated or vps with 4TB or more, but this doesn't suit my use case (backup). I want the storage replicated geo-redunduntly backed-up and safer, Glacier/Backblaze/etc-style, not just lost whenever someone breaks into the server or there's a hardware issue at the hosting company, etc. Basically "upload and forget"... Same way, I can't find any good Squarespace/Ghost/Wordpress.com style service where I can run 3-4 sites that's not like $10/month per site or so... I'd appreciate a service that charges you based on actual traffic load, not mere website count/custom domain, and that is "post content and forget".
- mixcocam 6y agoAre there any options like these with redundancy built into the storage?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- OJFord 6y agoIt's a proxy for usage that fairly non-technical consumers can understand. > It'd be like charging for windows-up or windows-down on a taxi ride. Or like charging for time or distance travelled, when the 'real cost' is fuel?
- part1of2 6y ago>> essentially free Well Google is going to charge you $240 annually for a TB of storage now.
- mrep 6y agoWhere? I see $10 a month or $100 a year prepaid for 2 TB: https://one.google.com/u/1/storage https://one.google.com/u/1/storage
- mehrdadn 6y agoWhere does this meme of "storage is essentially free" come from? A 4TB drive is already like ~$100 and that's without any fault tolerance. Now purchase some for yourself, geo-replicate it across the world, make it be online 24/7 and accessible with high speed worldwide, and tell me how it came out to be "essentially free"?
- rq1 6y agoMarginal cost. You don't build one network per drive. I wouldn't personally say "essentially free" though.
- mehrdadn 6y agoThe network was hardly the culprit in my explanation. How much is the cost of 4TB of georeplicated storage do you think? Surely you have to at least pay for the storage itself? So like $300-$400 at least if it's replicated 3-4x? And I haven't even hinted at offline backups and all kinds of other things.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoThat sounds deliberately dense. Understand what marginal cost is. A megabyte of storage used to cost $1000. Today it costs $400 / 1,000,000. To store a photo is not a penny. Its some percents of a penny. You wouldn't bend over to pick it up on the street.
- mehrdadn 6y ago> To store a photo is not a penny. Its some percents of a penny. You wouldn't bend over to pick it up on the street. You're storing 1 photo (like 3MB)?? Or like thousands/millions? Give me an estimate for how much you think 4TB of replicated storage costs if you think I overestimated?
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoFor Google? A small fraction of what you guessed, in bulk.
- mywacaday 6y agoMaybe close to free on a per bit basis but I guess electricity, bandwidth, redundancy etc aren't. Photos is one of the products I'm actually happy to pay for extra storage. €100 buys my 2TB of storage that I can share with my wife and my kids when they are old enough. Knowing that any pic I snap is backed up is worth the cost, photographs are one of the few things that are truly irreplaceable. Saying that based on advice from other threads I'll be doing a regular download from takeout.google.xom
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoYeah they're nearly free too. For a photo, some invisible fraction of a penny per year. We're being marketed storage by features, not by the cost of the thing. And in an efficient market in a sane world, that should drop to nearly free.
- jonplackett 6y agoThose data centres just build themselves, right?
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoOne data center for 1B people? Yes, per person. Folks, try to understand marginal cost. Its a tiny number per person now, and plummeting.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Folks, try to understand marginal cost. 'Marginal cost' doesn't work like you think it does. Marginal cost means the cost for adding one new user. But they aren't paying to add one new user. They're paying for all users. If each user's storage cost 1 dollar a month then yeah adding an individual new user is basically free. But if they're supporting 100 million users then it's a hundred million dollars a month. Which isn't free. If you still don't quite get it - try this thought experiment. If storage is free then could you afford to set up a storage data centre? If not, why not? It's free after all, in your mind.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoThey're not charging a dollar. That's my point. They're raising their prices, while storage costs fall. Lets try not to choose the most uncharitable interpretation. That's actually in the site guidlines.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Lets try not to choose the most uncharitable interpretation. I agreee! I think my argument is the most charitable. 'It costs money to store things. They're asking you to pay for it'. Seems most charitable, reasonable, and simplest explanation. Your interpretation is 'each byte costs nothing so a hundred million dollar data centre also costs nothing' which is an uncharitable interpretation of what they're doing. At the end of the day 'storing a billion photos is free' - your argument - is simply a provably false statement, as everyone in these threads keeps trying to explain to you.
- pfortuny 6y agoThe price of storage is the price of maintenance not of storing.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoWhich, since its largely automated, is also essentially free.
- non-nil 6y ago>Storage is growing faster than humanity can fill it Maybe, though I'm not sure it's without breaking a sweat. Also, someone is most definitely footing some rather large bills. According to this blog post[0] the amount of data uploaded each day is over 4 petabytes. For Drive, Photos and Docs only, i.e. it doesn't even include YouTube. [0]https://blog.google/products/photos/storage-policy-update/ https://blog.google/products/photos/storage-policy-update/