3 ms·
This is only true if you don’t use GitHub for reviews/issue tracking/etc. You’re correct that it’s trivial to move the code, but that’s only a fraction of the c
by kortilla 6y ago
This is only true if you don’t use GitHub for reviews/issue tracking/etc. You’re correct that it’s trivial to move the code, but that’s only a fraction of the critical history and tooling for a large collaborative project.
- Macha 6y agoMany of the projects that are on github were once on Google Code and migrated over issues.
- acoard 6y agoTrue, but I've seen many projects that use both GitHub and JIRA (i.e. not BitBucket). Those work totally fine for issue tracking, project management, etc. It's the same amount of friction for what you're proposing. The main thing you are missing out on is a UI for merging and PRs, which is nontrivial but not a moat that can keep a monopoly afloat. Of course if JIRA shut down that'd be annoying too, but I could re-create my project in another project manager. To me, the bigger impact is things like GitHub Actions and your CI/CD pipeline. Issue tracking and PRs don't seem like big issues to me.
- gspr 6y ago> To me, the bigger impact is things like GitHub Actions and your CI/CD pipeline. Sure, and these are definitely important – but your project isn't directly threatened if they are pulled out from under you. You'll just be operating with degraded CI quality for a while.
- grayhatter 6y agoI get emails for all comments and PRs. It would be annoying to lose the GH interface but not repo ending. Allowing issues or pulls to exist only on GH is equivalent to having only a single copy of a something important on an old laptop. Basic backups of any kind solves this issue.
- bradly 6y agoI believe iTerm uses GitLab for issues and GitHub for source control. GitHub issues didn't have a core feature they needed issues, but it was already canonical for code.
- 8note 6y agoIt feels like there's a missing product to go with git: a free and distributed issue management and review system. GitHub should be a view on the data rather than the sole owner of the data
- gaius_baltar 6y agoThere is git-bug ( https://github.com/MichaelMure/git-bug https://github.com/MichaelMure/git-bug ). Not at the same level as Bugzilla, but usable. Issues are stored in hidden branches in the git repo itself.