4 ms·
As with most technical challenges, scale is always an issue. Depopulating a city is relatively easy and achievable with conventional bombs. A small country wou
by ineedasername 6y ago
As with most technical challenges, scale is always an issue.
Depopulating a city is relatively easy and achievable with conventional bombs. A small country would only be moderately more difficult with nuclear weapons. After this, things get much harder.
Sure, enough nukes could finish off the human race, but that's out of the price range for most shoppers in this market. In the long term, climate change might do it, but who's got that sort of time? You're probably left with something like a biological agent, a pathogen of some sort, and still run the risk of pockets of people hiding away or being immune. Still, let's say you did it, it worked, humans are gone. Yay! You destroyed the world! Right?
No. You extinguished one species. You have a long way to go on the entire world.
So you put your mind to it. Defoliation agents for the plants, the cast of Deadliest Catch to get the crabs (you planned ahead and saved them from the nuclear fallout), a few billion tons of boric acid for the roaches-- get it all covered. Yay, party time?
Again, no. If you were meticulously thorough, you killed all life, but really the project has just begun. Everything is dead, but it's all still here. The Earth is still here. And if you thought rooting out the last extremophiles was hard work, you've never had to try & sweep 6 * 10^24 kg of mass under the rug.
Do you break it up? Is that enough? Technically it's still there and if you leave it it will all just accrete back together. So maybe you decide to push it into the Sun, either piece by piece or all at once, depending on on your level of godhood.
Finally, you can relax. Cut yourself a nice piece of "I destroyed the world" cake. Have a beer... ... ... Ehh, maybe don't eat the cake or drink the beer. You didn't really destroy the world, of it's matter sti exists. It's not gone, it's just molten.
So no cake for you. In fact, it will be a long long time before you see any cake coming your way.
- Cthulhu_ 6y ago> Sure, enough nukes could finish off the human race, but that's out of the price range for most shoppers in this market. I dunno, there's plenty of nukes that are ready and waiting and have been paid for. I wonder what would be more effective; nuking the targets that have been designated by various states already since the cold war, or piling up all the nukes, maybe a few km underground, and trigger a cataclysmic event (like a supervolcano as mentioned on the page). Re: climate change, they could accellerate the process a bit and nuke the north and south pole ice, maybe. Or spread a darkening agent on any exposed ice to increase heat absorption. But anyway, I don't think any of these would completely sterilize the earth, possibly only humanity and other large animals. To sterilize it, we need to get rid of the atmosphere and most of the earth's crust. I guess a big enough asteroid could do it (think moon-sized), something whose impact is so big it breaks up the whole ball.
- arethuza 6y agoA video on "what happens if we pile up all the nukes and set them off": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyECrGp-Sw8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyECrGp-Sw8
- noneeeed 6y agoAmazing :) I really should watch more of their videos, I'd forgotten how brilliant they are.
- arethuza 6y agoThey also do one on "what happens if a single modern nuclear weapon is exploded over a city" - but I think the BBC did a better job: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9GJttnC8PoA&t=16s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9GJttnC8PoA&t=16s [Edit: And by 'better job' I mean scared me witless as a teenager]
- noneeeed 6y agoOh wow, I'd forgotten all about Q.E.D. _Feels old_
- joshxyz 6y agoCant we just attach all nukes to one side of the moon, make it explode so hard that it pushes the moon toward the earth that it hits like a cool asteroid? Haha
- ineedasername 6y agoIt would take some reengineering but you could probably convert the nukes to directed-energy rockets, harnessing the full power of the blast & using part of the moon itself as reaction mass. The problem though is still the amount of energy needed: In short, too much. Ball park estimate place it at about 410^28 joules, and a large nuker only puts out about 410^15. The theory is still sound though, and could be modified: Drill down a hundred miles or so and put 90% of the nukes down the hole to blow a crater out. Take the largest chunks and the remaining 10% of the nukes and proceed as originally planned, but on a smaller scale. Bonus: The debris should also make its way to LEO and trigger a cascade of collisions that take out everything in orbit.
- nullsense 6y agoIn my head I read that as a monologue given by Rick from Rick and Morty. Made it very entertaining.
- cevi 6y agoReminds me very strongly of the opening lines of https://qntm.org/destroy https://qntm.org/destroy
- ineedasername 6y agoThat's fantastic! Clearly I'm not the only one that has listened to countless fictional villains claim they want to destroy the world while I think "No, you just want to kill people."