5 ms·
For most people, if there computer was ‘theirs’, it would be that way for about 10 minutes until it was pwned by a bad actor. The general issue of other people
by zepto 6y ago
For most people, if there computer was ‘theirs’, it would be that way for about 10 minutes until it was pwned by a bad actor.
The general issue of other people (I.e. Apple et al) having a lot of control over your computer, is entirely valid even if some of the points in the piece are exaggerations.
The problem is that people want it that way.
They are in fact correct that computers are scary and too complex for them to manage, and they want someone they can trust to do it for them.
Stallman may have predicted the issue, but he really didn’t do much to solve the real problems.
The presence of open software isn’t enough without a way for people to know what is trustworthy without being experts.
Until we provide that, this situation cannot change.
- sneak 6y ago> The presence of open software isn’t enough without a way for people to know what is trustworthy without being experts. As Apple has demonstrated, neither has the presence of closed software. Between Apple and Microsoft, they're nearly 100% likely to get software that is not trustworthy, and cannot be made so. This would be less worrisome if the state did not compel these organizations to provide their data to the military on demand without a warrant, but due to the vertical integration of big tech companies and US military spying, this becomes a major threat to our society and the basic exercise of civic participation. It's hard to do things like, for example, investigative reporting against corrupt government officials if the government officials know every time you open Premiere, and where you do it, because they forced your chip/OS manufacturer to tell them.
- zepto 6y agoFirstly - this is a false equivalence. Sure a government agency may be forcing Apple or MS to help them spy on you, just as they could have compromised whatever else you are using. But when you download software from at least the Apple App Store, you are in fact protected from many kinds of harmful software. Let’s not lie and pretend that isn’t a real benefit to many people, even though there are serious downsides to it. But even if you were right about the equivalence - what’s the point in the handwringing? There is no way out unless we build our way out. Shaking your fist at the man just isn’t going to do anything. The reason there is no alternative is that we haven’t solved the problems yet. People are in fact trying. Nothing you can say about Microsoft or Apple will make an alternative appear.
- JAlexoid 6y agoThe last hoax that I almost fell for was an ad in the Facebook app.
- zepto 6y agoSo what? That’s a nasty communication you chose to receive by installing ad supported software. It has nothing to do with security or really even computers.
- JAlexoid 6y agoThe sense of security is literally the reason why facebook ad hoaxes exist, nothing more. A claim that "buying Apple makes you safer" makes one less safe, due to perception of extra safety.
- damnencryption 6y ago> They are in fact correct that [insert anything] are scary and too complex for them to manage, and they want someone they can trust to do it for them Is this an argument for forced autonomous cars or stopping selling of knives because they are scary and you can cut yourself while cooking?
- zepto 6y agoWhy would you think that? I vehemently oppose government regulation of software distribution, precisely because otherwise we won’t be able to develop a true alternative. I don’t want people to be prevented from using dangerous tools such as sharp knives, or manual vehicles. But neither do I want them to be forced to take risks they don’t want to take.
- thotsBgone 6y agoForced autonomous cars: Yes, once they are good enough. We make people wear seat-belts. Same thing. Stopping selling of knives: Yes, once we have a safer way of cutting things. Though the real problem is probably people cutting each other on purpose, rather than themselves by accident.
- forest_dweller 6y ago> Forced autonomous cars: Yes, once they are good enough. We make people wear seat-belts. Same thing. Selt belt wearing is rarely enforced anywhere (especially in Europe, in Italy nobody wears one even though it is illegal). As for autonomous cars. If they ever work, one of the first mods people will do is to add a steering wheel. > Stopping selling of knives: Yes, once we have a safer way of cutting things. Knives are a safe way of cutting things. Billions of people use them everyday without issue. > Though the real problem is probably people cutting each other on purpose, rather than themselves by accident. How are you going to stop people from making knives? Humans have been making them for several 1000s of years, IIRC Chimps can make them now. In prisons they literally make shives out of toilet paper. In the UK carrying knives is banned and their sale is heavily restricted. However in our capital city we still have a lot of knife violence. Guns are also heavily restricted but people still have those illegally and people do get shot. My uncle is a convicted bank robber, he had plenty of guns. You are solving the wrong problem. You must solve the problem of why people are being violent to one another. That will actually make people safer.
- forest_dweller 6y agoThis is the same sort of logic that some people have that people shouldn't be allowed to make choices in life because they "might get it wrong". People should be allowed to make their own choices in what they believe to be their best interests and they should be allowed to get things wrong. > For most people, if there computer was ‘theirs’, it would be that way for about 10 minutes until it was pwned by a bad actor. This may have been true back in the early 2000s when people first had good broadband. However all the major operating systems have pretty decent security out of the box mainly due to the embarassment of events like MS Blaster Worm. > The general issue of other people (I.e. Apple et al) having a lot of control over your computer, is entirely valid even if some of the points in the piece are exaggerations. The problem is that if you buy a general purpose computing device. You should be able to run whatever you like on it. They should just have a button somewhere in whatever the equivalent of the BIOS on these machines is that says "I am an adult and I accept the risks of turning off these protections" and then let you install Temple OS if you so choose to. This is something that needs to be enforced by legal means IMO, something similar to right to repair. > The problem is that people want it that way. I don't know about that. They frequently get irritated by it and are just resigned to it IME. However the popularity of single board computers such as the Raspberry Pi, People building their own gaming rigs and people tinkering with gadgets goes someway in refuting this notion. There will be of course many people that just won't care and will use "iDevice" and that is fine, however there is a large spectrum between "I only run stuff from the app store" to "I run custom Arch Install with optimised kernel with tk kernel patches". > The presence of open software isn’t enough without a way for people to know what is trustworthy without being experts. I agree. This is a failing of the open source community. I've actually written a draft manifesto called "better than freedom". This may actually push me to at least have it critiqued by my friends. > Until we provide that, this situation cannot change. Something has to change. We are sliding back into the 1980s where all the computer hardware was incomptable with one another.
- ernst_klim 6y ago> People should be allowed to make their own choices in what they believe to be their best interests > You should be able to run whatever you like on it. You are contradicting yourself. People are explicitly choosing iphone, a walled garden. Then you say that that's a wrong choice because you believe it's a general purpose computing device and should work differently. If people buy it then, well, they are fine with it.
- bergstromm466 6y ago> The problem is that people want it that way. No, the real story here is that Corporations in the USA, and other Global North countries, have both 1) benefited from state/taxpayer-funded subsidies, grants, and research, and 2) are now locking up and monopolizing these discoveries using the international TRIPS system, 'claiming' Patents and Copyrights, 'kicking away the ladder': "How did the rich countries really become rich? In this provocative study, Ha-Joon Chang examines the great pressure on developing countries from the developed world to adopt certain 'good policies' and 'good institutions', seen today as necessary for economic development. Adopting a historical approach, Dr Chang finds that the economic evolution of now-developed countries differed dramatically from the procedures that they now recommend to poorer nations. His conclusions are compelling and disturbing: that developed countries are attempting to 'kick away the ladder' with which they have climbed to the top, thereby preventing developing counties from adopting policies and institutions that they themselves have used." + “Rich countries have ‘kicked away the ladder’ by forcing free-market, free-trade policies on poor countries. Already established countries do not want more competitors emerging through the nationalistic policies they themselves successfully used in the past.” [1] Professor Yash Tandon adds: “During the 1980s and 1990s I worked in many countries in eastern and southern Africa, and then for four years at the South Centre—2005–09. I can say from my experience that the industrialised countries of the North have been trying systematically to block all efforts by the countries of the South to industrialise. Their mega-corporations have tried—and, alas, succeeded—in privatising knowledge, and using it to promote corporate profits over the lives of people." [...] “It is the seeds and pharmaceutical companies of the West that have pirated the knowledge of seeds and medicinal products from the South. But whereas in the South this knowledge was shared as a public asset, the Western companies, having learnt from the South, proceeded to claim it as their private property. They are guilty—morally guilty—for the avoidable deaths of millions of people in the South who cannot afford their ‘patented’ medicines against, for example, AIDS, malaria, tuberculosis and other killer diseases. It is a sordid story. But it is not all doom and gloom. Those who control the system (the global corporations and the international organisations that the West controls) do not get their own way entirely. Wars do not always end in the victory of the militarily or ‘intellectually’ powerful.” [2] All of this then comes together through Tech's Great-Man theory, that has us idolizing those monopolizers: "In the movie Steve Jobs, a character asks, “So how come 10 times in a day I read ‘Steve Jobs is a genius?’” The great man reputation that envelops Jobs is just part of a larger mythology of the role that Silicon Valley, and indeed the entire U.S. private sector, has played in technology innovation. We idolize tech entrepreneurs like Jobs, and credit them for most of the growth in our economy. But University of Sussex economist Mariana Mazzucato, who has just published a new U.S. edition of her book, The Entrepreneurial State: Debunking Public vs. Private Sector Myths, makes a timely argument that it is the government, not venture capitalists and tech visionaries, that have been heroic. “Every major technological change in recent years traces most of its funding back to the state,” says Mazzucato. Even “early stage” private-sector VCs come in much later, after the big breakthroughs have been made. For example, she notes, “The National Institutes of Health have spent almost a trillion dollars since their founding on the research that created both the pharmaceutical and the biotech sectors–with venture capitalists only entering biotech once the red carpet was laid down in the 1980s. We pretend that the government was at best just in the background creating the basic conditions (skills, infrastructure, basic science). But the truth is that the involvement required massive risk taking along the entire innovation chain: basic research, applied research and early stage financing of companies themselves.” The Silicon Valley VC model, which has typically dictated that financiers exit within 5 years or so, simply isn’t patient enough to create game changing innovation." [3] [1] https://anthempress.com/kicking-away-the-ladder-pb https://anthempress.com/kicking-away-the-ladder-pb [2] https://www.orbooks.com/catalog/trade-war-yash-tandon-2nd-ed/ https://www.orbooks.com/catalog/trade-war-yash-tandon-2nd-ed... [3] https://time.com/4089171/mariana-mazzucato/ https://time.com/4089171/mariana-mazzucato/
- protoman3000 6y ago> For most people, if there computer was ‘theirs’, it would be that way for about 10 minutes until it was pwned by a bad actor. I remember very well the times where when you’d connect a fresh Windows XP SP2 to the internet without a router or firewall it immediately showed malicious popups and eventually a BSOD.
- crististm 6y ago"Stallman [...] really didn’t do much to solve the real problems" - I beg your pardon but when was he appointed with this responsibility?
- drummer 6y agoBesides, he actually did A LOT. The problem is, the general sheep won't listen to him anyway. "The choice for mankind lies between freedom and happiness and for the great bulk of mankind, happiness is better." -- George Orwell, 1984
- aydwi 6y ago> For most people, if there computer was ‘theirs’, it would be that way for about 10 minutes until it was pwned by a bad actor. I own a company which manufactures and sells showerheads. Since "most" people are prone to a fall while taking a shower, my company also mandatorily installs a camera alongside, so that we can monitor for accidents, given our deep concern for our customers. "Some" customers have raised concerns about their privacy, but this is for the greater good. My company is very ethical in its practices, and really values each customer's privacy (pinky promise). The footage of you and your loved ones showering is completely safe with us, although you can choose not to be recorded while showering by not purchasing our products. Oh by the way, our showerheads are sleeker and more convenient than anything else in the market.
- superkuh 6y agoFeudal lords protected their serfs too.