3 ms·
You’re making a valid point but it ignores the historical context that as a group this work is shouldered on women, is extremely undervalued, and puts women in
by Spivak 6y ago
You’re making a valid point but it ignores the historical context that as a group this work is shouldered on women, is extremely undervalued, and puts women in an extremely vulnerable position. I can’t explain it any better than Elizabeth Warren in The Double Income Trap. The entire book talks about women as the social safety net and the really shitty dynamics at play. There also has to be some care to treat separately the class of women from individual women. Since we’re on HN class Woman != Set<Woman>.
This doesn’t imply that no men take on this role or feel pressured to. And it doesn’t imply that literally all women do either. Nor does it imply that our patriarchal system doesn’t do serious harm to men in the ways you described and more.
Footnotes:
* The US has domestic violence laws. Like almost all criminal code they exist at the state level.
* Law enforcement absolutely does not ignore domestic violence against men. They ignore domestic violence entirely! Even with the act! The story of police not taking the claims seriously and one, leaving them with their abuser and two, removing the threat of police involvement as a deterrent to that abuse happens again and again.
* I’m not at all offended as a gay women because I know this article isn’t about me as an individual but about a complex social dynamic that the case studies serve as examples of.
- woofie11 6y agoThe solution to sexism isn't sexism. There's a bizarre belief in some darker corners of feminism that if a group is disadvantaged, you want to address that by advantaging them in other ways, rather than by pushing for equality. There are times for that, but that's the exception, not the rule. 1) It perpetuates or changes the problem, but it doesn't fix it. It's not too dissimilar from gender relations in Islam or Mormonism, where you try to compensate from giving men power by placing women on a pedestal, and giving them protections. It's not effective. 2) It makes a lot of potential allies into enemies too. I'm pretty convinced Trump beat Clinton because of divorced dads, and some particularly sexist comments she made. Divorced dads make up a big portion of the electorate, are a disadvantaged population, and have private support groups. They hated Trumps sexism and racism, but hated Clinton's sexism too, and won't vote against their own interests. I'll mention many of those same dads supported Warren in the primary, who is a far more effective feminist than Clinton (actually, a far more effective everything), in part because she's a feminist and NOT a sexist, where Clinton was a sexist but not much of a feminist. I can see the case for things like affirmative action, where there is no other solution, but in this case, the point could have been made just as well, if not better, if the articles didn't talk about husbands and wives but used neutral language. If you make it gendered, you get into a gender/race/ethnicity war. If you make it neutral, everyone gets behind you, but the same change comes out the other end. Actually, usually a better change, since it treats people as equal individuals, and removes a systemic barrier that disproportionately impacts some, rather than as stereotypes. Footnotes: * Many state laws are named in gendered terms as well. VAWA in abstract applies to both genders, but doesn't in practice. It perpetuates the stereotype that violence against men is uncommon. It turns out that physical abuse is similar in both directions. There's a perception that it's a 99/1 split, but it's more like a 60/40 split. Women are somewhat more likely to be seriously injured, due to size/strength differences, but even that's not as extreme as made out. A knife, bat, or frying pan overcomes a lot of those differences. In most cases (in both directions) the partner doesn't fight back. The studies to look at are broad surveys (researcher calls thousands of people, and asks structured questions). * There are studies on police response too. In the best study I saw, literally zero domestic violence calls placed by men led to resolution, and in 12% of cases, the male victim was arrested themselves. Women didn't have a perfect success rate, but it was far better.