3 ms·
> That's why a defensive missile shield technology is not a good investment if you want more peace. That depends on whether you go for a 'weak' shield or a 'st
by throw0101a 6y ago
> That's why a defensive missile shield technology is not a good investment if you want more peace.
That depends on whether you go for a 'weak' shield or a 'strong' shield. A weak shield may defend a dozen or two warheads: something that North Korea would launch. Japan has a 'weak' shield AFAICT:
* https://www.rand.org/pubs/monograph_reports/MR1374.html https://www.rand.org/pubs/monograph_reports/MR1374.html
A strong one would protect against hundreds: another major power. IMHO only the latter would destabilize peace, while the former would help defend agains crazies and potentially rogue operations.
> The existing MAD mantra is what stops nuclear war.
There are a bunch of criticism of MAD:
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutual_assured_destruction#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutual_assured_destruction#Cri...
- usrusr 6y agoBut weak shields are only not destabilizing as long as there is complete awareness of its weak nature. Forms of reality denial are standard mode of operations in politics and good luck finding a war that didn't start with one form or another of reality denial. On a tangent that doesn't really change ether we find weak shields bothersome or not: arguably all strong shield projects were just weak shields with reality denial built right into the sales pitch.
- tachyonbeam 6y agoAFAIK anti-missile shields aren't a realistic option. Modern ICBM designs have multiple independently targetable warheads. There are also submarines with nuclear missiles. You can also launch decoys (eg: aluminium foil or flares). And uh. Recently, I was reading a book called Skunk Works. The author explains that, basically, the US was able to keep the existence of stealth fighters a secret from the public (and Russia) for years and years. He also mentions the idea of a stealth ICBM multiple times in the book (which was published in 1995). That's when it hit me. That technology already exists. Russia and the US probably have an arsenal of stealth ICBMs. They're just not publicly boasting about it, but if you think about it, there's no reason that technology wouldn't exist, particularly since military contractors were already thinking about it over 25 years ago.
- taneq 6y agoI don't understand why you would keep such a thing secret. As Dr. Strangelove rightly pointed out, a doomsday device is pointless if nobody knows about it.
- baybal2 6y agoHaving just any weapon is worth keeping a secret. From the moment you have a weapon, and an enemy, the later will try to disarm you.
- taneq 6y agoNot 'worth keeping a secret' - worth controlling the information revealed about it. In the case of nuclear weapons, you want to keep its weaknesses and fallibilities secret while trumpeting its existence from the rooftops. The more parties know you have a mega-weapon, the lower the chance you'll have to use it.
- baybal2 6y ago> The more parties know you have a mega-weapon, the lower the chance you'll have to use it. But if you have to... the lower you have a chance to win, as the enemy with more than 1 gram of gray matter will do just anything to take it down before you can shoot. Betting all of your strategy on assumption that the enemy is scared enough of you not to attack is stupidity beyond all bounds. If you attack someone, especially if you attack somebody stronger than you, then you attack with all force available to you, and maximum ferocity. You assume the enemy will willingly throw away his biggest chance to take away your biggest force multiplier, and the biggest chance to win?
- taneq 6y ago> If you attack someone, especially if you attack somebody stronger than you, then you attack with all force available to you, and maximum ferocity. True, IF you attack someone. But if you see someone who is unassailably stronger than you, that you couldn't possibly defeat, then you don't even go there. And that is the point of MAD. An enemy with one nuke is scary, scary enough to make them worth attacking. But an enemy with thousands of nukes, scattered across the globe, in unknown locations, which will launch at their signal (or lack of signal)... You just don't attack them.