3 ms·
> As a non-American it always surprises me how much American's look for the past for guidance in the democracy and government. We're not looking to the past fo
by pdonis 6y ago
> As a non-American it always surprises me how much American's look for the past for guidance in the democracy and government.
We're not looking to the past for guidance. We're looking at what the Constitution says because it is still the supreme law of the land. People who think some provision of that supreme law of the land should be changed can propose amendments; the US Constitution has already been amended 27 times. But you're not supposed to just pretend that the law doesn't apply because you don't like what it says.
> All that was a long time ago and things have evolved.
And the US Constitution has been amended where necessary to take that into account. We amended the Constitution to abolish slavery, to give women the right to vote, to have Senators elected by the people of their states instead of the legislatures, to eliminate poll taxes, to limit how many terms a President can serve. And we can continue to amend the Constitution where necessary to fix other issues. That is how people who want to take Justice Ginsburg's advice and take advantage of advances other countries have made should do that.
- ceejayoz 6y agoI don't think the Founders necessarily expected it to become so difficult to amend things. The most recent Amendment took 202 years to ratify, and that was nearly 30 years ago, and it was a minor tinkering with how Congressional salaries work. You have to go back another 20 years to the next one.
- pdonis 6y ago> I don't think the Founders necessarily expected it to become so difficult to amend things. It isn't difficult if you have general agreement that a particular amendment is needed. What makes it seem difficult to get passage of particular amendments that particular special interest groups have proposed is that there is not general agreement that they are needed. And in that situation, the amendment should not be passed--and that's exactly how the Founders set things up. That's why they required a two-thirds vote in each house of Congress to send an amendment to the States for ratification, and three-fourths of the States to ratify it in order to have it in force. > The most recent Amendment took 202 years to ratify That was an anomaly; no other amendment has taken anything close to that long. And that particular one probably could have been passed sooner, except that once it got left out of the original Bill of Rights, it was forgotten.
- godelski 6y ago> The most recent Amendment took 202 years to ratify, and that was nearly 30 years ago This is a deceptive picture to paint. That amendment was an outlier in respect. There are only 3/27 amendments that took more than 3 years to pass and 2 of them were passed faster than 4 years. The mean is 8.94 years and if you remove the 27th the average was 1.44 years. We also have an average of 8.2 years between the amendments (counting from 1789).
- ceejayoz 6y ago> We also have an average of 8.2 years between the amendments (counting from 1789). This reinforces my point. The last meaningful amendment (the 27th affecting only a couple hundred people, after all) was in 1971, and I suspect quite a few of the amendments in the 60s/70s would have a tremendously uphill battle if on the table in today's political climate.
- godelski 6y agoYour point might be that we're currently in an outlying situation, but that's not quite what you said and you used a deceptive data point to make that point. One could attribute our current outlying behavior to the strange debate of "living vs static document" that is being had (weird because we literally have the federalist papers and notes on what the founders wanted so it doesn't make sense to argue "what the founders thought" without looking at said documents). The point here is that your comment implies that that amendments are few and far between and you used an outlier to make that point. That statement was woefully misleading. Which frankly isn't going to fly on HN.
- pdonis 6y ago> I suspect quite a few of the amendments in the 60s/70s would have a tremendously uphill battle if on the table in today's political climate. Which ones?
- ceejayoz 6y agoAny of them, frankly. Even "Should the US default on its debt via the debt ceiling" became a political football in the last few years. The 23rd, 24th, and 26th amendments would all likely meet strong Republican opposition if proposed today.
- brightball 6y agoI believe they did. There is no unity in force. There is unity in cooperation and mutual agreement. When 51% want something, it shouldn’t be so. It should necessarily require more buy in. That’s precisely why the states were largely expected to govern themselves with federal power being less extreme. The divide that we see in the country today is caused by two sides trying to force their way on each other rather than allowing states to just...disagree. We’d all be a lot better off if our states ran the way we wanted and simply turned our nose up and joked about the ones we didn’t agree with, than trying to constantly force those other states to do things our way.
- pksebben 6y agothe shared burden of infrastructure makes that problematic. A huge chunk of the country would collapse if it didn't have the ability to externalize cost to other states, and taxing the coasts without representing their needs in the budget would kind of, like, be counter to the point, no?
- brightball 6y agoThat seems like something that could gather a 2/3 vote.
- johnwallz 6y agoWell said! I agree 100%. When we look back to the Founders this is what we're talking about. A multi-layered Federal Republic without strong centralization. Centralization is what Progressives have been pushing on us bit by bit for 100 years and look at the mess we're in now. Every regime change in the Whitehouse pisses off 50% of the country. We're a large country with 50 independent states of differing geographies and political philosophies that s/b largely governing themselves. We're not a small country like Sweden. Why can't we have progressive states like CA and conservative states like TX. If CA wants healthcare they can implement it themselves and if TX doesn't then they don't have to do it for themselves. CA is the 5th largest economy in the world on their own. They dont need DC. I'm a conservative who crossed the border from MA into the Live Free or Die state of NH. Why do Progressives want to hammer a one size fits all solution down to all states from DC and ruin our freedoms like that?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- justin66 6y ago> We're not looking to the past for guidance. We're looking at what the Constitution says because it is still the supreme law of the land. When we discuss the Federalist Papers and the Anti-Federalist Papers, we are looking to the past for guidance.
- UncleMeat 6y agoDisagree. Every single time I end up I a discussion about the electoral college it returns to “the founders knew what they were doing.” There is absolutely a reverence for the popular perception of the founders and the idea that it were possible for them to be completely wrong is just not viable in the discourse today.