5 ms·
As a non-American it always surprises me how much American's look for the past for guidance in the democracy and government. America was one of the first moder
by nabla9 6y ago
As a non-American it always surprises me how much American's look for the past for guidance in the democracy and government. America was one of the first modern democracies, and people who wrote the constitution were the bleeding edge. All that was a long time ago and things have evolved.
Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Jan. 30, 2012:
>You should certainly be aided by all the constitution writing that has gone on since the end of World War II. I would not look to the U.S. Constitution if I were drafting a constitution in the year 2012. I might look at the constitution of South Africa — that was a deliberate attempt to have a fundamental instrument of government that embraced basic human rights, had an independent judiciary. It really is, I think, a great piece of work that was done. Much more recently than the U.S. Constitution, Canada has the Charter of Rights and Freedoms — dates from 1982. You would almost certainly look at the European Convention on Human Rights. So, yes, why not take advantage of what there is elsewhere in the world?
- DudeInBasement 6y agoAmerica has never been a democracy. It amazes me that people think we are smarter now, than we were then. We are just surrounded with technology.
- ceejayoz 6y agoWe don't have to be smarter to learn from historical stuff that happened. My IQ doesn't go up any when I burn myself on a hot stove, but I certainly learn something.
- amalcon 6y agoThe way these things are taught in history class is pretty weird, and goes a long way toward explaining this. The Connecticut Compromise is a great example. You're taught that the large states wanted representation in proportion to population, and the small states wanted states to be represented identically (regardless of population), for obvious reasons. So, they decided to split the difference, making one house proportional and the other population-independent. While they did this because it was the only thing they could get agreement on, it was also the greatest civic invention since democracy itself... by coincidence, I guess? Yeah, it's pretty weird.
- pdonis 6y ago> it was also the greatest civic invention since democracy itself... I wasn't taught that in history class. I was just taught the facts you described: that the compromise was made because it was the only way to get agreement at the convention on how the national legislature should be organized.
- amalcon 6y agoWell, my memory is decades out of date and from a low-population state. Still, I remember spending a lot of time on how smart this was and how well it's worked. "Greatest civic invention since democracy itself" was a bit of hyperbole, but there was definitely a lot of emphasis on how good the compromise was.
- pdonis 6y agoI expect it varies by when and where you went to school.
- falcor84 6y ago>the greatest civic invention since democracy itself According to what parameter? Is there any objective manner in which bicameral parliaments fare better than unicameral ones?
- WalterBright 6y agoI'd say stability. The various checks and balances make it difficult for any radical change from getting through, even if the majority wants it.
- ip26 6y agoStaying power? Obtaining & maintaining consent of the governed being one of the most critical features of a representative government.
- bigger_cheese 6y agoI am fairly ignorant about US political system. Doesn't the idea of having two separate houses come from British Westminster system? The Westminster system is supposedly the basis for my country (Australia's) parliament but I believe we also have taken influences from other systems and have incorporated some things that aren't common anywhere else (like compulsory voting) our constitution comes from 1901. I could be wrong, but I think the main difference Between US system and ours is how the leader is appointed. The US directly votes for president, where as here the winning party (Based on number of Lower House seats won) appoints the leader. Our Prime Minister is much more beholden to the party he belongs to where in US presidents gets to Veto stuff - I think.
- pdonis 6y ago> As a non-American it always surprises me how much American's look for the past for guidance in the democracy and government. We're not looking to the past for guidance. We're looking at what the Constitution says because it is still the supreme law of the land. People who think some provision of that supreme law of the land should be changed can propose amendments; the US Constitution has already been amended 27 times. But you're not supposed to just pretend that the law doesn't apply because you don't like what it says. > All that was a long time ago and things have evolved. And the US Constitution has been amended where necessary to take that into account. We amended the Constitution to abolish slavery, to give women the right to vote, to have Senators elected by the people of their states instead of the legislatures, to eliminate poll taxes, to limit how many terms a President can serve. And we can continue to amend the Constitution where necessary to fix other issues. That is how people who want to take Justice Ginsburg's advice and take advantage of advances other countries have made should do that.
- ceejayoz 6y agoI don't think the Founders necessarily expected it to become so difficult to amend things. The most recent Amendment took 202 years to ratify, and that was nearly 30 years ago, and it was a minor tinkering with how Congressional salaries work. You have to go back another 20 years to the next one.
- pdonis 6y ago> I don't think the Founders necessarily expected it to become so difficult to amend things. It isn't difficult if you have general agreement that a particular amendment is needed. What makes it seem difficult to get passage of particular amendments that particular special interest groups have proposed is that there is not general agreement that they are needed. And in that situation, the amendment should not be passed--and that's exactly how the Founders set things up. That's why they required a two-thirds vote in each house of Congress to send an amendment to the States for ratification, and three-fourths of the States to ratify it in order to have it in force. > The most recent Amendment took 202 years to ratify That was an anomaly; no other amendment has taken anything close to that long. And that particular one probably could have been passed sooner, except that once it got left out of the original Bill of Rights, it was forgotten.
- CapitalistCartr 6y agoThe judiciary's role is to interpret and apply the law, not to legislate or rewrite it. We aren't looking to the past, but to the law, and the context surrounding it's writing so as to understand it. Of course laws are written in the past, but that's incidental. Many countries have lots of interesting ideas; that's up to the legislative branch to be informed by, and perhaps copy. For the judicial branch to do otherwise would invalidate a rule of law, and the separation of powers. While interpretation of law evolves, it can't be rewritten because a judge (or judges) liked something another country did. If the legislative branch wishes to amend The Constitution, there is a procedure for that, including a wholesale rewriting of it (Constitutional Convention). We've amended it via 27 amendments, substantially altering its structure.
- tikhonj 6y agoThere's a practical lesson here: in contentious areas like politics, having a standard everyone agrees on—even if they don't agree on interpretation—is valuable in and of itself. The Constitution and its surrounding documents are foundational simply because they're foundational, not because they are the final word on political philosophy or practical governance. The Constitution just has to be good enough to supply a floor for the quality of a government that has any pretense of following it and, for the past few hundred years, it's done the job well enough to survive despite some fundamental failings. And in practice, whatever anybody says, the interpretation of the Constitution has evolved massively over the country's history, even along supposedly originalist views. The most important ideas in the Constitution—say, the First Amendment—are intentionally under-specified; the full meaning of the First Amendment is not in its 45 words but in centuries of legal scholarship and judicial precedent. While the Amendment itself has a couple of centuries under its belt, its practical manifestation in American legal practice is at least as sophisticated and modern as anywhere else.
- drawkbox 6y agoJames Madison "Father of the Constitution" wrote the Constitution, Bill of Rights and co-wrote of the Federalist papers has a great insight in Federalist 10: > It is in vain to say that enlightened statesmen will be able to adjust these clashing interests, and render them all subservient to the public good. Enlightened statesmen will not always be at the helm. Nor, in many cases, can such an adjustment be made at all without taking into view indirect and remote considerations, which will rarely prevail over the immediate interest which one party may find in disregarding the rights of another or the good of the whole. The reason why people look to the founding papers and value them is because they are breaking away from tyranny, greed, monarchy, almost mafia state like control. They have interesting takes that are true in any power grab and warnings. You can't write a Constitution as good as when you just went through revolution from tyranny. That is what changing it like the push for a Convention of States is trying to do is a dangerous thing while so divided. We are in a state of uncivil war, not unity over an external enemy, though maybe we should be. The United States has the longest running form of government, I'd say it was architected pretty well. The Constitution is a good guide for setting up a system that allows depressurization. Western liberalized democratic republics allow for depressurization and waves and cycles to flow, some intense, some wonderful, some problematic, but return or escape from those eras. Authoritarianism does not, eventually authoritarianism blows up when the loyalty and leverage break down, there is no pressure release.
- ceejayoz 6y ago> The United States has the longest running form of government The Vatican is likely to disagree.
- Majromax 6y ago> The United States has the longest running form of government, I'd say it was architected pretty well. The Constitution is a good guide for setting up a system that allows depressurization. The US Civil War (1861-1865) called, it would like to have a discussion about "depressurization." The founding writings are fine examples of political philosophy, but the government that we have today in any western liberal democracy would be alien to those authors. The United States today has a government informed by its constitution of 230 years ago, but it is equally informed by a long history of profound social change and (at times) bloodshed. The document of the 1780s can inspire, but there are better models to imitate if need be.
- zajio1am 6y agoThe interesting part here is that there is a record of public discourse that lead to the US Constitution. So you do not see just the product, but also the process that preceded it. Also note that people do not just write constitution to satisfy their ideal image of constitution, they need to write such constitution that would be accepted by many citizens with differing ideas and goals. Especially when it is not a constitution of a unitary state, but federation. Last time we tried something similar, we ended with Treaty of Lisbon.
- arminiusreturns 6y agoThis view frustrates me because it ignores what the founders based the constitution on, namely, the history of governments across the world and philosophical underpinnings of the enlightenment and renaissance that enabled them. Madison in particular studied such a wide array of topics in his forumaltion of proposed systems that hardly anyone I know of even today could even come close in understanding the big picture view he did due to that study. Ask any modern politician about what philsopher was the main originator of the checks and balances system and I bet almost none of them would even know Montesquieu's name, much less have read him. The same for the people who then talk about the contitution as being some outdated document of rich slave owners that should be completely rewritten. It's just become a trope narrative to me that gets tiring to hear from those who love to pontificate on the subject without being more informed. As for non-Americans, I think those foundational principles, if not the constitution itself, should be valued just as much elsewhere as they are in America (in theory at least). Perhaps I have a too naively positive a view of the extent of liberal education in Europe and elsewhere. As Christopher Hitchens said: "The American Revolution, the one that says, build your public on individual rights, not group rights, have a bill of rights that inscribes these and makes theme legible to everybody, separate the church from the state, separate the executive from the judicial, and the political branch. Do all these things; It doesn't sound like much but it's really a very revolutionary idea. There is hardly a country in the world that wouldn't benefit from adopting those principles. I think that gives the United States a really good claim to be a revolutionary country as well as of course, paradoxically a very conservative one."
- kls 6y agoI agree, they started with a confederation and ended up with a republic realizing while a confederation was ideal, it would not survive. Now in saying that, we do have to take into account the times. For example the separation of church and state, they really could not event envision in their time, that the government should have never been involved in the marriage issue in the first place as it is a religious institution. The government has a legal process for a group working as an entity and that is either a corporation or a trust. From the onset families and their legal rights should have been an inherent trust. This would have kept the religious dogma out of the gay marriage argument and left it to the denominations as to whether they want to sanction the ceremony of marriage or not. Obviously slavery would be another issue, but again I see that as the times, as the people believed that a particular race was less than human. This was corrected via amendments but I don't think a different form of government, at the time, would have reached a more humanitarian conclusion. So we don't really get to ding the republic for it. The problem I have is that the republic works very well, history is littered with the successes of the republic in offering prosperity to its people. The issue is that the republic by its very nature tends to generally gives way to empires. What we have now is an empire, it, in no way shape or form, resembles the original republic, with the exception of vestiges. so it is irksome to hear people lament the foundation as bad or not sufficient and utilize present day examples to do so. The American republic has been gone for a long time. The railroad barons chipped away at it, citizens united chipped away at it, the move to push more and more to the federal level chipped away at it and much, much more, to the extent that we no longer remotely resemble the foundational republic. The prescription is not to fundamentally change what we where, rather it is to take lessons learned and apply them to getting back to a true republic, with fixes to that original model. That is what the founders did, the studied Rome, they studied Greece and tried to account for the failings that they suffered and what allowed them to slide towards the empire and tyranny.
- viburnum 6y agoIt’s crazy, the people who wrote the constitution overturned a constitution that was only about a decade old. They certainly weren’t hung up on what Henry VIII had intended 250 years earlier.
- xwowsersx 6y agoRBG's basic idea is 1) the Constitution is dated and 2) that there are newer ideas we can glean from. Firstly, at least as read one way, the first assertion is highly debatable because the principles of limited government, the checking of abuses and preventing tyranny through a careful system of checks and balances, the independence of the judiciary, the inability of the majority to rule on certain things (the Bill of Rights), etc are all timeless ideas. Their codification in the Constitution was the result of much political philosophy, deliberation and debate. It was also informed by history. The Framers understood that 1) they had no guarantee that future people would be as wise and virtuous as they considered themselves to be and 2) democracy, while preferable to other systems of government, carries with it the risk of mob rule or tyranny of the majority. As a result, they drafted a written Constitution which, if ratified by the states, would serve as the legally binding document which prescribes exactly the manner in which the government encounters the individual. The rules set forth the structure of the government, how power is distributed among the various branches and how those powers are checked in order to maintain the primacy of the individual. To put it simply: given that a) the Framers thought very deeply about all the problems associated with this system of government and the best ways to resolve or minimize those problems and given that b) they had no way of knowing if people in the future would be as cautious, careful and diligent as they were in their thinking and given that c) mistakes and poor thinking in these matters tends to disfavor the individual whose rights they sought to protect that therefore amending the Constitution should be very difficult and it should require an incredibly high level of agreement and consensus that can only be achieved through an abundance of deliberation, argumentation, etc. In other words, the system they designed which was so carefully considered should not be easy to change. The system simply isn't durable if in order for it to work, we must have faith that every generation which might come to adjust the system is at least as virtuous as the one which ratified the Constitution. On the other hand, the Framers were not so presumptuous as to think that they could have anticipated the needs of all future generations so it simply had to be possible to amend the Constitution under some circumstances. The high bar for ratification offers some protection against the risk that by bending to the passing political whims of every generation we bring about the disintegration of the system. Put another way: the protective nature of the Constitution -- against government infringing on individual liberties, on the government devolving into tyranny, etc -- is inversely correlated with how flexible the system is. _We_ might consider _our_ amendment aspirations to be good and virtuous and well-intentioned, but the power to amend does not go away when a new group of people who are less well-intentioned arises. Hence, the great difficulty of amending the Constitution hampers the bad actors, even if by so doing it also impedes "progress" sought by good people. RBG doesn't seem to understand this or, at the very least, her comments quoted here reflect a lack of appreciation for this aspect of the system.
- int_19h 6y agoThese are interesting examples. If we take Canada, for one, its Charter has this gem: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_33_of_the_Canadian_Charter_of_Rights_and_Freedoms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_33_of_the_Canadian_Cha... So, things have evolved, but not all of that evolution was positive. And one has to look at both the US Constitution and the Canadian CR&F to compare and contrast. You can't automatically assume that newer is better in all respects.