6 ms·
> I'm puzzled that people are willing buy a computer/OS where (apparently) software can/will fail to launch if some central company server goes down. Maybe I'm
by tshaddox 6y ago
> I'm puzzled that people are willing buy a computer/OS where (apparently) software can/will fail to launch if some central company server goes down. Maybe I'm just getting this wrong, because I can honestly not quite wrap my head around this. This is such a big no-go, from a systems design point of view.
The answer is pretty simple: these problems are extremely rare, they don't last very long, and they tend to have fairly simple workarounds. You seem to have a principle that any non-zero chance of being affected by a problem of a certain type is a complete deal-breaker, but most people when buying a computer probably just subconsciously estimate the likelihood and impact of this type (and all other types) of problems and weigh that against other unrelated factors like price.
- satisfaction 6y ago> rare, very long, simple in this context those are simply weasel words in my opinion
- tshaddox 6y agoIt's true that I don't have data on how often this type of problem happens, how long they last, and what the workarounds are, but I'm using those words not to be intentionally vague, but to reflect my own impression from my own experience, and I strongly suspect my impression matches most people's.
- kbenson 6y agoThe problem is that this is not an issue that should be viewed only in the current context. Just because things are rare now, don't last very long doesn't mean that they will continue to be that way, or that it will work at all in the future if Apple decides that only EOL OSs could be using this system at some future point where it's mostly changed. Not caring about this now is like not caring about government or corporate privacy invasions because "I have nothing to hide". It completely ignores all the variables that have to align to make this benign that happen to at this point, but are in now was assured for the future.
- rmah 6y agoHe's not commenting how the problem should be viewed. He's communicating how he thinks most people view it. IOW, you're arguing what should be while he was talking about what is.
- tshaddox 6y ago> Just because things are rare now, don't last very long doesn't mean that they will continue to be that way, or that it will work at all in the future if Apple decides that only EOL OSs could be using this system at some future point where it's mostly changed. Okay, sure, you could attempt to estimate future damage from what appears to be a simple (albeit bad) bug in MacOS. Maybe it means all Macs will completely stop working in 2 years. But again, I think consumers will subconsciously estimate the likelihood of this to be extremely low. > Not caring about this now is like not caring about government or corporate privacy invasions because "I have nothing to hide". What? I thought we were talking about the immediate user-visible bug here, where some third-party apps could not be opened on some Macs for some period of time today. Sure, there are separate potential privacy concerns any time an OS phones home for any reason. But the problem here is just a blatant bug that manifests when the OS phones home and the servers are having problems. Macs continue to work fine when they're not connected to the internet, so it's pretty clear this is just a bug that's not actually related to the privacy concerns with phoning home.
- kbenson 6y ago> What? I thought we were talking about the immediate user-visible bug here, where some third-party apps could not be opened on some Macs for some period of time today. >>>>> these problems are extremely rare, they don't last very long, and they tend to have fairly simple workarounds. This is about Apple controlling what software you can run on your computer, for all third parties, and in a way that if the system/service is malfunctioning or shut down there's a chance it blocks all non Apple software. You can either choose to accept that Apple is a good steward of this because they haven't screwed up too much yet, and that you're okay with it because you have no or little need for third party software it might affect (or are willing to deal with it), or you can view this as an erosion of your rights to control the hardware you bought, which while only slightly inconveniencing now are still fundamentally the same as what could be used egregiously in the future. You either vigorously defend the rights (or what you want to be a right) now, or you watch it erode slowly. That's how the system works. You want privacy or believe it's important? Protect it now and even if you don't have anything to hide. You want the ability to control your own computer and run your own software, and not be beholden to some companies deprecation schedule affecting things they didn't write, or at least believe it's important for a possible future? Then defend it now. Given how iOS functions, and how Apple is moving to their own silicon for their other products, do people seriously doubt that a future where you actually can't run anything on MacOS except what you get through their store isn't at least a possible future? If that's something we care about, it's something we should be vocal about now.
- satisfaction 6y agoIf you use your laptop as mostly a youtube machine or a social media station then yes, the described problems are not a big deal, in fact they are probably beneficial to your well-being. But if you use your laptop to earn a living, that can be a major problem, day traders for a top of the head example. This also sounds like a nightmare for the corporate world. I suspect that these custom silicon iOS devices will be fully cemented as 'Fisher Price' computers.
- heavyset_go 6y ago> If you use your laptop as mostly a youtube machine or a social media station then yes, the described problems are not a big deal, in fact they are probably beneficial to your well-being I've set up a few Linux installations for people who only use their computers as Facebook and YouTube machines, and I haven't had a complaint. They also wouldn't be able to break their systems if they tried. I'm of the opinion that if ChromeOS would fit a user's use case, then so would Ubuntu with Firefox or Chrome, most of the time. Those same Linux systems would fit my needs as a developer with only a few small changes. Security, simplicity, power and ownership don't have to be mutually exclusive. You can have a simple and secure computer, and also have power over your system and own your hardware.
- m4rtink 6y agoYeah, a modern Linux distro can satisfy the needs of a "regular" user just fine - an up to date web browser and maybe an email client and all is fine. Yet at the same time it makes it possible for the user to "grow" and make use of more advanced features of the system for creative endeavors. On the other hand on a locked down mobile device or chromebook, there is not really any room to grow and be creative, it's only good for consuming content.
- tshaddox 6y agoThere's no question that software bugs are bad. But that doesn't mean we should expect consumers to ditch an entire manufacturer forever because it's physically possible for that manufacturer to have a software bug. Obviously, bugs are inevitable. I'm not making excuses. I'm just explaining why people wouldn't instantly abandon a manufacturer after experiencing a single serious software bug.
- nine_k 6y agoIt's like saying car crashes are rare, insured against, and you personally never experienced one. This does not mean car crashes can be ignored, or cannot happen to be dangerous. There is a balance between the possible damage because of not checking signatures remotely, and the possible damage from not being able to run a program when the remote checking service is unavailable. But there is no situation where the average damage is exactly zero :-/
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tshaddox 6y agoWhat? In your analogy, the parent commenter would be saying "I'm puzzled that people are willing to buy an operate an automobile given that they can be involved in dangerous accidents." And in this analogy, I'm not saying "we should ignore car crashes." I'm saying "the reason people still buy and operate automobiles despite the possibility of accidents is pretty simple."
- jb1991 6y agoYour metaphor suffers an imbalance in spectrum. We are hardly talking about life and death here. You clearly can’t make the same comparison to car crashes. People’s motivations will certainly not be the same in these two cases.
- tj-teej 6y agoI think more specifically it's rare enough that it hasn't happened to most people yet or people blame themselves ("my internet is bad" and the like)
- floatingatoll 6y agoThe payoff for the very slight risk is an effective built-in malware prevention system that doesn’t treat me abusively and reacts in a timely manner to abusive circumstances. After decades of production operations, I have no complaints about how this was handled, and I expect they’ll investigate and patch any defects exposed by the outage. I went for a walk when this happened and when I got back it was fixed. Works for me.
- craftinator 6y agoWhat's it like renting a computer?
- floatingatoll 6y agoThe tricky part with renting a computer is that you have to insure it against accidental damage by the renter, and that has to be “gig economy” or “business” compatible insurance, because you’re profiting from loaning it to others. There’s also not exactly a huge market for rental computers when you consider that libraries offer them for free, and often with better Internet connections than those renting a computer could offer. Renting computers is a lot easier if you host them in the cloud and deny physical access to your customers, though — they generally can’t do permanent damage, and there’s no issues with theft/loss. But this isn’t typically viewed as “renting” anymore, but instead something like “colocation” or whatever EC2 is. Why do you ask?
- totalZero 6y agoNormally I'm of a similar opinion to yours...but in this case I'm not. What happens if you're trading securities, or if you have an imminent deadline? Apple sells a fail-closed security feature, without investing the resources necessary to keep it as near to 100% serviceable as possible, and never really discusses it with the user. When it hangs, most users don't even know why. WTF! Seems like they could partner with Akamai (or one of its competitors) to make the server-side component of this feature more robust. If they are going to sell the MBP as a premium professional product, then they must recognize that it will sometimes serve as the linchpin of users' mission-critical activities. Take a billion dollars out of the stock buyback, invest it in the product instead, and make this problem go away.
- jonny_eh 6y agoIt's even simpler than people not caring, people don't know.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoExactly. Today was the first day when I knew this was possible. If I had been buying a computer a month ago, this would not have been a factor in my calculations whatsoever, because I didn't know it was even a possibility to consider. A month from now? Different story.
- judge2020 6y agoFYI, both Windows and Chrome (to an extent) can do this too. Windows will phone home to smartscreen scan downloaded executables, and Chrome checks every download against virustotal (owned by Google since 2013) for viruses to warn that software is malicious, and I've been burned by this a few times when a download wouldn't complete for multiple minutes due to this scan.
- adonese 6y agoYou still can run the same program checked by windows though, by opting in to use the program. And definitely you still run other programs as the check only occurs on installation, and not every time after running it.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoFurthermore, if you’re one of the few who do know and it bothers you, you can turn it off.
- tomxor 6y agoFurthermore, if you're one of the majority who don't know, you cannot turn it off when it affects you.
- 6y ago
- yboris 6y agoThere's software "EazyFlixPix" which shut down its authentication server - so everyone who purchased the app can no longer install it (unsure, but they might be also prevented from running it too). Feels problematic.
- rbecker 6y agoWithout principles, your freedom will be (is being!) slowly chiseled away, pragmatically accepting each small step. By the time even pragmatism tells you to refuse, it'll be too late. That's exactly what happened in Hong Kong: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/09/technology/apple-hong-kong-app.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/09/technology/apple-hong-kon... But it could never happen here... (As someone pointed out, this does more than just prevent apps from running - it also leaks which apps you use and how often. Someone could ask Apple exactly when you started Tor browser, for example)
- LMYahooTFY 6y agoI agree with your point about it being a principle, although I would add that the decision to build a product in this manner is also a principle. Furthermore, I would sort of disagree with the answer to why people would buy this. In terms of "most people buying a computer", the overwhelming majority of Apple customers are likely ignorant to this issue, and will continue to be.
- Swizec 6y agoAs an Apple user of 10 years: I had no idea macos phones home like this.
- amznthrwaway 6y agoIt's a certificate check. I knew and didn't care. If you care, you're going to be real upset when you look at your other alternatives. That said, I don't think many people here actually care. I firmly believe that most of the people on this site just like to shit on Apple, because they prefer that to trust their privacy to an Advertising company.
- tshaddox 6y agoThat's one potential issue, if you have privacy concerns. But the real problem here is that there's a blatant bug in the phone-home code that causes apps to crash if Apple's servers have a problem.
- floatingatoll 6y ago“Bug” is an unverified assumption. For all we know this could be a designed outcome.
- wtetzner 6y agoThen it's a bug in the design.
- floatingatoll 6y agoI would accept "flaw", "incorrect choice", or "mistake". But if they considered it, and chose this path, knowing full well this would happen, that's not a bug.
- akoncius 6y agosimply doing “if server does not respond, don’t check anything” would be bigger flaw in design because that would mean just modify hosts file to localhost or something and the security check would be worked around.
- sergeykish 6y agoThat's different mindset — ability to fix, right to repair. No way to comfortably run another OS on MacBook, has to use macOS. It is closed source, users at mercy of the company. Think different.
- rodgerd 6y agoAlso, which is the bigger risk for most people: disruption to the cert verification, or malicious runtimes on their system? (Hint: I have literally never seen an example of one of our bank's customers being unable to bank because of this. I have seen heaps and heaps of examples of endpoint compromises resulting in people having their accounts cleaned out.)
- TwoBit 6y agoHow do you use your computer if you don't have an Internet connection and one is required?