3 ms·
That quote leaves out important context. They did not actually observe lower all-cause mortality with HIIT compared to the controls nor MICT, because both resu
by loeg 6y ago
That quote leaves out important context. They did not actually observe lower all-cause mortality with HIIT compared to the controls nor MICT, because both results were statistically insignificant.
- tomtheelder 6y agoThey did observe lower all-cause mortality, just like they said themselves in their conclusion. They observed that, but were not able to safely conclude a causal relationship. In particular, in the case of HIIT vs MICT they were within a percent or two of that 95% confidence. It is clear that further investigation is necessary, as it is quite a bit more likely than not that a causal relationship will be determined. It is a good practice for scientists to not draw firm conclusions, nor for policy makers to adjust policy, for results that fail to meet that level of statistical significance. However, trying to shut down discussion and interpretation on that basis is neither helpful, nor productive.
- solveit 6y agoStatistical significance is not binary. And, personally, I have more confidence in a p=0.07 study than a p=0.048 study
- CGamesPlay 6y ago> And, personally, I have more confidence in a p=0.07 study than a p=0.048 study Why on earth would that be?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- solveit 6y agoThere's a depressingly good chance that the p=0.048 was p-hacked while we can trust the p=0.07 to be what it says on the tin.