3 ms·
That's all well and good, but it drives me crazy Microsoft refused and refuses to invest in F#, which could have very well been the Python of today if they had
by bmitc 6y ago
That's all well and good, but it drives me crazy Microsoft refused and refuses to invest in F#, which could have very well been the Python of today if they had paid any attention to it.
- justin66 6y ago> F#, which could have very well been the Python of today There's a phrase you don't see every day.
- iammiles 6y agoAs another F# enthusiast, I share the sentiment, but practically speaking I don't think F# would have been in any position to be the Python of today. It might have had a greater chance if .Net Core existed 15 years ago, but being tied to Windows was a big show-stopper regardless.
- bmitc 6y agoI agree that my comment takes into account too much hindsight, but certainly this is part of the pain. If Microsoft had transitioned .NET to be cross-platform much sooner or from the beginning, then they would have been better off. I was recently surprised to learn that Mono basically existed from the beginning of .NET, as I had no idea it was so old, so it's clear that people wanted something like .NET Core from the beginning. It's confusing to me that Microsoft embarked on their Iron <x> project, or whatever it was called, to stress test the CLR, got F# out of the project, and then decided to sit on it. They have incorporated F# features into C#, but it is confusing to me that they saw the rising popularity of Python and decided to let it happen unchecked because C# will never be F# or a language that appeals to Python programmers.
- lostmsu 6y agoIt worked on Mono
- altrunox 6y ago> which could have very well been the Python of today if they had paid any attention to it. Wow, really? I'm a big fan of Clojure and F#, but IDK, I think there is a bias against functional languages since they, IMO, are harder to start doing stuff.
- bmitc 6y agoYou can write F# just as you would with Python. This would be just using OOP or just a collection of functions operating on simple struct- or dictionary-like types, using for loops, using list comprehensions, using if-else, etc. It will look very similar and be just as easy or easier to understand.
- marcinzm 6y agoF# is strongly typed as I understand it. Python succeeded because it wasn't. A languages type system design mutates slower than the domain specific needs of what is popular. That slowness translates to difficulty in grabbing emerging domains. And the existing users are opposed to untyped structures as hacks causing friction. For example, most deep learning libraries even in typed languages are only semi-typed as matrix sizes aren't compared in the type system but in run time.
- oaiey 6y agoF# is a community with an independent mindset. That is not a good investment target. Also there is a factor is 100:1 between C# and F# developers. I think the investment is maybe even in favor of F# compared to that.