5 ms·
Do people really consider Python to have taste? It basically ignored Scheme, ML, and Erlang dialects from its creation onwards.
by bmitc 6y ago
Do people really consider Python to have taste? It basically ignored Scheme, ML, and Erlang dialects from its creation onwards.
- Scarbutt 6y agoI think it's all about the syntax and less about the semantics that still makes it a top 5 language. Makes you think about how important the syntax for a language is.
- ehsankia 6y agoThe fact that Python code is readable like pseudocode is most definitely why I like it best, over esoteric languages like Perl or Erlang with their non-intuitive use of various characters. To a seasoned programmer it may look obvious, but Python is still by far the best language for newcomers, and generally people tend to stick much longer to the language they were first taught.
- bmitc 6y agoI am "seasoned", and I find Python not obvious at all. It's a confusing language with little gotchas everywhere. I find writing code in something like Racket or F# to be much easier and more consistent than Python.
- chippy 6y agothe user said the person who created Python had good taste, not that the language they created has it (somehow)
- webmaven 6y ago> the user said the person who created Python had good taste, not that the language they created has it (somehow) I think that saying Guido has taste implies that Python is tasteful.
- munificent 6y ago> Do people really consider Python to have taste? Yes. Obviously people have different tastes, but many many people find Python to be tastefully designed. > It basically ignored Scheme, ML, and Erlang dialects from its creation onwards. Those are... all radically different languages from each other. This is like arguing that a peanut butter and jelly sandwich would be better if it was more like sushi, chocolate, and pasta.
- bmitc 6y ago> Those are... all radically different languages from each other. Not really, but that wasn't my point. My point was, that at the time of Python's creation, all those languages existed and have taste. The fact that they were ignored in Python's development is an example of it not having taste. The best example of this is Python's scoping rules. When something like Scheme or ML exists and you end up with Python's scoping, it's hard for me to understand where the taste is.
- ajkjk 6y agoI suspect Python's popularity was greatly helped by ignoring those languages. Your definition of taste isn't everyone's.
- bmitc 6y agoI didn’t say it was. I am curious though what others consider to be tasteful about Python. It objectively has ignored features from those languages, such as immutability, concurrency, sane scoping, functional ways of thinking, pattern matching, better REPL, etc. which have all been making their way into most modern languages. So what’s tasteful about Python? The benefits it has that I see are that it’s easy to download and run for simple scripts and has clean-ish syntax, but that’s about it. For anything larger, it quickly gets in the way. Popularity is a confusing beast. What has made Python popular, in my opinion, is that it was adopted by scientists, but in my experience, that group of people has little taste in software and little want to figure out what else is out there.
- solinent 6y agoPython 2 was pretty tasteful, simple, usable, the exception that proved the rule. I think Python has evolved since.