3 ms·
OK, but what about before that? Space itself was expanding faster than the speed of light? There had to be a time when that was not true, because as you go ba
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
OK, but what about before that?
Space itself was expanding faster than the speed of light? There had to be a time when that was not true, because as you go back earlier in time, if that continued back far enough it would mean the diameter of the universe was negative. That's clearly absurd.
But that leaves you with all this mass, inside the Chandrasekhar limit, but the universe not expanding faster than the speed of light. And then it starts expanding.
All this presumes that time can be thought of as extending back before the big bang, which I don't know if that's actually a valid idea.
I have heard the claim that the laws of general relativity allow for a white hole as well - a singularity from which things go out, instead of things going in. That may be an accurate picture, or at least a decent model.
- opwieurposiu 6y agoThe big bang theory gets weirder the further back you go. I agree with you that at a certain point it starts to seem pretty hand-wavy. A popular explanation is that at very high energies, the laws of physics work differently, IE gravity, strong, weak and electromagnetic force were all combined into one and there was negative mass. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronology_of_the_universe#Planck_epoch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronology_of_the_universe#Pla...
- vl 6y ago>OK, but what about before that? Well, the standard answer is that “time didn’t exist”. This is of course in unsatisfactory. The truth is that nobody knows, and so far it looks like we are unlikely to know. If you think about it, it doesn’t make much sense at all: some huge amount of matter, came from somewhere, space expanded with it. Why? Where it came from? What is the reason? This is the area, where scientists that dwell on it too much, start to go crazy or become overly religious.