5 ms·
> Google doesn't care about you or what you think. I find the Google/Startup dichotomy here fascinating. We are on hackernews, a site focused on startups. Pivo
by UncleMeat 6y ago
> Google doesn't care about you or what you think.
I find the Google/Startup dichotomy here fascinating. We are on hackernews, a site focused on startups. Pivoting dramatically, including throwing away your entire customer base for a different population, is considered an essential part of running a startup. But if a big company has a product that is obviously stagnating at a small userbase then the community demands that it be supported in perpetuity.
There is a pair of Cole Haan shoes I really like. I bought several of the same exact style over the years. It was eventually phased out. I can't buy it anymore. Is Cole Haan narcissistic for not offering me the shoe I want?
Is it narcissism, or good business?
- ctrl-j 6y agoI'll admit, I don't work in the startup space. However, it seems to me that Google doesn't really run their products like a startup generally does. It seems like adapting your product to your existing client base is usually better than launching a similar but different product while your current one is live. Once you've fragmented your user base then shuttering one of your products and (hoping?) that the users who didn't migrate will finally migrate to your new product... that seems like a lot of unnecessary risk? Or maybe that's just the startup game? I feel like if startups ran their business like google runs their products, they'd fail pretty quickly. Am I off base here?
- specialist 6y agoTalent retention. All the side projects are makework, amusement, seduction. So the top talent doesn't wander off to work some where else.
- onion2k 6y agoIs this true or is it what Googlers who work on the low priority products that will inevitably be killed off after a few years tell themselves to feel better about working on what is essentially shovelware clones of the latest idea someone else is having some success with? Google are big enough and generate enough profit that they can afford to have entire divisions of developers who are kept around in case they're needed one day. That doesn't make those people good developers though. Obviously there are some very capable people on those teams, but if they're genuinely talented why aren't they working on Search or Ads? That's what makes Google money, so that's why the best people end up, not on little side projects.
- baq 6y agodefine 'small userbase'. one million users is small for google but any startup with such number would be an unicorn, or close to.
- vertis 6y agoThis is known as 'The Innovators Dilemma' and there is a book by the same name by Clayton Christensen[1]. Essentially, the bigger you get the harder it is to go after "small" opportunities. But some of the biggest disruptions come from those "small" problems. It's a fine way to look for niches to exploit for a startup. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Innovator%27s_Dilemma https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Innovator%27s_Dilemma
- theptip 6y agoIt’s bad business if users won’t buy in future because you get a reputation for axing products, and/or you never apply yourself well to any one thing. It’s debatable whether many people outside HN actually hold a grudge; Google’s overall favorability ratings are crazily high. But I wouldn’t be surprised if Stadia had a rough launch because of Google’s reputation. Shoes are a bad analogy because there is little switching cost; you just ties a different pair of laces and you’re done. If you had five years of playlists on G Music and now you have to move them to Spotify, that’s a major project. (Source: I did this, and it took me many hours). Put differently, as a happy customer, you don’t want the company to pivot. It’s usually bad news for all of the existing happy customers. A successful pivot is great for the company, hopefully great for the new happy users, and very disruptive for the old customers. In the best cases the net utility is even positive.
- jboy55 6y agoYour comment about Stadia gave me this thought. What odds would I be willing to bet that Stadia would be around in 5 years. I wouldn't take a even money bet. Maybe 5:1 that they'd still be functioning in 2025? (edit, made the odds clearer)
- theptip 6y agoIt's an interesting question, I think i'd give it less than 10% but above 1%. It's outside their core competency, it involves them negotiating with rightsholders, and there's a bunch of competition coming from existing companies in the space (e.g. Microsoft, NVidia, etc.). As I can see, their only edge is that they own a global content delivery network which in the best case might be able to give them a few years' head-start in terms of performance vs. other players that don't own IP infrastructure. (It's a recent development that cloud-hosted gaming is even viable from a latency perspective). But that doesn't seem like the core long-term problem; it might give you a first-mover advantage but I don't see that being enough to build a defensible moat in this space.
- stronglikedan 6y agoIt's just good business, but that won't stop aging millenials from living up to their "entitlement generation" moniker by claiming it's narcissism.
- bccdee 6y agoIt might be good business if it weren't Google. Have you used Youtube Music, their replacement service? It's garbage. It's barely usable. I'm going to have to switch to Spotify. Google always does this thing where it trashes a mature service and replaces it with something really new and immature that doesn't fit the use case of their previous customers in the hopes that they'll acquire new customers. But there's no sales pitch for Youtube Music. It doesn't do anything new. It's just, "the last one wasn't as successful as we'd like, so let's change things up a bit." And with an attitude like that, the next one won't be successful either. Which is why Google keeps doing this over and over. They have corporate commitment problems. They never take a service and make it good, they just scrap it and start a new one in the hopes that they'll luck into a big hit. They've had like a dozen different instant-messaging apps in the past decade, and none of them ever caught on, because they keep scrapping them. I couldn't even tell you what the current iteration is. I used to use Google Allo a bit, which was their last one, but then they scrapped that and made this most recent one. I don't know why they do this.
- Tassels 6y agoI ended up switching to Apple Music. I know, I know, Apple, but like Google Music, they allow me to upload any music I have MP3s of. That includes all the tracks I bought from bands I love (usually through bandcamp, or ripped CDs) who aren't on streaming services yet. Just import them into the music app on my laptop, sync my library, and boom those tracks are available everywhere, just like google music. I actually like it better, since it's an actual app and I don't need to upload the tracks through chrome – I don't use chrome, I use firefox, and I used to have to use chrome just to upload my music.
- robotnikman 6y ago
- sp332 6y agoI dislike when a company throws away a user's data. It's not great for a startup, but at least there's the excuse that they ran out of money or whatever. Google doesn't even have that reason. They deleted our data when they 100% had the option not to.
- throwaway413 6y agoOff-topic, were they the Cole Haan Grand Pro Runners? Best shoes I’ve ever owned...
- Fellshard 6y agoSoftware ain't fashion.
- mekoka 6y agoWhy is it fascinating if it's not a false dichotomy? Google is not a startup. It's like saying that you're puzzled because companies operating from a garage are not held to the same standards than a fortune 500. When Google tries to be disruptive in an emerging niche, it does it with a backing (brand & money) that could effectively snuff the smaller (and more willing) competition that it finds already operating in the arena. It enters as the 800lbs big G, smashing everything in its wake. Then sometime later, loses interest and goes home with its ball, leaving its users and the surviving smaller competition to figure out what's next. Edit: If the service truly represents a dead end, why not sell it?
- benlivengood 6y ago> Edit: If the service truly represents a dead end, why not sell it? The practical reason is that it's statically compiled out of the monorepo and hosted on borg behind GFEs so there's really nothing to sell except the codebase and infrastructure of Google of which a snippet is the service in question, and the licensing that makes it possible is probably non-transferrable.
- Closi 6y ago> The practical reason is that it's statically compiled out of the monorepo and hosted on borg behind GFEs so there's really nothing to sell except the codebase and infrastructure of Google of which a snippet is the service in question, and the licensing that makes it possible is probably non-transferrable. That's not a practical reason, if it was a small company they would sell it. The real reason is that Google would prefer to kill the service than have it continue with another owner which would compete with other Google offerings. And compared to Google's overall value, they don't particularly need the sale price.
- musingsole 6y agoThe Real Reason (tm). Why not both?
- benlivengood 6y ago
- specialist 6y ago"Is Cole Haan narcissistic for not offering me the shoe I want?" Yes. Absolutely. First, shoes and music streaming are NOTHING alike. Many products like shoes are so close to mass customization. Levis finally, mostly got smart about this. Why can't I reorder the exact same glasses, shoes, jeans that fit? It's mostly because of the broken feedback loops, missing backward flow of information. The designer, fashion buyer, PHB absolutely knows what you should want. Your opinion is moot. Oh gosh it'd cost so much to build the infrastructure, complication, returns, we'd have to pay laborers a few pennies more blah blah blah. Excuses. I don't care. Just make the shoes I want and I'll be a loyal customer forever. PS- I asked LA Eyeworks to resume making the Big Bodhi (John Lennon, Steve Jobs) glasses for 20+ years. The pair I bought in the 90s were finally beyond repair. The lady I bought from said she could sell two dozen pairs overnight. I visited the original LA Eyeworks store twice, to make a personal appeal. Nope. Can't be done. Not possible. (The Big Bodhi are XL size, for my big pumpkin head.) PPS- Speaking of Cole Haan... I had a pair that I absolutely loved. Bought them for working conventions. Standing on that concrete all day for 3-4 days. Sucks. Think of fashionable postman shoes. Gods, I loved those shoes. LOVED THEM. Best shoes I've ever owned. I tried so many times to replace them. I'm so mad at Cole Haan. I LOATHE them. Apparently they were bought by Nike or something and completely went to shit.
- musingsole 6y ago>"Is Cole Haan narcissistic for not offering me the shoe I want?" >Yes. Absolutely. A mirror might help with your narcissist detection. There's a lot more involved in manufacturing than one person or even 20 people wanting it and that 3D printers exist doesn't change the equation so much. They've been around for a while. The short of it is a larger market is far more appealing than your brand of customer loyalty.
- specialist 6y agoELI5 why Cole Haan, LA Eyeworks can't do this: https://www.levi.com/US/en_US/blog/category/make-it-yours/ https://www.levi.com/US/en_US/blog/category/make-it-yours/ Mea culpa: Worked for fashion retailer on recommendation engine. Have some experience with the players.
- bduerst 6y agoYou are witnessing the brand lifecycle. Facebook, Amazon, and Google are no longer the new underdogs and are old enough to be in the disenfranchisement trough. They will eventually stabilize like Apple and Microsoft.
- tweetle_beetle 6y agoI suspect this is just fatigue of seeing Google involved in yet another story along these lines. It has the emotional brand baggage of dozens of cancelled and pivoted products - of which a single user could have experienced many.