3 ms·
> Today's doctors are for the most part motivated by $. Not any more so than any other field. Me - I want a doctor who is smart enough to have done something
by anamax 18y ago
> Today's doctors are for the most part motivated by $.
Not any more so than any other field. Me - I want a doctor who is smart enough to have done something else and smart enough to say "pay me what I'm worth".
> We need more doctors and need to pay them less.
Unless you're going to break the monopoly on services that can only be performed by doctors or the medical school monopoly, you're not going to reduce income without introducing more scarcity (they'll do something else and won't be replaced).
The "universal health care" advocates never mention that the federal, state, and local govts directly control about half of the US healthcare spending and cover about half of the covered people. If you're going to argue that govt healthcare can be better/cheaper, that can be done today with those resources.
As it is, they're arguing that they'll be able to cover more than twice as many people for about 50% more money. How about demonstrating that and opening up the govt system to outsiders for cost? If you're right, the private system will either become as good or die.
- giardini 18y agoI cannot address complaints about your imagined concept of universal health care. Perhaps next time you'll respond to my post, rather than your imagination. Such methods as training doctors less and allowing specialization earlier, eliminating situations where doctors are currently required, tracking and publishing doctors' success rates, allowing pharmacists to write prescriptions, etc. all would reduce doctors' income and weaken the medical school monopoly. Many more students would enter medicine since, while it wouldn't pay as much, it would pay well, and the requirements and time needed to enter the field would be significantly reduced. And please read http://www.strategy-business.com/press/article/07110?gko=56480&tid=230&pg=all http://www.strategy-business.com/press/article/07110?gko=564... Scroll down and read especially "Redefining Competition" about Porter and Teisberg's ideas.