4 ms·
I am in Europe and I do not see anything close to what the author is describing. Nothing is really at no cost. It is paid for with tax money or directly. The a
by zelphirkalt 6y ago
I am in Europe and I do not see anything close to what the author is describing.
Nothing is really at no cost. It is paid for with tax money or directly. The author is not specifying "for those who could not otherwise afford it", but describing it as at no cost for everyone. Most universities cost money to enrole and attend. Does your baker give out buns at no cost? Is the grocery store giving away all the food at no cost? Has it all become a service at no cost?
Nope, none of that has happened and it will not happen, as long as everything needs to be a good business in a capitalistic sense. The single person business or small business or any business cannot escape the reality in this system.
Show me that country or even that city please. Show me the social experiment, that tries to get people to work without pay, as long as they have access to "all the things we need in our daily lives". As far as I know, it has never been done. What if you have any extra wish? How will it be supplied, without tracking your every move in such a society? How would different needs be satisfied, everyone having slightly different needs?
So that's why I call it pure fiction. You are welcome to show me that model city, which self-sufficiently makes it happen. I might move there.
- chmod775 6y ago> Nothing is really at no cost. It is paid for with tax money or directly. > The author is not specifying "for those who could not otherwise afford it", but describing it as at no cost for everyone. The author never specified whether or how things are paid for, but for me personally I am assuming tax money. He also leaves open whether luxury goods/foods are still paid for. > Show me that country or even that city please. Show me the social experiment, that tries to get people to work without pay, as long as they have access to "all the things we need in our daily lives". As far as I know, it has never been done. Why are you asking me to show you something I never claimed existed? I claimed there's places with social security (housing, food) and free public transport (Luxembourg for instance). > So that's why I call it pure fiction. Anything that doesn't exist yet is fiction. It seems that you both misunderstood the article and my comment, then tried to maneuver me into a position where I would defend something nobody ever claimed. To be fair, the author leaves a lot of things unexplained, so one's imagination is going to fill in the gaps. Personally I imagined a city where basic necessities are provided for free, but where you have to pay for anything that is a cut above. Greatly expanded social security essentially.
- zelphirkalt 6y agoI see. OK seems I interpret the text differently. Not sure my interpretation is necessarily a wrong reading.
- collyw 6y agoTry to find the BBC documentary Inside the Bruderhof (it was on youtube, but seems to have gone). It's a religious commune and it's the best example I have seen of a form of communism that works. Not my idea of how to live my life though. I'll take the evils of free market capitalism over that.