4 ms·
> If I were more mean spirited I might say that you don't understand how to parse a sentence or that words can take on different meanings in different contexts
by KirinDave 16y ago
> If I were more mean spirited I might say that you don't understand how to parse a sentence or that words can take on different meanings in different contexts. I'm certain that's not actually true but that is effectively the conclusion you came to in the same situation. Pretty silly right?
Ahh so let's just play word games then? Let's just call callbacks "allocators of effect" and functions "parameterized callbacks" and see how clear our writing is. Even if we ignore this gaffe, it implies Ryah thinks the world is struggling under the burden of blocking libraries. "Oh no," our hypothetical wage slave might cry, "this library unexpected uses a thread. Now my job is impossible." It's strange to even claim that a feature in 2011. Maybe Node's needs a Paul-Tyma-figure to come snap them out of their implicit assumption that asynchronous libraries are always faster; they are not.
But what he said wasn't true. You can write loops in Javascript, so libraries could enter into infinite loops which would stop the machine from progressing.
> Whether or not winning benchmarks is useful is debatable, but given that constraint it's obvious you don't want GC. He wants a scripting language without GC not JavaScript specifically.
He was not asking or direct allocators and deallocators, if you read the quote, he was talking about removing memory management entirely. I'm not sure how Node's functions could lexically close over anything unless you start introducing a lot of new notions that current node programmers don't care abut.
> Give the guy some credit, he is a C programmer by trade.
I want to. I really want to. But then he writes blog posts like this (http://antirobotrobot.tumblr.com/post/5109182039/overlapped-i-o http://antirobotrobot.tumblr.com/post/5109182039/overlapped-...) and severely undermines my confidence in him. When he was just playing around with a side project I thought it was a cool hack. Now that he's got a corporate backer it's a little surprising he isn't bothering to up his game.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]