4 ms·
I sympathize with the author's points, but the headline is misleading - the only reason they posit to move to Venus is because Elon Musk wants to move to Mars.
by pavel_lishin 6y ago
I sympathize with the author's points, but the headline is misleading - the only reason they posit to move to Venus is because Elon Musk wants to move to Mars.
Yes, Venus can be as habitable as Mars, but there's a big problem - like it or not, we have to extract resources from a place to live there, and there just isn't much we can extract from Venus. Extracting any resources from the surface means mining them from a hellscape, and then lifting them out of the gravity well into the clouds. (Though, to be fair, maybe we could just park a few asteroids in orbit and use those.)
- ericbarrett 6y agoVenus also requires a lot more energy to lift mass from the surface since it’s nearly the same size as Earth. Its escape velocity is 10.3 km/s. Earth is 11.2 km/s and Mars is 5.0.
- tzs 6y agoCould you use balloons to lift things from the surface to the cloud city level?
- dwaltrip 6y agoThe heat at the surface (864 deg F) melts lead, so it doesn’t seem feasible.
- pavel_lishin 6y agoThat's a good question, I have no idea! You'd have to pump it full of gas against a pressure of ~1300 PSI. Googling around, that's about equivalent to a kilometer under water. Granted, it's not impossible - ocean oil rigs operate at those depths - but they're not operating at 500 degrees celcius.
- ncmncm 6y agoThe thing is, Mars is a dump. Every detail is wrong, excepting only that there is dirt. When dirt is your best feature, you have to fall back on hype. Venus and Mars are both extremely difficult environments, overwhelmingly moreso than Antarctica, the middle of the Takla Makan Desert, undersea, or in orbit, and also much harder to get to and from. No one has attempted living sustainably in any of those, and there is no proof they could if they tried. So, only billionaires' public fantasies make them seem doable at all. Of the two, the cloud tops of Venus are somewhat less all-around hellish.
- dogma1138 6y agoAntarctica or the Takla Makan Desert don't give you any "advantage" over the existing habitable zones on earth - mars does and that advantage is that it's a different fucking planet. Mars is also a stepping stone to the belt and the outer solar system and like it or not it's our next frontier. Antarctica isn't going to yield you the same reaches as the belt will or heck even Mars because currently "polluting" Mars would actually be beneficial or at the least immaterial. Humanity needs a new frontier to expand too, we tried making space our next frontier but it didn't caught on, maybe now it will if not it will be quite sad imo as it would leave the digital frontier as the only other frontier to expand into.
- ncmncm 6y agoWe don't need a stepping stone to the Belt. The Belt is right there. Mars is at best a distraction, more likely a deep, deep hole. Phobos could be useful.
- ASalazarMX 6y agoEarth is also just wet dirt, what makes it fertile can be replicated on small-scale elsewhere.
- ncmncm 6y agoEarth: Life, water, air, air pressure, warmth, gravity, sunshine, dirt. Venus: Water vapor, air pressure, warmth, gravity, more sunshine. Mars: Dirt.
- ASalazarMX 6y agoMars: dirt, water (likely as brine), air, air pressure, warmth, gravity, sunshine. You just get a lot of dirt, and a lot less of the others, but brine can be purified, air can be compressed to get pressure, useful minerals can be mined from the soil and rocks, which unlike Venus, isn't under a scorching acid bath.