3 ms·
Google is also introducing a new policy of deleting data from inactive accounts that haven’t been logged in to for at least two years. A little bit of good new
by DoreenMichele 6y ago
Google is also introducing a new policy of deleting data from inactive accounts that haven’t been logged in to for at least two years.
A little bit of good news, IMO. Next, they need to do like Reddit and start making "dead" account names available for re-use. (Something Reddit does for sub-reddits and which Google seems to not do for, say, BlogSpot.)
Edit: I say this as someone with old, dead google accounts I will never recover and I would rather the data be deleted than fall into the hands of nefarious third parties. Also, we bellyache about the amount of electricity used for Bitcoin as an environmental hazard, but we think Google should keep abandoned accounts intact indefinitely? Why?
All systems need some means to clean out the cruft and recycle stuff and not just permanently freeze it for people who may be dead, who may have forgotten they made that account while high that one night, etc.
- duskwuff 6y agoAllowing email addresses to be reused is a huge security and privacy problem. It means that any email which was still being sent to the old address -- including account recovery emails -- becomes accessible to the new owner of the email address. Deleting data from "dead" accounts is fine and good. But they need to stay dead, not come back to life.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI'm talking about recycling BlogSpot addresses. Currently, it's common to see a BlogSpot blog with a single post from ten years ago and it means all the best URLs are gone and will never be available.
- duskwuff 6y agoThat's vulnerable to a different sort of hijacking -- SEO spammers recreating blogs with URLs of deleted sites that previously had a lot of incoming links. It'd also risk destroying historically important content that was published in "one-off" Blogspot sites.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoReddit doesn't let you adopt a subreddit if the mod is active anywhere on Reddit, even if you as a user can't see it. The subreddit has to be completely abandoned and the mod account has to be dead. I see no reason why Google can't have similar policies that if the Gmail that controls the blog is completely inactive to the point where it gets deleted, any blogs it controlled can now be recycled.
- duskwuff 6y agoSubreddits are built upon user activity, and need active moderation to keep that under control. A policy of allowing the subreddit to be passed on to a new moderator if the previous moderator is gone -- which doesn't even remove any existing content -- is eminently reasonable. Blogspot blogs, on the other hand, are primarily about the author's content. Destroying that content simply because the author is no longer reachable (e.g. if they have died!) is not a reasonable policy.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI think you are not really hearing my point. I'm saying there are many blogspot URLs that have been claimed and that aren't really in use. In most cases, these are not sites with substantial content of any kind. There's currently no means to recycle them that I know of. I deleted one of my own and can't reclaim the URL. It just no longer exists. Period. I think that's a problem.