3 ms·
Apple’s chip is not just a general purpose CPU, it is designed for specific workloads. We have similar performance jumps in cryptocurrency mining: GPU’s are or
by mrtksn 6y ago
Apple’s chip is not just a general purpose CPU, it is designed for specific workloads.
We have similar performance jumps in cryptocurrency mining: GPU’s are orders of magnitude faster than CPU’s and ASIC’s are orders of magnitude faster than GPU’s for the same power consumption.
- norswap 6y agoIt's supposed to run a Mac, why isn't it a general purpose CPU? What specific workload do you have in mind? I could use it for web browsing, programming, media editing...
- kridsdale1 6y agoPerhaps the answer is that x86 is far more general purpose than that. Many of the instructions are as old as the Millennial workforce at Intel who is building their chips, from an era where the web wasn't a concern and GUIs were uncommon. A vast amount of transistors are dedicated to a different optimization than what the software of this decade cares about. OTOH ARM and Apple have tailored their chips to the workload of ~10 years ago (running Javascript at single-digit watts) which is far more tailored to what actually gets used these days.
- mrtksn 6y agoAnything that has to do with audio, video, graphics processing and so on. There are videos on youtube demonstrating that you can edit large video files on an iPhone connected to an external monitor and do it smoother than a much larger PC. Here is an example of using iPhone SE strapped to an external screen, editing a 4K footage: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LmbrOUPFDvg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LmbrOUPFDvg Notice how smooth is everything.
- photojosh 6y agoI thought the mouse support was iPad only... thanks for the TIL.
- klelatti 6y agoBut the M1 is a general purpose CPU and it is faster (without any help from Neural Engines etc) than competing devices.
- mrtksn 6y agoWhy without any help from Neural Engines and etc.? They, the workload specific processors, are included in M1.
- klelatti 6y agoThey are but they don't account for the CPU performance jumps being quoted - these are the result of better standalone CPU performance. Your parent comment seemed to imply that the leap was due to an architecture shift like CPU -> GPU. It's not, it's just better CPU design.
- mrtksn 6y agoWell, there's no standalone CPU to talk about, is there? Purpose built architecture could mean many things, like having efficient cores and high performance cores, codec specific hardware, the way that the memory is accessed, cache configuration, co-processors, signal processors. Everything counts.
- wmf 6y agoPlenty of workloads like SPEC and compiling don't use GPUs, neural networks, etc. They just use CPU cores, cache, and memory. Fortunately Apple has gotten the basics right and they have also added accelerators.
- mrtksn 6y agoI would guess that the tight proximity of the components as well as the way their communication is designed also brings something on the table. People are used to complain that the ram is soldered to the board, now it is part of the IC.