3 ms·
Translation: people who disagreed with me were incorrect on a different topic. Therefore, everyone who disagrees with me on this peripherally related topic is a
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
Translation: people who disagreed with me were incorrect on a different topic. Therefore, everyone who disagrees with me on this peripherally related topic is also likely to be incorrect.
See the logical fallacy?
- starwed 16y agoOoh, it's the strawman! Oh... you meant in the OP?
- vbtemp 16y agoThere was no logically fallacy, he was just making a relevant point.
- cgoddard 16y agoPeripherally related is really stretching it. The way I understood chrismealy's argument is this: Biological essentialist arguments were previously used to explain the disparity of men and women in law and medicine. Now that we know that those arguments were critically flawed and did not reflect reality, we should be very hesitant to support similar arguments being used to explain the lack of women in STEM disciplines.