4 ms·
It helps to separate the PhD from the general academia angst because it’s in an entirely different category. The complaints about the lower degrees are usually
by kortilla 6y ago
It helps to separate the PhD from the general academia angst because it’s in an entirely different category.
The complaints about the lower degrees are usually about value for cost, remote learning, etc. This is easily compatible with the fact that employers want employees to have degrees. It’s even one of the primary reasons the prices have been able to go up so much for a degree (economic value).
The PhD programs, research, and tenure track academia in general is an entirely different beast with some pretty fundamental flaws. Very few companies require PhDs so the job opportunities for a PhD student who wants a position that requires one are scarce.
I got my PhD from a top 10 CS research university and it was shocking how much competition the graduates had to get a tenure track position at some third rate university when they graduated. Publications in top journals and even a solid post doc just got you the opportunity to fight 8 other equally qualified candidates for a single slot.
The professors do not emphasize enough that tenure track research faculty is nothing more than a fantasy for 90% of the graduates, and that’s ignoring the 50% of PhD students who dropped out before finishing.
- atq2119 6y ago> it was shocking how much competition the graduates had to get a tenure track position at some third rate university when they graduated Counterpoint: assuming a stable size of universities, the average number per professor of supervised doctoral students who receive tenure is 1. How many doctoral students does a professor have on average over the course of their career? By that point, the situation really shouldn't be surprising. It only seems that way because the 20th century saw a period of extremely fast growth of universities, and societal expectations have a lot of inertia.
- bananaface 6y agoIt's not surprising when you're wise enough to realise this, but I think it's a deceptive promise sold to incoming students. You hear so many horror stories from people who didn't realise they were signing their life away when they signed. It seems very predatory to me.
- michaelmior 6y agoI'm not sure when you got your degree but now (well, at least pre-COVID) there are often more openings than can be filled. (Speaking of CS here.) Anyone I know who graduated in a similar time frame as me didn't have too much difficulty getting a faculty position somewhere (without postdoc).