3 ms·
Ignoring the problems with this pop article: > This argument and the other regarding protein powders not being "real food" stands beyond reason to me. If you'r
by gumby 6y ago
Ignoring the problems with this pop article:
> This argument and the other regarding protein powders not being "real food" stands beyond reason to me. If you're eating vitamins or protein in food or in a pill, what would the difference be? Are smoothies or soups not food?
Nutrition studies are quite difficult to perform, and the biology of digestion is not well understood. Certainly different foods eaten in different ways are absorbed by your body differently. Your smoothie example is a good one: fibrous vegetables travel farther through the gut* and their nutrients are absorbed differently than when the fibres are chopped up so that they travel through the lower intestine faster.
> ...The only way I could imagine they're useless is if the the vitamins themselves are structurally different and indigestible?
Likewise an iron supplement alone (or just iron from a piece of meat) will not raise iron levels as much as when taken with lemon juice or, yes, vitamin C.
You can measure this effect for yourself by measuring glucose rise when eating various foods: a raw apple, for example, vs the same mass of apple sauce vs the same mass of apple juice.
* of course it all makes its way the same distance from mouth to anus! I mean arriving intact, or less processed, in the lower intestine and spending a longer time there.
- bamboozled 6y agoThen I guess I'd be happy to take them even if I get "some benefits and nutrients from them", super easy to take, relatively inexpensive and like I said, I do take them with various foods, as you said sometimes nutrients are absorbed best in combination with others, so my logic is sometimes I might have breakfast containing more vitamin C, this day I'll get some extra iron, seems like a win to me? I'm not a doctor so maybe my views are overly simplistic? Seems like a good insurance policy to me more than anything else. I still strive to eat a healthy diet, but why not cover all bases?
- maerF0x0 6y ago> You can measure this effect for yourself by measuring glucose rise when eating various foods: a raw apple, for example, vs the same mass of apple sauce vs the same mass of apple juice. Just to be pedantic for a moment, but you'd want to compare same calories (isocaloric), rather than mass per se
- gumby 6y agoI was thinking of the rise time but indeed, your pedantry is appropriate for looking at the peak which will also be different