3 ms·
Did Nate Cohn's predictions this election pan out? “The final polls more or less comport with how we already viewed the race. Mr. Biden ends the race up by mor
by SV_BubbleTime 6y ago
Did Nate Cohn's predictions this election pan out?
“The final polls more or less comport with how we already viewed the race. Mr. Biden ends the race up by more than eight points nationwide — the largest lead a candidate has held in the final polls since Bill Clinton in 1996. He’s up by at least five points in states worth more than 270 electoral votes, the number needed to win. Beyond that, he’s got at least a nominal lead in states worth 350 electoral votes, and he’s just a 2012 polling error away from a sweeping landslide of more than 400 electoral votes.”
https://www.nytimes.com/live/2020/presidential-polls-trump-biden/assessing-the-last-polls-before-the-election https://www.nytimes.com/live/2020/presidential-polls-trump-b...
Cohn's polling leading up to the election:
Tuesday Nevada Biden +6
Wednesday Michigan Biden +8
Thursday N.C. Biden +3
Sunday Arizona Biden +6
Sunday Florida Biden +3
Sunday Pennsylvania Biden +6
Sunday Wisconsin Biden +11
Which of these happened?
Biden underperformed compared to Clinton in most pivot counties and bellweather predictions (which were 90% wrong this year, wow), and most counties in swing states entirely with the except of greaty overperforming in the densest liberal areas, in some of those cases even doing better than Obama as crazy as that seems. Biden underperformed with hispanics and black from exceptions and likewise Trump did better with them than expected overall. And no matter what if you think someone the day of the election saying "Biden Landside" was possible, well...
You do you, but me personally, I'm going to go to someone else for opinions because that was such an exaggeration of reality that it seems like it had to be "for effect".
- bryanlarsen 6y agoSomebody who got it wrong and actually admitted he got it wrong is often a credible source on why he got it wrong.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y agoI disagree. It's FAR too early for him to be writing about "why we got it wrong" because if they knew that now, they would have known that last week. Look, if it was 2 points in a couple states here or there, I get it! But... if the guy was claiming the possibility of a 400 vote Biden landslide? Nah man, that is either massive incompetence or it's intentionally misleading. Neither scenario do I trust this person.
- bryanlarsen 6y ago> because if they knew that now, they would have known that last week. Last week he didn't have access to the results or exit polling data like he does now. > if the guy was claiming the possibility of a 400 vote Biden landslide? A polling error of this magnitude in the other direction would have been a massive landslide.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y agoWhich one of Cohn's swing state predictions are within "polling error"? If you can't even consider the possibility that the polls were pushed to demoralize, that's not on me. Here... Let me give you a source of pollster who explains just how crazy Cohn, Silver, Wasserman's polls were and how drastically they overshot. This guy is right leaning, but no fan of Republicans, but the view here is that he's pissed about how poorly everyone did this and how it's incompetence or malice. https://www.youtube.com/watch?list=PLHe3u4zZfY7K1N04z6Xu_JbYPNDqxJC3P&v=TP-rlEGDQVE&feature=emb_logo https://www.youtube.com/watch?list=PLHe3u4zZfY7K1N04z6Xu_JbY... Watch from 30min to 40min. That's 10 minutes that I think will make the point with numbers that I can not make here.
- bryanlarsen 6y ago> how crazy Cohn, Silver, Wasserman's polls were Silver didn't do any polling, and is the guy that wrote [I'm here to remind you that Trump can still win](https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/im-here-to-remind-you-that-trump-can-still-win/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/im-here-to-remind-you-t...) before the election. > incompetence or malice. IIRC, Cohn said his number on Latinos in many districts was off by 50%. Call it incompetence if you want.
- bryanlarsen 6y ago> Which one of Cohn's swing state predictions are within "polling error"? If you can't even consider the possibility that the polls were pushed to demoralize, that's not on me. A normal polling error is about 5%, so all of them are within that except for Florida and Wisconsin.