7 ms·
Not making any other assumptions here, but I think this is a great example of something that's become more and more obvious to HNers over the past few years: fr
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
Not making any other assumptions here, but I think this is a great example of something that's become more and more obvious to HNers over the past few years: from a financial perspective, if you have an opportunity to join a FAANG vs a startup, it pretty much almost always makes financial sense (usually much more sense) to join the FAANG. And since it usually makes a LOT more financial sense, it can often make a lot of the other points moot as well, because you could save so much more working at a FAANG that you could afford to take time off to do whatever you want, or retire early.
I mean, in this example Baremetrics actually had a pretty good outcome, better than most, and the employee's basically got very, very little for their overall equity. Even the founder probably got less than a mid/senior level FAANG employee would get (and the FAANG employee had no risk).
Of course, not everyone can get an offer at a FAANG, but again, if you could get an offer, startups basically never make sense anymore. You almost always will get more even if the startup hits, which is rare.
- bob33212 6y agoA startup makes sense if you are looking to do something different or to expand you skillset. Working at a major corporation can feel stifling over time. The important thing to understand that there is almost 0% chance that your "1-4%" ownership will ever be more than 6 figures.
- pc86 6y agoAlmost a 0% chance it will be worth anything more than $0 and, maybe, a good story.
- ericd 6y agoThis is a commonly repeated trope, I guess it's to inoculate people from being "suckered in", but it hasn't been true from what I've seen, having lots of friends involved startups. Even "failing" startups frequently get acquihired for non-trivial amounts per person, and since the point of that is to get the people, those amounts typically go to retaining the people. And many of the people I've known have done really well by employee equity, a couple with multiple 7 figure payoffs, some with instant retirement amounts, a couple with serious maybe-I-buy-a-jet megawealth. It's not guaranteed like a FAANG salary (which actually isn't completely, the past few years have seen great stock appreciation), usually it takes a few rolls of the dice, but it's just not accurate to describe it as a definite 0. Startup selection ability pays a serious role here, I've seen people whose picks I shake my head at consistently, and some people who can home in on successful ones like heatseeking missiles. If you're the type to take the story of a business person about lofty valuations and prospects at face value, though, you're probably going to have a bad time and end up bitter and talking about how bad a deal startups are on the internet.
- TuringNYC 6y agoSelecting at random, i'd disagree with you. Selecting with loaded dice sounds intriguing. Can you please share some high level selection criteria to evaluate potential startup employers? The only one i follow is repeat-founder-previous-exit.
- ericd 6y agoLike investing in companies, its not a list of hard and fast criteria. You have to ask yourself if you could reasonably see this company being huge ($10B+) - do they have a great product? Does this have an aha! feel like Stripe and Dropbox did at their public launches? Do the founders really understand their market well? What are the risks - is this a hardware startup in a totally new market? Is the market saturated? How do people feel about the existing products? And do the founders respect you enough to share cap table/preference overhang, the percentage your equity stake represents, and growth metrics? Also, value your equity stake at the current valuation, not a future one - the current valuation already has the expected future growth priced in. What is that equity grant worth per year that it vests? Do you need a larger grant to make it worth the salary disparity vs your other offers? But basically, you really need to do your homework and treat it like you’re making an investment.
- TuringNYC 6y agoThanks for the detail. For everyone else, the last point is CRUCIAL > treat it like you’re making an investment Remember, if you are giving up a market total-comp package (e.g., 200 or 300k+) for a below-market startup package -- you are literally investing the difference. Treat the difference as an investment. Also keep in mind, unlike public stock or real estate investments this major, you also often have no visibility into financials -- discount for that. You also cant sell when you may need to -- discount for that also. Unlike a property or stocks, you dont get interim dividends/yield -- discount for that also. You may also be forced to invest heavily or forgo stock if you leave the company -- discount for that.
- 6y ago
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoAgreed, but that's why my argument is that if you have the chance to work at a FAANG, work there first, then you can easily afford to take time off and do whatever you want after a few years.
- TuringNYC 6y agoAnd that is if you even have 1-4%. It is common to get 5,000 or 10,000 or some other amount of options/shares while having now access to the cap table -- you know the numerator but not the denominator and no details on preference. The only realistic value to assign is zero.
- brightball 6y agoI did the math one time, many years ago when I was working for a London based startup. They offered me a small portion of equity with vesting to offset the lower salary. If the company sold for $10 million, I would have ended up with about one years worth of the lower end salary...which was about 1/2 of what I could make from an average offer in rural parts of the US. Ten years later, the company finally sold.
- Swizec 6y agoI think there’s a sweet spot in well-funded Series A companies. You get the benefit of a small team and large impact inside the org which feels nice to a certain kind of person. The company is big and mature enough that you get decent impact on the world as well. Also great for many people And most importantly, the company can afford to pay well. Not quite FAANG level, but plenty for you to reasonably plan to retire (in a FIRE way) at 50 instead of 65. And heck if it does hit, you’re early enough for a nice cushy bonus. edit: yes the difference in comp is easily 100k+, but making 180k+ cash to not be a small cog in a gigantic machine, to me, doesn’t sound that bad
- ffdjjjffjj 6y agoNot even close to FAANG level compensation in my experience. I’m just a moderately experienced backend/infra person and VC backed startups would straight up tell me they can’t compete when I told them what FAANGs had offered. We’re talking well over 100k difference in TC, and a significant difference in cash, and that’s not even accounting for liquidity.
- ghaff 6y agoIt's not just startups. The reality is that (as a developer or certain other types of positions) if you can get a job at one of these companies and are OK with working for them, especially in SV, no one else outside of maybe finance for certain skills is going to seriously salary match. Some people are less concerned about the money but many are indeed focused on maximizing their comp.
- marcinzm 6y agoThe cash difference (RSUs are cash) between startups and FAANG is something like $200k+/year if you're moderately senior. That goes up if you're lucky or good enough to get promoted further within FAANG. Startups tend to cap compensation for ICs pretty heavily. That's a lot of money to give up.
- mooreds 6y ago> Of course, not everyone can get an offer at a FAANG Note that this is true for many reasons, not all of which are related to technical ability. Not everyone should try to get a FAANG job, either. Factors candidates may consider: * how much time they want to spend interviewing/prepping * what their previous experience has been * where they went to school * where they are willing to live * what type of work they like to do * what type of organizations they enjoy being part of (largeco, smallco) * how much control they want over their work * what kind of impact they want to have * how much they want to learn (and what type of knowledge--general vs specific) In addition to salary, all of these play a role in determining whether a startup, small biz, other software company or FAANG make sense for an individual.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoBut I'm making the argument that most of the bullet points in your list make no sense to consider because the remuneration at FAANGs is usually so much more, and that money would then give you the freedom to do what you want. I mean "how much time they want to spend interviewing/prepping"?? If a FAANG will average 2-3x payout, it would be insane not to be willing to prep for literally months if that made the difference between getting a job and not.
- mooreds 6y agoIs someone making 450k in SV (renting a home, commuting hours each way, having to fly to see family) really living a better life than someone making 150k in, say Birmingham? Where they could work from home, live close to family, have a bike commute? It's not for me (or you) to decide for others, however :) . I just think there are many more dimensions than raw salary to consider. You could work like a dog for 5 years at a FAANG, make a ton of money, and die just after you retire. It's all weighing the risks and rewards and there isn't a formula for that. BTW yes, 2-3 months of free time to prep may not be worth it given: * one will miss/sacrifice other aspects of life * one may not get the job. Nothing's guaranteed, after all * the job may not be right even if they get it
- 6y ago
- unishark 6y agoAre you counting the FAANG stock performance of the last few years as part of that "no risk" alternative? Because that's hindsight. Stock is always a risk (apart from same-day sales, which only net a small percentage and may be blacked out). And you're kinda simultaneously arguing it's a good outcome and a bad one, in both cases the reason is the founder owned most of it. The net is that it's a mediocre outcome, just that in this case one guy did ok. If you can get nine other people to contribute towards building up your side project to sell for an average market price of the technology and business, you can get more, sure. But it's not "successful startup" more.
- codegeek 6y agonot everyone works at a startup or small company to cash out someday. Lot of people just get a regular job at these companies just like they would at a large company. There is no expectation of any additional payout because they are employees who get decent salary, benefits and are happy to go home with a work life balance. If you want founder benefits, you have to be willing to work like a founder and most people don't want to do that contrary to what HN crowd may think or believe.
- picodguyo 6y agoVery much disagree just because, FAANG or not, working for a large corporation is not for everyone. That said, I would never work under a solo founder for the reasons exemplified by this outcome. I don't even like VCs and I feel like what was pulled here was pretty galling. How does someone rationalize calling up an early investor and telling them to eat their investment because...more money for me?
- gumby 6y ago> Of course, not everyone can get an offer at a FAANG, but again, if you could get an offer, startups basically never make sense anymore. You almost always will get more even if the startup hits, which is rare. Of course plenty of people prefer to work at startups because the environment is more fun and you have direct influence on what ships and often direct contact with customers. Remember when Google suddenly gave an across-the-board 10% raise to every employee to try to stave off defections to startups? Sure, there are certain jobs that are fun (depending on your interests) and of course it's easy to find "phone it in" positions at FB and Google, but most of my friends avoid FAANG or are glad they left. Once your comp hits $X there's more to life than money.
- kmonsen 6y agoIt was a 25% raise across the board. Some of that was converting potential bonus into salary, but still that was a good day.
- tinyhouse 6y ago> Even the founder probably got less than a mid/senior level FAANG employee would get (and the FAANG employee had no risk) Not really... he's been working on the startup for 7 years. Let's assume he had an average salary of 150K during those years. Plus he got $3.7M on the acquisition (it's not clear from his post if that's what he takes home or if it's pre-tax). That's 4.75M. Now let's assume a senior engineer in FAANG with a an average salary of $350K for 7 years. That's 2.45M. That's a very rough comparison and not taking into account taxes (the FAANG engineer is likely to pay more money in taxes overall). But the bigger difference is how he spent those 7 years. He spent it building and managing his own company with all the freedom in the world. Compare that to a senior engineer in FAANG... Update: someone in the comments mentioned he'll likely not need to pay any federal tax on the acquisition money. That makes a huge difference and the take home gap is much larger than my initial estimate.
- humanlion87 6y agoAll the freedom in the world, and all the responsibility in the world too. The constant pressure to make the correct decisions for over 7 years would definitely be worth a 2x multiplier at least right?
- tinyhouse 6y agoIt's definitely worth the multiplier. But that's not the right question imo. The question is if his well being was affected by that responsibility. From his post I didn't get the impression he was under a lot of pressure (unlike a senior FAANG engineer...). He worked hard of course but that doesn't mean he suffered. He just lost interest. I'm not saying running a company is not stressful. Of course it is. Even is it's yours and no one can fire you. But it's very different when you're the one who is making the decisions and not depending on other people and politics.
- texasbigdata 6y agoThe federal reserve keeps statistics on this and I believe there is a business school professor at Harvard Biz that did a significant review: entrepreneurship on _average_ underperforms just taking a job. On net, mostly individuals lose money because like OP the outcome is mediocre to poor and very lengthy, even thought some do very very well.