12 ms·
I know there's a trope about the naive founder getting screwed by shifty-eyed VC sharks, but it really sounds like Josh screwed his investors and employees here
by pc86 6y ago
I know there's a trope about the naive founder getting screwed by shifty-eyed VC sharks, but it really sounds like Josh screwed his investors and employees here.
> I wanted them to at least get their money back, but ultimately, for the $4m purchase price to work, we’d need to ask them to walk on their [$800,000] investment.
He clearly didn't want it very badly, then. Nearly $3 million wasn't enough? That's about $420k per year for the time he put in, not counting anything he already took out. Keeping the extra money only increases that to about $530k/yr.
And it sounds like the early employees get nothing, other than not getting fired immediately.
I like the Baremetrics product but man this really leaves a bad taste in my mouth about Josh personally.
- Shpigford 6y agoYou're making a veritable crap-ton of assumptions here. Happy to talk about specific concerns, but not if you're going in to this with guns blazing looking for a witch to burn.
- ccmcarey 6y agoI'm curious how it works from a technical standpoint. If they invest, do they not own shares of the company, and then during the sale the shares are sold, did they just gift the shares back to you personally? Does that have tax implications?
- Shpigford 6y agoInvestment vehicle was a SAFE. They basically cancelled the SAFE as part of the deal. We've had carryover losses for years, so from a tax perspective, there was no hit on either side.
- ccmcarey 6y agoMakes sense, thanks!
- TechBro8615 6y agoWouldn't this count as a liquidation event and thus give them the right to purchase shares at the price that the buyer is purchasing them at?
- kirubakaran 6y agoDepends on whether it was a stock sale or an asset sale.
- high_derivative 6y agoSo what did employees get?
- Shpigford 6y agoDepends on the employees and when they joined and if they exercised stock options or not. Big range from a few thousand to over $80,000.
- falcolas 6y ago$80k for how many years of work? Unless it’s one, I’m with the parent. I’m sure it’s all legal and ‘equitable’ according to the terms, but that’s peanuts of a return for somewhere between 4 and 7 years of work (based off a typical vesting schedule).
- twox2 6y agoIt's peanuts, but it's also REALITY. Few people get big windfalls working for startups as employees or even founders, but maybe you get a little bonus on top of your salary if there's an exit.
- falcolas 6y agoFew employees may get a windfall in reality, but it doesn’t make it easier to see (nor does it justify the founder’s choices). Those employees are just as responsible for the company’s success as the founder is; it sucks to see them get shafted while the founder walks away with “fuck you” money.
- twox2 6y agoAgreed, which is why it's good that this stuff is being shared. It's a datapoint to consider for those of us as we make career choices. But let's face it, if we are not founders, then we are just "the help".
- pc86 6y agoNow that you mention it, you're right, maybe some of that extra $300k went to the employees? I don't know because I wasn't in the room. I'm curious how much money employees got, and why $3.7 million was enough when $2.9 wasn't.
- Shpigford 6y agoThat entire $300k went to employees. As for $3.7 vs $2.9...that was basically the number that, to oversimplify, would roughly give the outcome I wanted for "retirement" when it comes to investment interest over the next 50 years. Basically, it's the number I felt comfortable with to not instantly feel like I needed to get back to work in a few years.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hajimemash 6y agoHe worked out a win-win deal that gives them publicity and him $4M. In gaming terms, I believe this play is known as a QUAD KILL.
- rocqua 6y agoDid the early employees expect a big payout? Not everyone takes equity when they start a company. If they do not have equity, then they did not get screwed.
- marcinzm 6y agoBased on the numbers employees got 7.5% of the payout. There seems to be 5 current employees on LinkedIn and possibly some earlier employees who bought out their equity. That seems roughly a standard equity split for employees which just goes to show you how depressingly low the standard equity grants are for employees. As people say, don't join a startup to get rich unless you're the founder.
- czbond 6y agoWhich is true, but so is my phrase of "If you want to go broke, found a startup". It cuts very deep on the south side often for founders - whereas employees do get a paycheck. Founders will go YEARS often with little to no income.
- marcinzm 6y agoI don't disagree however the paycheck for engineering employees is often a lot less than one could get from established companies. Every startup I've talked to sold equity as a large part of the total compensation and argued it makes up for the cash difference. So you're being asked to give up $100-200k/year worth of salary by joining a startup which isn't trivial. For a tiny fraction of equity with multiple restrictions (10 year expiration, 90 day window to exercise on leaving, can't sell it, etc.).
- czbond 6y agoWholly agree in most cases the trade is not worth the equity
- nxmnxm99 6y agoThe fact that people on hacker news are angry about this cracks me up. The vast majority of folks here really are the crotchety programmers. Yes, a founder gets compensated significantly more than early employees. Massive shocker. If those early employees were talented enough, they’d be founders getting compensated. I don’t know when this dramatic shift happened to Americans to believe building a successful company is mostly luck, but it’s depressing. Shame on you, HN.
- marcinzm 6y ago>I don’t know when this dramatic shift happened to Americans to believe building a successful company is mostly luck, but it’s depressing. Because it's true? Studies (Gompers, et. al. (2009)) indicate that a second time entrepreneur has a 30% chance of success versus a 20% for a first time one. So there's some skill in it but it mostly comes down to luck. edit: And if you're arguing skill then clearly the skill of the early employees matter tremendously and not just the skill of the founder. So why do you think it's wrong for those employees to get more stake?
- nxmnxm99 6y agoThe fact that that’s your conclusion based on that “study” is exactly why success is easy for some of us
- dasil003 6y agoAnyone who believes startup outcomes are mostly luck doesn’t have what it takes to be a successful founder—you need to have the belief that you can shape the outcome. The idea that we reduce outcomes to two buckets, success and failure and then flip a coin is reductive and belies the decisions and effort that lead every human endeavor to its own unique outcome. Keep in mind corporate projects fail all the time too, we just don’t talk in these terms because people’s salaries and jobs aren’t on the line. Of course luck matters tremendously in terms of riding a series of waves to make a billion dollar company, but it was paved with hard and deliberate work every step of the way. The founders could have reacted and changed direction completely at any stage along the way, therefore these fixed percentage figures are meaningless. How hard did each of those founders work? How many pivots? What type of businesses? What skill sets did they bring? And to your last point, who is saying it’s wrong for employees to get more stake? Of course it’s not wrong, but as an employee you have to negotiate that. People can’t just magically get what they feel they deserve because it would add up to way over 100%. Remember, the company exists because of the founder, doesn’t matter how much you think you contribute, because at the end of the day the company does not exist without them. If you can convince them to give you more then you should, and if you can’t you are free to start your own company. I do not see what is so unfair about this situation and I say that as instrumental #1 employee who got less than 1% for a 9-year effort building a moderately successful company. You don’t get what you deserve in life, you get what you negotiate.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoNot making any other assumptions here, but I think this is a great example of something that's become more and more obvious to HNers over the past few years: from a financial perspective, if you have an opportunity to join a FAANG vs a startup, it pretty much almost always makes financial sense (usually much more sense) to join the FAANG. And since it usually makes a LOT more financial sense, it can often make a lot of the other points moot as well, because you could save so much more working at a FAANG that you could afford to take time off to do whatever you want, or retire early. I mean, in this example Baremetrics actually had a pretty good outcome, better than most, and the employee's basically got very, very little for their overall equity. Even the founder probably got less than a mid/senior level FAANG employee would get (and the FAANG employee had no risk). Of course, not everyone can get an offer at a FAANG, but again, if you could get an offer, startups basically never make sense anymore. You almost always will get more even if the startup hits, which is rare.
- bob33212 6y agoA startup makes sense if you are looking to do something different or to expand you skillset. Working at a major corporation can feel stifling over time. The important thing to understand that there is almost 0% chance that your "1-4%" ownership will ever be more than 6 figures.
- pc86 6y agoAlmost a 0% chance it will be worth anything more than $0 and, maybe, a good story.
- ericd 6y agoThis is a commonly repeated trope, I guess it's to inoculate people from being "suckered in", but it hasn't been true from what I've seen, having lots of friends involved startups. Even "failing" startups frequently get acquihired for non-trivial amounts per person, and since the point of that is to get the people, those amounts typically go to retaining the people. And many of the people I've known have done really well by employee equity, a couple with multiple 7 figure payoffs, some with instant retirement amounts, a couple with serious maybe-I-buy-a-jet megawealth. It's not guaranteed like a FAANG salary (which actually isn't completely, the past few years have seen great stock appreciation), usually it takes a few rolls of the dice, but it's just not accurate to describe it as a definite 0. Startup selection ability pays a serious role here, I've seen people whose picks I shake my head at consistently, and some people who can home in on successful ones like heatseeking missiles. If you're the type to take the story of a business person about lofty valuations and prospects at face value, though, you're probably going to have a bad time and end up bitter and talking about how bad a deal startups are on the internet.
- caffeine 6y agoWhy are you making moral judgements on a business decision? The investors didn't HAVE to take a write down, they chose to. The early employees didn't HAVE to join this company, they chose to. Why do you deem it immoral for a founder to do what is best for himself within the bounds of the agreements he has made? This kind of calling-out is common in HN and quite distasteful. Comments like this all amount to saying "X is immoral because they refused to give a charitable donation to Y". Charity is not a moral requirement and arguably it's not even a moral good.
- matthewmacleod 6y agoWe all make moral judgements like this all the time, and it’s totally normal to do so. Morality isn’t defined by what is legally permissible; it’s possible to be simultaneously entirely compliant with your legal obligations, and an absolute raging arsehole who has acted in an immoral manner.
- imgabe 6y agoIt's not that it's legally permissible, it's that it's within bounds of what all parties agreed to. If I agree to sell you my car for $5,000 then you show up with the money and give it to me and take the car, I don't get to change my mind later and get mad that you didn't give me more and call you immoral.
- Jochim 6y agoFor startup employees it's more like they agree to help fix a car you intend to sell in return for payment and a take in the profits of the sale. A lot of startup exits seem to take the form of you then selling the car to someone for a break even amount, who just happens to also pay you individually an extra $5,000 on the side. Is it a good deal for you? Yes. Is it a scummy move? Yes.
- coward8675309 6y agoThe reality is that many startup employees may have stacked Stanford STEM degrees yadda yadda yadda, but they can’t do basic math, don’t have a good intuitive grasp of probability, have outlandish expectations, and/or don’t ask clarifying questions about the cap table. One of my startups sold for about $25-40MM depending on whether you count pre- or post-earnout. The typical engineer got maybe a quarter of a percent of options on common stock. You’d think that would net out to $62.5K but we had a messy cap table. Various investments’ preferred status ate deeply into what remained for common stockholders. Even if there were no cap table issues, the engineers wouldn’t have been happy, because they hung their hopes and dreams on a multi-hundred-million dollar exit. We experienced 90%+ engineer turnover over the next six months. (We got by just fine.) Rule of thumb: do not join a startup for the money.
- remote_phone 6y agoThe takeaway for me is that if you come across a company that is founded by Josh Pigford, do NOT join it. It’s clear that even if the startup gains traction, he will leave before the value gets maximized and also take the lion’s share of any payout and leave you with practically nothing. That’s not what most people expect when they join a start up, they expect to share in the spoils for their hard work.
- dang 6y agoPersonal attacks like this are not allowed on HN. We ban accounts that do it repeatedly, so please don't. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- polote 6y ago> And it sounds like the early employees get nothing, other than not getting fired immediately. Why early employees should get anything from an acquisition ? If they don't have stocks, they shouldn't, that's how it works, a company belongs to its shareholders, not its employees.
- Topgamer7 6y agoI'm not the most financially savvy person. And I am not an attentive follower of Baremetrics. But wouldn't the investors have been getting dividend returns quarterly all along since their investment was made?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- texasbigdata 6y agoA) dividends require positive cash flow or positive profits, which might have not happened here. B) some preferred equity investors do just that. It’s a bit rarer but you can see a PIK 8% piece of pref with 4% current cash pay and a 4% accruing liability. VC startups don’t generally pay dividends due to the cost of capital requiring reinvestment of profits (if any) to make the growth targets work.
- goodGood00 6y agoI don’t even know you and this post left a bad taste in my mouth personally. Good thing you left your LinkedIn. Other people aren’t obligated to live up to the image you hold of yourself. This has been happening every day in America for decades. I have little sympathy for App Corps everywhere realizing the same thing other industries have dealt with the whole time; your society doesn’t really care. Welcome to free market speculative economics full of disruptive behaviors. Oh what you thought the disruption was just over here? Looks like you got disrupted in an unconsidered way.
- dang 6y agoI didn't see this in time to make a difference by replying, but this crosses into personal attack in a way that's not cool with the site rules: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. If you wanted to say how it seemed to you and raise the questions you felt were unanswered, that's of course fine. But jumping to psychological interpretation and personal denunciation based on a handful of beans in a blog post is not the kind of magic beanstalk we want here.