7 ms·
There are so many amazon products coming out of the pipeline. At first there were amazon batteries and hdmi cables. But now there are weird products like amaz
by m463 6y ago
There are so many amazon products coming out of the pipeline.
At first there were amazon batteries and hdmi cables.
But now there are weird products like amazon gaming desks.
It's not hard to imagine they said "we sell a lot of these" and made their own.
- niffydroid 6y agoYeah and it's because of people like me. When there are 2 items, both pretty much the same, if not from the same factory. If one is sold directly by amazon then I'd pick that one over the third party. Why? It's so much easier to get a replacement/refund/return with amazon than third party sellers. If third parties are all selling the same thing then amazon can probably make more profit than the third party as well, so that's why amazon will also do it. Now I do wish Amazon would pay more tax etc etc, but people like me make it easy for them to operate and do things like this.
- lm28469 6y agoYou're already two steps too far to get out of the system. If all the choices you can imagine are "buy item #1 on amazon" or "buy similar item #2 on amazon" amazon already won
- mytailorisrich 6y agoAmazon wins based on a superior product. I tend to behave like niffydroid for the same reson. From experience Amazon offers a superior experience and a superior service so that, everything being more or less equal, purchasing from Amazon is the safer option. This applied both when choosing among vendors on Amazon, and when choosing a marketplace website. Amazon my be blamed for many things, but not for delivering one of the best delivery and customer service.
- JAlexoid 6y agoThat's a bit different. You are making a decision based on services associated with the product, rather than "this one looks identical and is $2 cheaper". Which is a valid differentiator. But in the end it's not even about that. It's about Amazon not having to go through the cost of marketing(product development, placement, market analysis, etc) to then kick someone that did all of this.
- Closi 6y ago> It's not hard to imagine they said "we sell a lot of these" and made their own. Or more accurately, "this other company sells a lot of these on our marketplace platform, let's make our own, promote it over theirs in search, and undercut them"
- martin_a 6y agoThis is what people seem to be missing. Amazon has the unique insights into sales, CTRs, search results and so on. They are not a simple competitor to your product/brand, they are the super-charged competitor who knows everything about your business AND can simply favor itself in search results, recommendations and so on. The balance is missing.
- code4tee 6y agoBy this logic though shouldn’t “store brands” at the grocery store or “CVS brand” medicine at the drug store also be “illegal.” Both those surely look at which brands are selling before deciding to make a generic to put on the same shelf at a lower price. That’s not a monopoly, that’s standard practice in the retail business. Thus the presence of competing products or the fact that generics appear against popular options is really not a good argument for nefarious activity. The issue from some of those crying foul is really that there isn’t any brand loyalty towards what are commodity items. Why should someone buy your more expensive HDMI cable when a perfectly good one sells for less? It’s a valid question those crying foul need to answer. The answer here of course is that many/most of those doing the selling are middle-men and not actual product manufacturers thus it’s very easy to undercut the person that doesn’t really need to be part of the supply chain.
- randompwd 6y agoYou're completely ignoring the Amazon being the marketplace.
- code4tee 6y agoIs a traditional store also not a marketplace for product manufacturers and distributors to sell their wares? It operates the same way. Drop off a truckload of your stuff at mega-mart’s distribution hub and they take care of the rest via their marketplace for your canned beans or whatever you’re trying to sell. If your product is popular, mega-mart will probably make mega-mart beans and put them right next to yours on the shelf at a lower price. The fact that it happens on a website vs a physical store doesn’t change anything.
- jdmichal 6y agoIt depends. By marketplace, what people mean here is that Amazon is taking zero risk on the inventory. They are merely providing a place to list it. (Along with maybe some other paid services such as fulfillment and inventory management.) Retailers sometimes operate under this model. But retails also sometimes operate under the model where the inventory on their shelves was purchased by them from the manufacturer or distributor. They are taking the risk on the inventory, and not selling means they are losing money. The manufacturers and distributors were already paid. So, I reflect a question back to you: If it's all your owned inventory, what does it matter what name is on the box? No matter what, you the retailer are getting your sale and making the profit. This is not true of the marketplace model. There, whitelabels are directly competing for every sale, and no sales means no money to the manufacturers of those other products. All this is also heavily discounting the fact that Amazon also owns the search. Some people equate this to product placement on shelves, but it's really more like there's two stores. The first store is all Amazon stuff, and you have to walk through that store to get to the second store, where other sellers are.