4 ms·
This is a huge misreading of the situation Naval power is a means of force projection. You can control a sea without a single ship. The US is a naval power. Th
by sudosysgen 6y ago
This is a huge misreading of the situation
Naval power is a means of force projection. You can control a sea without a single ship. The US is a naval power. The US cannot project power into the South China Sea without the use of Naval Power.
China, however, can. Easily, in fact.
Indeed, if you look at the J-20, you will notice that it is significantly larger than the F-22 and F-35. Why is that? In order to store very long range weaponry, and much higher amounts of fuel.
This design aspect reflects the doctrine of sea control via air and missile power, not naval power.
So, if for some reason there were no way to sail a vessel near the SCS, the China automatically, decisively, gains control thereof.
Moreso, China and Russia are significantly ahead of the US in hypersonic flight technology.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> You can control a sea without a single ship Can. Mutual denial isn't control. (Seoul doesn't control the DMZ.) As you said, "naval power is a means of force projection." If China can't sail the South China Sea its options for projecting force e.g. across the Taiwan Strait are diminished. Their coastline will be safer from incursion. But offensive options will be constrained.
- sudosysgen 6y agoI don't know why you would interpret what I wrote as mutual denial. It's not mutual denial, it is supremacy. The US requires naval power to project power into the South China Sea, China doesn't. Without naval power, China has almost uncontested control. US Military Doctrine cannot hope to control the SCS without naval control, Chinese military doctrine is built around that. Even with the US having access to advanced hypersonic missiles, China retains the option of an amphibious landing on Taiwan, for example. Indeed, hypersonic antiship missiles, for a great many reasons, only work very well against large, slow-maneuvering ships that are far away from their destination (and thus offer the attacker the option to choose when to launch), because of kinematic and targeting concerns far away from traditional targeting assets. Their offensive options are more than sufficient using purely air and missile power over the South China Sea. From then on, the ability to project power can be used to disable enemy missile launch options progressively, until the point at which supply lines can be reaffirmed.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> US requires naval power to project power into the South China Sea, China doesn't I understand your point better now. Thank you. > Without naval power, China has almost uncontested control The United States has bases in the region. Large bases. They're not configured to pack a strike group's firepower. But there's no reason they couldn't be. > hypersonic antiship missiles, for a great many reasons, only work very well against large, slow-maneuvering ships Large, slow, surface ships will go the way of the battleship when hypersonic anti-ship missile technology matures. (Unless missile defense does something unexpected.) That doesn't mean other modes haven't been discussed. (Swarms being the concept du jour.) > offensive options are more than sufficient using purely air and missile power over the South China Sea Planes and missiles don't hold territory. Denying large Chinese ships their coast significant curtails their force projection capability onto their neighbors.
- sudosysgen 6y agoPlanes don't hold territory, but neither do boats. Only boots on the ground hold territory. Planes and ships are mostly equivalent. Now, while it's very true that the US has many bases in SCS, they are completely untenable without naval power. Indeed, US bases are fundamentally cut off from US productive capabilities. In a serious war, the US won't be able to hold Guam if they cannot maintain naval control - Guam will be targeted by a large barrage of missiles, and will then be interdicted in the way we discussed earlier Really, only Okinawa is left as a base, and China vs Okinawa is a win for China. The truth is, the US is fundamentally a naval power. The reason why the US, like Britain before, has so many bases all around the world is because it can maintain naval dominance. Without naval dominance, US ground bases lose significant power - its still possible to supply then via air, but how do you maintain air supremacy after a missile barrage without naval dominance This is evident from the makeup of the PLAAF and PLARF. If you look at most Chinese platforms, you can notice the emphasis on range. Indeed, the Chinese military trains to disable Guam without any naval usage, and without the use of tankers. The US, on the flipside, cannot supply Guam sustainably without the use of naval power. I think that we were living the past 40 years in a kind of military anomaly, where the US basically didn't have to care about overextending its supply lines, and the basis of that is unpredecented total naval domination. Without that, the world completely changes, and the advantage of any given theather being close to your mainland increases significantly. Now, of course, while I think China would be able to achieve its strategic objectives, the US is going to inflict incredible amounts of damage before that could be possible, which is why, unless somehow the conflict is forced, I don't think they will attempt this until much more than five years.
- renewiltord 6y agoThe US has an unsinkable aircraft carrier. The only way China gets the SCS is if the US withdraws.
- ajmadesc 6y agoIt's yuge! You're gonna love it. Its the best, unsinkable really! The titanic of aircraft carriers. Believe me chyna won't know what hit'em.
- renewiltord 6y agoHaha, it's a term https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unsinkable_aircraft_carrier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unsinkable_aircraft_carrier I'm not bigging it up.
- FrojoS 6y agoI think he/she is talking about Guam.
- bigbizisverywyz 6y agoAdded to that China has built the world a really nice base near the Spratlys that I'm sure could be quite quickly overwhelmed by another country and used as a nice forward base to control the SCS. Very nice of them to build that.
- sudosysgen 6y agoGuam is not sinkable, but it's very vulnerable to mission kills. Guess what's the point of the PLA Rocket Force? Hint: they train often about massive strikes on Guam and Okinawa. If US bases are disabled by overwhelming missile attacks, and hypersonic missiles successfully interdict the US Navy, it's only a matter of time before Chinese air superiority over them makes them completely useless and barren. Remember, the US is a fundamentally naval power. The US simply cannot project power outside of the Northern Atlantic without it's naval capabilities.