5 ms·
> a fair chance at life If you eliminate meat and dairy, those animals won’t have any life at all. The only reason they are there is because humans eat them.
by amanaplanacanal 6y ago
> a fair chance at life
If you eliminate meat and dairy, those animals won’t have any life at all. The only reason they are there is because humans eat them.
- sc4les 6y agoHaha what. So it's okay to have dog fights since the dogs wouldn't be born otherwise? That's such a weird argument
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoI quoted the part I was responding to. I wasn’t making any argument about the larger question as to whether keeping animals is moral.
- moab 6y agoI am sure we would still have some number of dairy cows like the lovely highland cows that this person takes care of: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YmBYs53quP8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YmBYs53quP8 Their population would be greatly reduced, but is having a billion consciousnesses in a mediocre state and potentially suffering somehow better than having a few orders of magnitude fewer consciousnesses that are properly cared for and living more "natural" lives? It is hard to say without getting into the details, but from a high-level utilitarian perspective, one feels that the latter is somehow more preferable, although doing any kind of arithmetic with souls is a risky business.
- sunwukung 6y agonot much of a life really is it? That aside, it would make room for the non-livestock animals to live on the planet, reintroduce some biodiversity and create genetic firewalls to stop pandemics going absolutely buckwild.