8 ms·
War should sicken everyone involved, with each soldier that comes home dead acting as a motivation to ask the question "Is this worth the cost?". If one side ne
by nomel 6y ago
War should sicken everyone involved, with each soldier that comes home dead acting as a motivation to ask the question "Is this worth the cost?". If one side never has to ask that question, how do you slow the war machine?
Related, I'm currently not afraid of my government using the military against us any time soon. I think the morals of the soldiers would severely limit this. With a fleet of robots, it seems it would be much easier to suppress the people.
Everyone knows this is the future, and saw it coming, but wow, I naively thought it would take longer.
- darawk 6y agoThe problem with war is that if your side doesn't develop its armies, the other side will. Today, that other side is China. For all the faults of the United States, of which there are many, i'd prefer it any day over the Chinese politburo.
- disown 6y agoThat's funny cause it was the "chinese politburo" that liberated the chinese from the united states which invaded and occupied it for 100 years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yangtze_Patrol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yangtze_Patrol But even if you are being sincere, and usually nobody using china as a boogeyman are, we aren't using our military to defend ourselves from a nonexistent chinese invasion. We used our military to kill iraqis, syrians, libyans, vietnamese, etc. If chinese did 1/100th of what we did, hypocrites would be crying they were the most evil nation on earth. We have nukes to deal with china. We don't have armies to deal with china. They've got 1.4 billion people. Pretty much all our wars have been offensive wars of conquest/genocide/domination. But yeah, it's china that's the bad guy. Can you think of the last defensive war we've fought? Even ww2 wasn't really a defensive war as we already attacked japan with sanctions. Edit: > China is not yet strong enough to do that outright with the west like it does within Asia and its maritime claims. Within Asia? Are you saying it's china that has troops in korea, japan, etc? It isn't china that colonized philippines, indonesia, india, etc. Lets be honest here, asia isn't in need of liberation from china, it's in need of liberation from the west. Just think about it. > With the west, it has taken on a different approach: infiltrate all levels of political, educational, and corporate institutions. Is that why everyone has a good opinion of china? China has infiltrated everything, that's why we started a trade war with china? If anything, I could understand if you said israel or saudi arabia has infiltrated all levels. But certainly not china or russia. When it comes to china, all I see is projection. Everything we are accusing china of doing, we are guilty of. We are the ones who invaded and brutalized asia ( including china, india, etc ). We are ones that invaded and occupied. And as best as I can tell, it's us who are meddling in chinese affairs and telling them what they should do or not do. Edit1: > I can't name another empire or superpower in human history that has shown more restraint. Is this a joke? We wiped out an entire continent full of people. Dozens of native nations were exterminated. We dropped nukes on civilians. That's restraint? And we've been involved in wars in every corner of the earth. What amazing restraint. For those hypocrites downvoting me, try replacing US with china for every historical act. 9/11 happens and china invades afghanistan and iraq murdering hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians. I bet every hypocrite downvoting would call them monsters.
- ponker 6y agoChina is using its money to achieve world domination in such a vastly smarter way than the US (Belt and Road initiative, controlling natural resources) that I expect my children will be learning Chinese someday the way that Chinese kids had to learn English.
- frequentnapper 6y agoAnd discriminated against for not being Chinese regardless.
- ponker 6y agoWell, I expect that China is building world domination for the benefit of the Chinese people, not the benefit of everyone who comes under their dominion, similar to the white men who built American world domination.
- _wt8k 6y agoThis is a false moral equivalence. The US was founded on the idea that "all men are created equal." The US has made terrible mistakes, such as not immediately banning slavery and not extending voting rights to women, and the US still has room to improve today. However, the founding ideas of the US provide a mandate and inspire people to work towards a more equal society. I would greatly prefer the US over China as the world hegemon. I am Chinese-American, so if China were to displace the US as world hegemon and put Han people at the top of society, that would personally benefit me. However, I do not want that, as I support racial equality.
- hungryhobo 6y agoand china is called "the people's republic", what US or China call themselves is irrelevant. I am Chinese as well, I do not think Chinese has ambition for world domination, but I believe it deserves the right to develop and enjoy a living standard similar to the west.
- blackrock 6y agoChina for all of their 5000 years of existence as a civilization, has never invaded a distant country. They have never brought wars, death, destruction, slavery, genocide, and concentration camps to those distant lands. Yes, they expanded along their periphery, which is how they got to their size today. But even when they had boats, they visited as far away as Africa, and traded with them, instead of enslaving them. However, in contrast, let’s list all the countries that have enslaved foreign lands. Britain, France, Spain, Portugal, Germany, United States, Netherlands, Australia. Yes, you guessed it. All these are European countries that have brought an untold number of deaths and destruction to the lands that they visited. But of course, you are free to turn a blind eye to all their injustices that they have done in the past.
- refurb 6y agoChina for all of their 5000 years of existence as a civilization, has never invaded a distant country. I like how you inserted "distant" in there as if it matters. Even in just recent history, China has: - Invaded Vietnam, purely for political reasons as they were stymieing China's aspirations in SE Asia, Cambodia in particular - They provided military support to North Vietnam as a way to increase their sphere of influence and offset the USSR in SE Asia - They are currently expropriating land and sea for economic purposes that although justified in their own public statements, I'm not sure even they believe
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>I like how you inserted "distant" in there as if it matters. He/she likely needed to include that as a way to ignore the Tibetan elephant in the room.
- jcranmer 6y agoIf you're going to count the United States as having "enslaved foreign lands", you'll have to include the Chinese domination of Korea, Mongolia, Manchuria, Tibet, and the Tarim Basin at various points in history, since those are ethnically non-Chinese areas that were ruled by China at different points in history. China also established a pretty extensive tributary system in the past, requiring a variety of local states to pay tribute every few years. This is really venturing far from my knowledge of history, but I believe this system would have included much of modern central Asia (the -stans), and all of East and Southeast Asia, through much of the Indonesian islands.
- nexuist 6y agoWhile it is usually the assumption that only one side has access to some kind of groundbreaking technology in these dystopian futures, that is rarely the reality in actual conflicts. Consider the Arab Spring, largely held with cellphones most of us would consider heavily outdated. Citizens were still able to communicate and plan protests against the will of their governments despite the fact that their governments obviously had the capital and resources to invest in better technology than existed in consumer hands at the time. In a civilized world, the only thing stopping rapid equalization of technology in peoples' hands is intellectual property law, preventing thousands of copycat companies from ripping off the new iPhones until the price is so violently driven into the ground that you can find them at dollar stores. In a world at war, IP laws don't apply, and the only thing stopping the "other side" from standing up their own robot army is the will to invest in and support that technology. We may consider it to be secret government technology now, but all you need is one hardware hacker with some JTAG wires and one disabled unit for all of their secrets to spill out onto the open Web.
- jariel 6y agoThe Arab Spring was mostly a failure, and then up against some very weak an ill-funded regimes. 'The people' are never going to gain access to networks of information systems, complicated weapons, training / support etc.. You can overthrow a weak government by getting a lot of people on board, some of them with AKs, but not much otherwise. And it's not 'IP laws' that stop China from building the same weapons as the US it's 'trade secrecy' - my gosh Boeing doesn't just 'patent and make public' their tech, they keep it very secret. Also - there's tremendous 'know how' in there, all the unspoken stuff, skill, knowledge that isn't very well summarized in any kind of document. China in 2020 is still having a hard time making it's own 5th gen jet engines, having to buy from Russia, though that may change.
- nexuist 6y ago> 'The people' are never going to gain access to networks of information systems, complicated weapons, training / support etc.. Who make up those networks if not people? Turncoats decide the fate of battles for a reason. The government cracks down hard on people like Snowden for a reason. These networks are only as secure as the weakest, and least loyal, link. > my gosh Boeing doesn't just 'patent and make public' their tech, they keep it very secret. How secret can you keep an aircraft once it gets shot down? The Russians reverse engineered the B-29 [1] , the Americans reverse engineered the Hind [2], the Chinese reverse engineered the F-22 [3], in part using wreckage from an F-117: "On 27 March 1999, one of the US Air Force’s stealth bombers was shot down in the NATO raid of Yugoslavia during Operation Noble Anvil. The wreckage was sent to China to study the stealth phenomenon except for the cockpit, which remains in a Belgrade museum." > Also - there's tremendous 'know how' in there, all the unspoken stuff, skill, knowledge that isn't very well summarized in any kind of document. Of course! It would take time to unravel this "know how" and get it documented. But the clues are there if you can afford to look. Almost every proprietary system can be documented and clean-room-reverse-engineered if you dedicate enough resources to it. Could a people's army do this? Maybe not, but it's not impossible either. > China in 2020 is still having a hard time making it's own 5th gen jet engines, having to buy from Russia, though that may change. I can guarantee you this project would advance much quicker if we were actually at a state of war, rather than peace with heightened tensions. These engines are not the end-all-be-all when compared to all their other priorities, but they could become a priority if war breaks out (obviously I hope it never does). When they do become a priority, history is on their side in terms of insurmountable odds beaten by skilled teams (see Manhattan Project, Have Blue, etc.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tupolev_Tu-4 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tupolev_Tu-4 [2] https://www.wearethemighty.com/mighty-trending/that-time-army-night-stalkers-stole-an-advanced-russian-helicopter https://www.wearethemighty.com/mighty-trending/that-time-arm... [3] https://theprint.in/defence/china-reverse-engineered-copied-technology-latest-j-20-fighter-jet/37266/ https://theprint.in/defence/china-reverse-engineered-copied-...
- xwdv 6y agoIs it worth the cost? Literally, yes. The United States having the world’s most powerful and expansive military is what makes it the best place to invest your money and keep your stuff. I keep all my stuff in the United States, don’t know about you.
- umanwizard 6y ago> The United States having the world’s most powerful and expansive military is what makes it the best place to invest your money and keep your stuff. This needs a stronger argument. Russia, North Korea, and Turkey have very powerful militaries, yet are much less safe for investment than various comparatively weak small European countries. A country being a good climate for business seems to have more to do with a lot of factors other than military strength.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y ago> yet are much less safe for investment than various comparatively weak small European countries. That is because those weak small European countries’ security is guaranteed by the United States and its allies. Ultimately, force underlies prosperity and stability. Right now the United States maintains the greatest ability to apply force and subsidizes the security and guarantees the security of Europe.
- hardlianotion 6y agoUnnecessarily, I might add. Russia has fewer people and spends less on its military than the EU, which seems to piss its military budgets up a wall.
- save_ferris 6y agoThis might be a controversial take, but I grew up in a very rural community in the Midwest and military service was widely seen as a pathway to stability and to a degree, glory, for those that didn’t have the opportunity to pursue higher education. It’s essentially a massive job creator that we don’t really talk about as a massive job creator. It’s always framed with national security in mind. We often talk about the human cost of war, but as I’ve gotten older and seen the never-ending military presence in the Middle East, I can’t help but wonder how much of that is driven by this political desire to provide these kinds of jobs to thousands of young men and women that don’t have many opportunities back home. Of course, it’s not really talked about this way, but I remember first thinking about it watching Ken Burns Vietnam war series. It wasn’t the rich kids that died in that war either, it was the children of the working class. Military is just as much of a domestic political tool as it is a force to shape geopolitics globally, and it’s deeply effective in communities that are reliant on military presence.
- skinner927 6y agoThe best way to jump from lower class to middle class in the US is to enlist.
- hunter-gatherer 6y agoGrew up lower class, and am now comfortably making 120k a year. Family and extended family is all still lower class. The military gave me structure, discipline, and then a GI bill. Only catch was to survive a deployment in 07. But yeah, my case is not unique, and most the people I served with are doing well now compared to where they would have been without it.
- cbm-vic-20 6y agoBeing too lazy to research this myself, I wonder if the "survival rate" of someone in the military is higher than the rate in other jobs, like construction.
- 6y ago
- tsjq 6y agoAnd these army surplus robots would soon be sold to Police Departments to augment their patrolling capabilities.
- 8note 6y agoMercenaries already exist, and the mercenary leaders hold political power. I don't think robots change the picture significantly. When you say the morals of the soldiers, maybe you mean racism of the soldiers? American soldiers are more than happy to act immorally, and it's not like suppressing and torturing foreigners is very different to home. You can look to Portland for supposedly moral people suppressing locals
- rosywoozlechan 6y ago> I think the morals of the soldiers would severely limit this. You should read War & Peace, or any number of other legendary books about war written since the 19th century to learn how quickly millennia of military training has conditioned young soldiers to turn morality off when it is required of them.
- cutitout 6y agoYes, and then robots (built by people so conditioned, no less) are still infinitely worse than that.
- austincheney 6y agoThe last time the US was involved in anything resembling actual warfare was Vietnam. I can say this as somebody who has been in the Army for 23 years and deployed 5 times. The risk of traditional warfare is astonishing low because the costs are too high and the superior modern force moves too fast. You have to keep in mind 10x more people have died in the Mexican drug conflict than all the years the US had been in Afghanistan. Those things said I find it strange that anytime somebody mentions investment in revision of military tactics or technology somebody cries about some unrelated moral ambiguity from some value vacuum.
- joelwilliamson 6y agoThat 10x figure doesn't sound right to me. Between the Taliban and government forces, Wikipedia says there were over 130,000 killed. Have over a million Mexicans died in the drug war? Otherwise, (as I assume) you are comparing foreigners killed in Afghanistan to Mexicans killed in Mexico, which doesn't seem like a fair comparison.
- austincheney 6y agoTechnically, Afghanistan has been in a continuous state of warfare since 1979 the most bloody of which were the civil wars of armed militias around Kabul in the early 90s although the Soviet invasion was pretty unconcerned with collateral damage. The Taliban eliminated that and arguably saved many lives in the process. In the broadest since the entirety of the Afghanistan conflicts easily stretches into millions dead, but I was only speaking to the US conflict.
- jcranmer 6y ago> The last time the US was involved in anything resembling actual warfare was Vietnam. I'd count the First Gulf War as the last conventional war the US was involved in, although the Iraqi army did not prove up to the task of actually fighting a modern army. If you consider wars the US hasn't fought in, Russia's invasion of Georgia is probably the last conventional war, although again, it was pretty one-sided.
- disown 6y ago> with each soldier that comes home dead Or the hundreds of civilians killed, raped, etc for every soldier killed. The biggest victims of war are the civilians. In ww2, vietnam, iraq wars, etc, the civilians accounted for the vast majority of the casualties, not the soldiers. > how do you slow the war machine? You can't. The elites who control the war machine control the propaganda in every country. Once they want war, the entire propaganda apparatus beats the war drums and anyone in their way gets steamrolled. Ask the dixie chicks, phil donahue, etc. Remember freedom fries? Go look at how quickly germany turned from being the heart of european civilization to nazi germany. > I think the morals of the soldiers would severely limit this. Has nothing to do with morals. Is it moral to go to another country and kill people? If you are labelled "enemy of the state" ( a great movie btw ), then you are fair game. > Everyone knows this is the future, and saw it coming, but wow, I naively thought it would take longer. It's not the robots that are worrisome. It's the concentration of money and power.
- Gustomaximus 6y agoI feel one of the domestic risks here is the combination of robots & less than lethal weapons. For a gov to take the step of gunning down crowds is significant with backlash. And while I dont doubt countries could head this way I think for the west its much easier for governments to deploy robots that use any of the less than lethal tech and keep enough of the population on side while they deal with those <insert politics you dont like> trouble makers. And this could be the start of a very slippery slope. I really think this is going to be one of humankinds great challenges: 1) tech where few can increasingly control many + 2) Advanced nations ability to conduct war with limited human cost on their side.
- natmaka 6y ago> 1) tech where few can increasingly control many > 2) Advanced nations ability to conduct war with limited human cost on their side. Indeed. Moreover anti-war protests often are conducted on a "don't get our children killed in your war" stance, therefore 2) will considerably reduce them. See squarefoot's comment above. 1) will be useful against protests at home, and also (to some extent) to control the population of an occupied country.