10 ms·
The Secret Math Society Known as Nicolas Bourbaki
- pattusk 6y agoI wish more science, and generally more work was done this way. Dispense with ego-flattering prizes, narratives of discovery that put lone geniuses in the spotlight, turning PIs heroes and dictators at the expense of their team... I understand this is not practical for all fields, but it would alleviate much of the pettiness and unethical behaviors that have become so normalized in academia.
- jacobolus 6y agoI am no expert but it is not my impression that adopting a group pseudonym eliminated politics or pettiness from the behavior of people inside or outside. But maybe makes the politics a bit less public/transparent? One criticism I have heard from professional mathematicians is that Bourbaki wasted a whole generation of French talent, pulling the best young mathematicians away from their own useful and interesting research to assign to them a project of marginal benefit if any, because being a member of Bourbaki was in itself prestigious. The work tries to be entirely self-contained instead of part of a conversation, which leads to insularity, arbitrary “not-invented-here” reformulation of established concepts, ignoring outside developments, and lack of historical links and attributions. It is essentially all reworking of previously known mathematics, rather than any new discovery. I am not a mathematician, and I don’t really have insight into the opportunity cost of research potential for the people involved, but personally I think the Bourbakist style has been very harmful to mathematics: it is entirely dry and formal, eschewing motivation, examples, or pictures. As a reference for professionals it might be okay, but the same style has infected broad swaths of mathematics teaching, and it serves to chase away many newcomers, almost like a kind of hazing ritual. But Bourbaki is to say the least a controversial group. I don’t think it should uncritically be taken as a model for other researchers.
- andi999 6y agoThis is really a good question. On the one hand the work of bourbaki was important, the foundation of math was shaky (I heard there were proof of some theorems and the negative of the same theorem). But then it somehow seems to destroy the spirit of mathematics. Arnold wrote about it: https://www.uni-muenster.de/Physik.TP/~munsteg/arnold.html#:~:text=by%20V.I.,Paris%20on%207%20March%201997.&text=In%20the%20middle%20of%20the,to%20divide%20physics%20and%20mathematics https://www.uni-muenster.de/Physik.TP/~munsteg/arnold.html#:....
- andi999 6y agoTo add: I dont know what the solution to this is. So lets say there are two types of approaching math. Approach one is formal/rigid (caring about Axiom of Choice, Set theoretical foundations ..:-)) the other one still (partially) rigorous but more classical in spirit. A big question for me is, how is actually research done? Is it more the first or more the second approach? So what are possible solutions? I dont know. If you are trained in the first approach, you usually loose the ability to gloss over the gaps in the second approach. If you are trained in the second you cannot (or very difficult) come around the first one. And then there is physics which uses the sloppy (and often not correct) version of the second approach. I once asked Serge Lang about this (phrasing:'what about physicist getting the right result with wrong mathematics' (thinking about renormalization)). Lang replied:'this is God's way of calculation'.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoOh wow. So it looks like that the reason why I suddenly got 'bad' at math towards the end of high school might be due to the switch to this hyper-formal way of teaching mathematics, instead of using a more geometric/physic way ?
- andi999 6y agoCould be. Although high school (at least where I am) only teaches a tiny drop of mathematics (so the other style is also difficult.). But generally the is an adaptation problem/challenge in the first two semesters of math students where usually only solving a lot of problem and getting them corrected helps. But dont worry, these things can be overcome (do not fight them at your current stage if you are still a student). Just dont believe the 'hours needed' in the description of the modules (they are politically decided). Generously work around the clock for the first few years..... edit: more seriously: although working hard is important: go to the office hours of your TA and/or prof and discuss the work you are doing. Usually no student does that and you will learn a lot.
- dnpp123 6y agoYou have to put back the creation of the group in context though. Back then philosophers/mathematicians were kinda popular (think Sartre, Beauvoir and so on) so making such a group draw a lot of more public attention than it would now. Sadly, I doubt that such a group could be created now.
- hurrynot 6y agoI think the group writing the HoTT book (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homotopy_type_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homotopy_type_theory ) probably come close, though.
- v01dlight 6y agoI have actually heard of this group before, thanks to an obscure reference in a Twenty One Pilots song oddly enough: https://genius.com/15480382 https://genius.com/15480382
- imaginetop 6y agoI came here to see if anyone mentioned this lol This band has adopted the character of Nicolas Bourbaki in their concept album Trench. It's interesting since they commonly use the symbol Ø in their branding, which was introduced in mathematics by Nicolas Bourbaki to denote an empty set.
- jbrooksuk 6y agoI also checked to see if they were mentioned! It’s interesting how a band can make you aware of something very obscure (outside of my domain, that is).
- hackeraccount 6y agoI'd heard of it as well - there was a novel that had a group of aging Biologist get together and publish anonymously under the name. The clever part of the novel - and I can't even remember the name - was that the "discovery" they made was PCR. It made it seem a lot better then if the novelist had just created some magic invention for the characters. Made it much more grounded - as I remember it. That said, how good could it be if I can't remember the name of the book.
- hackeraccount 6y agoThe Bourbaki Gambit (1994) by Carl Djerassi
- adw 6y agoCarl Djerassi was of course himself a world-class drug researcher: he has a good claim to being the most important figure in the development of oral contraceptives for women.
- justjonathan 6y agoI learned about this from the excellent BBC Radio series a brief history of mathematics with Marcus Du Sautoy. Here is the relevant episode: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00stcgv https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00stcgv
- melling 6y agoThe last episode of this BBC podcast series: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00stcgv https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00stcgv all the episodes were great.
- idoh 6y agoCan’t have an article about Nicolas Bourbaki without bringing up the mystery of nickb on Hacker News. Who was he? Paul G? A group of power users? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10535620 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10535620 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=152428 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=152428
- sillysaurusx 6y agoI asked pg directly whether he was nickb, and he said no. More specifically, he said “not only was I not nickb, but I have no idea who he was.” pg is many things, and he has bent the truth occasionally, but a liar he isn’t. Make of that whatever you will; it’s the closest you’ll get to an answer. However, the early secret sauce of HN was to hunt for stories manually and to keep the front page interesting every day. (It’s today’s secret sauce too.) One person can do it, but they’d have to spend several hours per day, like a full time job.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dang 6y agoI thought there had been more Bourbaki on HN before, but all I can find is: 2020 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23901507 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23901507 2019 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23412152 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23412152 2016 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11190443 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11190443
- lsh123 6y agoI have to admit that I did read a couple Bourbaki books. Or should I say “tried to read” because their texts are unreadable to put it mildly. They kill mathematics by removing the beauty of it and instead provide dry and boring texts that could be read by robots. Please don’t try to understand mathematics by reading Bourbaki texts. This is not what mathematics is about.
- drallison 6y agoI used Bourbaki as a second text in an advanced math course I took when I was at UC Berkeley in the early 1960's. I remember with delight the spare clarity of the presentation of the material and organic, intuitive organization of the topic. French has always seemed to me to be the language of mathematics, reason, logic (and love).
- tasogare 6y ago> French has always seemed to me to be the language of mathematics, reason, logic For some reason I often find papers and thesis I read in French way more interesting, well thought and presented than most things I read in English. I have a few hypotheses on why I get this impression: 1) the publish or perish culture originated from the Anglo-Saxon world. Until recently the research written in the national language was kinda shielded from it. In Japan for instance, where the higher education is modeled upon the US one, master students are expected to publish at least a conference paper. In France students generally don’t publish anything. 2) the PhD thesis are written differently. Where I’m studying it’s basically slapping three papers together with an introduction and a conclusion. This sometimes leads to awkward thesis and shallow work. Thesis (and HDR) written in Europe are more like a very well structured monograph. 3) the way to use the language is different as well. In French, any intellectual written work will use long and complex sentences (sometimes to a fault) that are cramming few ideas and their relationships. In English the style is to write short sentences, with at most one idea each. I sometimes feel I have to dumb down my writing and splitting sentences while in my native language a Proust-like sentence would be more appropriate.
- 6y ago
- dboreham 6y agoProto-Satoshi
- teruakohatu 6y agoPoorer-than-Satoshi?
- kumarvvr 6y agoI remember reading a set of books by Bourbaki, I distinctly remember being awed by the style and approach. I though this guy was awesome. I find it hard to comprehend that 'he' was actually many authors. Really surprised to find the style matched up.
- toyg 6y agoA group of contemporary Italian intellectuals set up “Nicoletta Bourbaki”, which is “an inquiry group devoted to the merry debunking of right-wing historical revisionism, history-related fake news and neofascist ideologies. [...] The group comprises historians, researchers in various disciplines, writers and activists. The collective pseudonym is a transgender tribute to the ensemble of mathematicians collectively known as «Nicolas Bourbaki»” [0]. The group published quite a bit of material about the manipulation of Wikipedia entries related to WWI and the Italian Eastern border, and other false historical memes being peddled online. [0] https://www.wumingfoundation.com/giap/what-is-the-wu-ming-foundation/ https://www.wumingfoundation.com/giap/what-is-the-wu-ming-fo...
- aarroyoc 6y agoIn my university in Spain, math students have the Saint Bourbaki day. That day is recognized holiday by the university and they don't have any classes.
- culturedsystems 6y agoThere was an interesting recent article about Bourbaki, and in particular why they wrote in the style that they did, in the New Left Review: https://newleftreview.org/issues/II124/articles/alice-bamford-mathematics-and-modern-literature https://newleftreview.org/issues/II124/articles/alice-bamfor...
- totony 6y agoThis made me think; is there a collection of books or a volume that treats mathematic extensively from base to advanced? Right now everything is divided in specialized books with little to no connection from one to the other. Is there a feynman equivalent for maths?
- reikonomusha 6y agoThe books do have strong connections to one another. They usually list the prerequisites. Math isn’t just one linear subject. The foundations have tons of branches, and the abstract stuff has lots of branches.
- rramadass 6y agoAssuming you are asking in general and not specifically Bourbaki authored; * Mathematics: Its Content, Methods and Meaning by Aleksandrov, Kolmogorov, Lavrentev * The Princeton Companion to Mathematics by Timothy Gowers et al. * The Princeton Companion to Applied Mathematics by Higham et al.
- totony 6y agoI'll take a look, thanks. For bourbaki, I had trouble figuring out what to read first, there are so many separate books. I'll try to figure it out
- arolihas 6y agoIn my experience I’d say just open one, try to read it, and move on to something else if you can’t decipher it. Eventually one will suit you, or none of them if you’re like me :p
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- inglor_cz 6y agoI studied algebra and number theory. Bourbaki was unreadable for me. I would compare it to extremely dessicated, tough jerky made out of the oldest bison ever.
- navanchauhan 6y agoA great video by Ted-Ed titled “The greatest mathematician that never lived” https://youtu.be/0O_boW9YA7I https://youtu.be/0O_boW9YA7I
- stoolpigeon 6y agoThe band Twenty One Pilots references Bourbaki as an integral part of their most recent album, "Trench". They created some pretty intricate puzzles for their fans leading up to the release of the album and it was fun to watch all these (mostly) young people work it out and learn more about math history at the same time.
- posed 6y agoWhere can I get their books? I badly want to read it.
- TheTrotters 6y agoI just came across this site, they seem to have books: https://www.amazon.com/s?k=bourbaki&ref=nb_sb_noss_2 https://www.amazon.com/s?k=bourbaki&ref=nb_sb_noss_2
- TheNorthman 6y ago1. http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=8F89864FED1AA4845F6B500C5E9ABF8E http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=8F89864FED1AA4845F6... 2. http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=FD4A085FE66F570A61104418CBA52B96 http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=FD4A085FE66F570A611... 3. http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=3D0FD4F846B974F5188B70B7ABDF606A http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=3D0FD4F846B974F5188... 4. http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=2E63639FC0764A525609FD6D7012E6CB http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=2E63639FC0764A52560... 5. http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=881279B349E43D6BED46EA108B31D32D http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=881279B349E43D6BED4... And so on...
- posed 6y agoThank you, Sir. Much appreciated. :)
- jungletime 6y agoActually this reminds me of this book series, with a lot of "sacred" math and geometry imagery. https://woodenbooks.com/index.php?id_cms=8&controller=cms https://woodenbooks.com/index.php?id_cms=8&controller=cms