9 ms·
In the Annals of St Bertin there's mention of an attack by the Danes (Vikings) on a region of Francia in 859 AD, where the peasants formed an association to def
by cmrdporcupine 6y ago
In the Annals of St Bertin there's mention of an attack by the Danes (Vikings) on a region of Francia in 859 AD, where the peasants formed an association to defend themselves and fought off the Vikings, and drove them off without the assistance of the Carolingian rulers.
This is reported by the Carolingians as brave but immoral, because Charlemagne had banned any such associations or militias, and military service was reserved for aristocrats only.
The response of the Frankish leadership was to come in and massacre the peasants who had defended their own land. Peasant autonomy and self-defense of any kind could not be tolerated.
- agency 6y agoThe more I hear about this feudalism thing the less I like it.
- peterburkimsher 6y agoSupporters of feudalism are down for the Count.
- lb1lf 6y ago-Fun fact: Feudalism (somehow) lingered on until about a decade ago on the channel island of Sark. That being said, aside from the dubious principle, 21st century feudalism on Sark had little in common with its medieval cousin.
- Ichthypresbyter 6y agoWhich makes sense given that it started with the settlement of the island by Helier de Carteret in 1565, well after feudalism in England was on the way out.
- arethuza 6y agoThe last parts of feudal law in Scotland were only removed in 2000: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abolition_of_Feudal_Tenure_etc._(Scotland)_Act_2000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abolition_of_Feudal_Tenure_etc...
- dragonelite 6y agoThe shitty thing is the west is gradually moving into neo feudalism, like the World Economic Forum said "You'll own nothing, and you'll be happy".
- magicsmoke 6y agoMy pet theory about why modern democracy appeared when it did instead of earlier during the Medieval period is that it coincided with the rise of cheap muskets, which overturned the power dynamic between masses of untrained and unequipped peasants and knights with lifelong combat training and the best armor technology available. When victories started to depend less on whoever had the best elite fighting force and more on whoever had the most muskets in the field, the winner is whoever had a better system for funneling wealth and power to as many people as possible instead of to just a small class of elite fighters. For a new state with little government tax revenue or wealth, the democratic vote was a cheap and effective way for America to raise as many militiamen and muskets as possible. If muskets didn't come onto the military scene when it did and the American revolution was fought between armored knights, I'm quite confident the vote would have remained limited to only landowners that had enough economic surplus to spend their time training and maintaining their war equipment instead of spreading to anyone that could hold a musket. Based on this model, WW2 was probably peak democratic potential. Everyone had the same capacity to hold a rifle or work on an assembly line, and whatever country could mobilize the most workers/soldiers would be the strongest. With automation and computerization, a member of the technology elite that can program a robot to make widgets or shoot hostiles can roll that out to replace millions of humans instantly. The world is reverting back to the economic and technological setup that fostered feudalism, where someone trained from birth with the best equipment can outproduce and outfight a numerically superior force. The big difference between old and neofeudalism I can see is that the technological elites in neofeudalism are more vulnerable than the old military elites because they individually also have lower bargaining power. For a medieval knight, their effectiveness is the same no matter which king they serve under, which gives them plenty of power to switch sides. For a member of the technological elite, you may be so hyperspecialized in your niche that if you leave the system that gives you the ecosystem and tools to do your work, your economic value plunges. An individual chip designer without a company that can pay thousands for monthly EDA software licenses or the millions needed to tape out a chip is as unproductive as any member of the unskilled labor pool. Even the average web developer is dependent on a surrounding national/international technological ecosystem far more than a medieval knight would be on his private estate. In neofeudalism, the real holders of power are the same as in older feudalism. They're propagandists, kings, clergymen, academics, populists, think tanks, revolutionaries, people with enough social acumen to get others to do things that coincide with what they want and make them like it at the same time.
- kebman 6y agoThen you probably won't like what the corporate elite has in store for you either. :)
- forinti 6y agoMy view is that nobility were really like gangs that controlled and fought over territory and extorted the common people. So the current nobility are really just the heirs of criminal associations. They shouldn't have a place in the modern world.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoThat's exactly right, although over time "nobility" added a layer of polish and distance which allowed it to pretend that nobles were more refined, more intelligent, and generally better people - when in fact they were just the most successful crooks. This continued all the way through the 20th century, where the disposable deplorables did the fighting while the aristocracy profited. There were even strong links to drugs. Look up the history of the opium wars for details. Most of the UK's country estates were built from the profits of slavery, drugs, and colonialism - which is just nation-scale feudal conquest painted over with flag-waving patriotism.
- goatinaboat 6y agoThis continued all the way through the 20th century, where the disposable deplorables did the fighting while the aristocracy profited. The upper classes volunteered enthusiastically for WW1 and died in vast numbers in the trenches along with the commoners. Perhaps because they had come to believe their own myths of honour and glory.
- m-p-3 6y agoI see it like all political systems really comes from people stepping up to acquire power over the common people, and over time are given de-facto legitimacy. Kinda like a mobster turning their money into legit business, and eventually their heirs takes over and people forgetting about how it all started.
- redis_mlc 6y ago> military service was reserved for aristocrats only. That varied by region. Often English Lords were required to provide troops or arrows on demand, and those both came from the peasant class. (Frankly, peasant men would have to be tough to work in the fields in the mid-day sun, so were ideal stock for battles.) Otherwise what was the point in appointing nobility if they weren't contributing an army, but just collecting taxes?
- Ichthypresbyter 6y ago"All burgesses and freemen shall have a gambeson, an iron cap and a lance" -English Assize of Arms, 1181. Knights, and freemen who owned more than a certain value of property, were required to own more and better weapons. Later laws extended this obligation to all men not just freemen, and required ownership of bows.
- briefcomment 6y agoI wonder if one day in the distant future, humans will each have their own autonomous mutually assured destruction devices hovering around them at all times, almost like a guardian angel. It would even the playing field in some ways.
- blandflakes 6y agoYou might like Vernor Vinge's work. This is briefly touched on in "Marooned in Realtime", and I suspect a prior novel, "The Peace War" is similarly interesting.
- Robin_Message 6y agoThe "slap drone" of Iain M. Banks' culture performs a similar function in a different way: IIRC, convicted murders are allowed out, but followed forever by an autonomous drone that will stun (slap) them to prevent further crimes.
- adwn 6y agoYou're misremembering a detail: the term isn't "slap drone", but "drone slapped" – as in, you'll be slapped with an electronic ankle bracelet in drone form. That drone doesn't necessarily have to physically hurt or stun you to prevent you from doing something bad; even at the time when Player of Games (in which this concept is explained) is set, drones are powerful and sophisticated enough to displace or physically restrain someone with their field effectors. Also, if you murder someone, you won't be invited to parties anymore.
- Robin_Message 6y agoThank you! That sounds about right. Must put Player Of Games on the re-read pile. And yes, I remember not getting invited to parties is the ultimate sanction.
- nlitened 6y agoIsn’t the second amendment about exactly that?
- faanghacker 6y agoDo you have a source for this? This sounds like a fishy story to me based on my understanding of medieval society: 1. Peasants are often called up for military duty as levies (conscripts), to supplement the knights and men-at-arms. Especially when there wasn't a standing army. 2. Authority wasn't so centralized -- these local matters would be the authority of local lords, not the king.
- somedudetbh 6y ago"In the Annals of St Bertin…"?
- samatman 6y agoThe account you're replying to gave you a source: the Annals of St. Bertin. It's available on Google Books, you have everything you need satisfy your own curiousity.
- sonthonax 6y agoGod, people’s reading comprehension is so poor nowadays.
- sundvor 6y agoAh, the young people... https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20171003-proof-that-people-have-always-complained-about-young-adults https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20171003-proof-that-peo...
- C1sc0cat 6y agoBut that period is dark ages not medieval
- maskros 6y agoThe Medieval period lasted from the 5th to 15th century. The Dark Ages is a misnomer for the early medieval period (5th to 10th centuries).
- jxramos 6y agoYeesh, sort of the exact opposite of a 2nd Amendment right to bear arms.
- romanoderoma 6y agoIt's so ourageous isn't it? a thousand years before the 2nd amendment was conceived, peasant had other preoccupations than bearing expensive, heavy, difficult to handle arms. What were they thinking? Did they not love freedom? It's so incredible that they did not copy the US Constitution, even though the first Constitution in the human history /, the Magna Charts, was written 4 centuries later than the Annales Bertiniani, in 1215.
- romanoderoma 6y agoSeriously guys, 2nd amendment was written in 1791, the Annales Bertiniani are from 840. The idea that the 2nd amendment protects the peasants is also wrong and it's one of the reasons people laugh at USA, when the 2nd amendment was approved, Grand Duchy of Tuscany had already abolished death penalty. 2nd amendment was introduced to permit people to shoot tax collectors (i.e. the British)
- krapp 6y ago>2nd amendment was introduced to permit people to shoot tax collectors (i.e. the British) The 2nd Amendment was introduced because the states were afraid a standing national army would give too much power to the Federal government, so the plan was to have individual states field their own militias instead. Also because the principles of the right to self defense were established in British common law at the time - but that has more to do with keeping cougars and vandals away than any abstract fears of tyranny. You're right that it didn't really protect "peasants" - it mostly protected the interests of rich landowners. Which is, ironically, what Ben Franklin was actually arguing against with his often repeated (and misinterpreted) quote about those who trade a little liberty for safety deserving neither.
- 6y ago
- jml7c5 6y agoDo you have more detail on this? Is there supporting detail from other sources? It's not clear from my brief reading that the association was conclusively for self-defense and held no insurrectionary or political aspect.
- Leherenn 6y agoIt might have started for self-defence, but became insurrectionist once the vikings had been defeated. "Why should we pay fealty to a liege that fails at his most basic duty?" The terms used are "conjurés/conjuration" (from Google: Middle English (also in the sense ‘oblige by oath’): from Old French conjurer ‘to plot or exorcise’, from Latin conjurare ‘band together by an oath, conspire’ (in medieval Latin ‘invoke’), from con- ‘together’ + jurare ‘swear’.). It seems to imply something more than just gather together for self-defence.
- miles 6y ago> the peasants formed an association to defend themselves and fought off the Vikings ... military service was reserved for aristocrats only ... The response of the Frankish leadership was to come in and massacre the peasants Strange that the peasants could fight back a group of Vikings ("the toughest warriors ever" according to National Geographic[0]) but not a bunch of aristocrats. [0] https://www.vikingmartialarts.com/vikingculture/2018/4/4/vikings-the-toughest-warriors-ever-by-tyr-neilsen https://www.vikingmartialarts.com/vikingculture/2018/4/4/vik...
- wyattpeak 6y agoUsing "bunch of aristocrats" pejoratively is a thoroughly modern take. Aristocrats were the best fighters in their day. They were the ones with money for good arms and time to train well, besides which fighting was for many of them their profession. Besides, "toughest warriors ever" sounds more like popular colouring than an academic assessment. I don't know a lot about Vikings but as I understand they were principally raiders, which I would absolutely expect to perform worse than a Frankish aristocrat-led army.
- ReptileMan 6y ago>I don't know a lot about Vikings but as I understand they were principally raiders, which I would absolutely expect to perform worse than a Frankish aristocrat-led army. In a pitched battle, on a open terrain, in a nice weather with preferably not too soft soil. Also if you want to find tough people you look them at the extremes - so high north, or up in the mountains or in the deserts.
- weff_ 6y agoThe 'living in harsh conditions makes you a crazy good fighter" is a meme though, as this historian explains: https://acoup.blog/2020/01/17/collections-the-fremen-mirage-part-i-war-at-the-dawn-of-civilization/ https://acoup.blog/2020/01/17/collections-the-fremen-mirage-...
- wyattpeak 6y ago
- jimmyhachahacha 6y agoI don't think these two events, the Danes raid and the rebellion crush are linked outside of one making the author remind itself about the second. The French translation from Latin http://remacle.org/bloodwolf/historiens/anonyme/annales.htm http://remacle.org/bloodwolf/historiens/anonyme/annales.htm [859] says: > Les Danois dévastent les pays au-delà de l'Escaut. Le commun peuple des pays entre Seine et Loire, conjuré entre soi, résiste courageusement aux Danois établis sur la Seine ; mais sa conjuration étant conduite sans prudence, il est facilement défait par nos grands. Which I would translate (using some true-to-heart adaptation given author period) by: Danes (norsemen) raid country further the Escaut (probably that river in the north). Commoners from between Seine et Loire (in the center so), which were seceding at the time (secede is way too modern but best bears the sense IMO), bravely resist to Danes camping by the Seine; this secession however being lead without much thought, is easily defeated by our rulers (kings or dukes I'd say, and probably over months). These annals are telegraph styled, written by multiple authors, etc. They are kind of notes. Yet they are one of the best material over this period of French history :)
- faanghacker 6y agoThanks for providing the direct citation, which is more specific than just "Annals of St Bertin." > I don't think these two events, the Danes raid and the rebellion crush are linked outside of one making the author remind itself about the second. Sound's like the parent comment's description oversimplified things. I knew it sounded off.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoNo, the text is ambiguous, but the main point about forbidden peasant autonomy and the "easily defeated" peasantry still stands. Look at the translation from the Latin in the other comment.
- zdkl 6y agoI have no relevant information for that era so this is purely a translation note. I'd love to learn more though, would you mind sharing additional reading you find pertinent? I question your use of "seceding" for "conjuré". As far as I understand, the connotation of ~seperation from a whole~ is absent in the original french which I'd argue speaks more of the spontaneous and unsanctioned nature of this militia's constitution. As in "le peuple ..., conjuré entre soi" could be adapted to "the people, having organised to take arms"
- rsync 6y ago"Peasant autonomy and self-defense of any kind could not be tolerated." In the United States, "gun control" (restrictions on gun rights) is universally classified as a liberal/left policy and the absence of "gun control" is classified as a conservative/right policy. Without entering into a discussion of these politics I would like to point out that those classifications are completely backwards. The US Second Amendment (and associated US gun rights, court interpretations, etc.) are extremely liberal, from an historical perspective.
- craig1f 6y agoIncorrect. Republicans have successfully branded themselves as gun advocates, and Democrats as anti-gun. There are as many liberal gun owners as conservatives. Liberals just don't jerk off with their guns on social media.
- js2 6y agoSome brief googling doesn't support the assertion that there are as many liberal (Democratic) gun owners as their are conservative (Republican) gun owners: https://news.gallup.com/poll/21496/gun-ownership-higher-among-republicans-than-democrats.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/21496/gun-ownership-higher-amon... But this is way too reductive. There's lots of gun ownership in the US across all political affiliations. Additionally, gun ownership is independent of someone's views on guns. I know people with liberal views on gun ownership who don't own guns and people with restrictive views on gun ownership who do own guns.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoThis is just factually incorrect. Republicans are significantly more likely to own guns than Democrats: https://www.statista.com/statistics/249775/percentage-of-population-in-the-us-owning-a-gun-by-party-affiliation/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/249775/percentage-of-pop...
- NovemberWhiskey 6y ago