4 ms·

Isn’t this a knockoff of something posted earlier this year?

moron4hire 6y ago
There are about half a dozen different, similar apps that all came out around the same time (I have one as well). I've done a lot of research on all of them and none of them are copies of any of the others. They all have pretty unique implementations.
- woah 6y ago
  Can you post a list of them?
  - moron4hire 6y ago
    I don't think that's really fair to do in someone else's Launch HN. Hence I didn't even link to my own app.
    - liamuk 6y ago
      Another cofounder of Gather here -- I'm totally okay with you posting your app here (Calla right?) or the whole list. I think the hackernews comment readers would benefit from seeing the wider space of takes on this idea.
  - moron4hire 6y ago
    The half-dozen that I had researched that all came out around the same time: - https://calla.chat (my own, though I don't run it as a service, it's a component of my project at work) - https://mixaba.com - https://sococo.com - https://spatial.chat (which looks like a 2D version of Spatial.IO) - https://highfidelity.com (a 2D pivot for what was originally a VR project from one of the founders of Second Life) - https://hubs.mozilla.com I'm missing one or two as I noticed that the main variation in total features could be covered with only a few of the ones I've listed and just stopped updating my notes doc). Add in another half-dozen mentioned elsewhere in this thread (though I've not looked too deeply at most of them) - https://www.movement.fm/spaces - https://makespace.fun/ - https://grouproom.io/ - https://rambly.app/ - https://www.huddlehq.io/ - https://branch.gg/ These are just the ones that run in the browser. There are several more built specifically for VR (AltspaceVR, VR Chat, Spatial.IO, RecRoom, etc.), as well as some very long-running native desktop apps. 3D and spatial chat is a pretty long-running market.
    - rompic 6y ago
      Does anyone remember project wonderland? I remember doing a presentation about it at uni in 2008 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Wonderland https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Wonderland
apoorvagovind 6y ago
Yeah. Probably huddle?
eambutu 6y ago
We posted an early prototype of this, https://theonline.town https://theonline.town, back in March (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22818300 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22818300). As others have mentioned though, there are a ton of people building similar things.

There are about half a dozen different, similar apps that all came out around the same time (I have one as well). I've done a lot of research on all of them and none of them are copies of any of the others. They all have pretty unique implementations.

woah 6y ago
Can you post a list of them?
- moron4hire 6y ago
  I don't think that's really fair to do in someone else's Launch HN. Hence I didn't even link to my own app.
  - liamuk 6y ago
    Another cofounder of Gather here -- I'm totally okay with you posting your app here (Calla right?) or the whole list. I think the hackernews comment readers would benefit from seeing the wider space of takes on this idea.
- moron4hire 6y ago
  The half-dozen that I had researched that all came out around the same time: - https://calla.chat (my own, though I don't run it as a service, it's a component of my project at work) - https://mixaba.com - https://sococo.com - https://spatial.chat (which looks like a 2D version of Spatial.IO) - https://highfidelity.com (a 2D pivot for what was originally a VR project from one of the founders of Second Life) - https://hubs.mozilla.com I'm missing one or two as I noticed that the main variation in total features could be covered with only a few of the ones I've listed and just stopped updating my notes doc). Add in another half-dozen mentioned elsewhere in this thread (though I've not looked too deeply at most of them) - https://www.movement.fm/spaces - https://makespace.fun/ - https://grouproom.io/ - https://rambly.app/ - https://www.huddlehq.io/ - https://branch.gg/ These are just the ones that run in the browser. There are several more built specifically for VR (AltspaceVR, VR Chat, Spatial.IO, RecRoom, etc.), as well as some very long-running native desktop apps. 3D and spatial chat is a pretty long-running market.
  - rompic 6y ago
    Does anyone remember project wonderland? I remember doing a presentation about it at uni in 2008 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Wonderland https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Wonderland

apoorvagovind 6y ago

Yeah. Probably huddle?

eambutu 6y ago

We posted an early prototype of this, https://theonline.town https://theonline.town, back in March (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22818300 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22818300). As others have mentioned though, there are a ton of people building similar things.