4 ms·
It seems a bit unreasonable to require a company to support a product for perpetuity. We already do have warranty laws that require products to do the thing th
by kube-system 6y ago
It seems a bit unreasonable to require a company to support a product for perpetuity. We already do have warranty laws that require products to do the thing they say they do for a reasonable period of time. Maybe we disagree on the specific duration, but I think few would agree that infinity is a reasonable number.
- tenebrisalietum 6y agoIf a physical device is tied to a company's service and can only be used with that company's service, it's very reasonable. What the company should do is rent you the physical device--not sell it to you. Cable companies operate on this model. I'm not familiar if Slingbox's devices fall in this category as I've never used them though.
- kube-system 6y agoI don’t think the engineering of the device necessarily has any relevance to this problem. At its core, this is a consumer law problem, not an engineering problem. We have laws to protect consumer because they have a right not to be cheated out of their money. We don’t make it the job of lawyers and legislators to make decisions about which engineering architectures are right or wrong. If we decide that consumers should be able to reasonably expect their widgets to last X duration of time, then that right shouldn’t be predicated on an engineering decision the consumer knows nothing about or has no power to choose.
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoThey shouldn't have to support it forever, but they should have to let someone else support it.
- pwdisswordfish4 6y agoStrawman. Not the argument of the person you're responding to.
- kube-system 6y agoIn what way?
- Xelbair 6y agoyou either sell a service or a product, and must brand it as such. IF you sell a product you lose all rights to modify, restrict and do anything with the copy you sold. Open sourcing sunsetted projects, seems like a really sane approach - because lets face it - it can, and is, used as a form of planned obsolescence.