3 ms·
>According to 8008 designer Hal Feeney, "We built the carry look-ahead logic because we needed the speed as far as the processor is concerned. So carry look ahe
by ncmncm 6y ago
>According to 8008 designer Hal Feeney, "We built the carry look-ahead logic because we needed the speed as far as the processor is concerned. So carry look ahead seemed like something we could integrate and have fairly low real estate overhead and, as you see, the whole carry look ahead is just a very small portion of the chip."
This is a very strange remark. Setting aside whether Feeney actually did design it, that look-ahead carry takes up a huge area of the chip -- almost as much as the whole rest of the ALU.
If they had cared about speed, they would not have shoehorned it into 18 pins.
According to Federico Faggin (Italian: "Fah-jeen"), Intel considered itself a memory company, and the 8008 project a waste of attention. They weren't about to set up 40-pin infrastructure for such a nothing part when no memory chip would ever need 40 pins.
When FF did the Z80, he realized that the result of an ALU op is never needed immediately with an 8080 ISA, so used a 4-bit unit, and was able to cut the look-ahead logic even more.
- kens 6y agoI was also surprised that Feeney considered carry generation to be a very small portion of the chip since it's a prominent part of the die. But I measured, and it's about 2% of the die. > If they had cared about speed, they would not have shoehorned it into 18 pins. My interpretation is that the 8008 team didn't have any control over Intel's bizarre 18-pin limit, but improving speed by adding carry lookahead was something they could do. Even so, the 8008 was slower than the Datapoint 2200's processor that it was supposed to replace and Datapoint abandoned the 8008.