2 ms·
> Mutations aren't a serious concern. Because when viruses mutate it's the strains that are more infectious and less lethal that win out. If only it worked tha
by samatman 6y ago
> Mutations aren't a serious concern. Because when viruses mutate it's the strains that are more infectious and less lethal that win out.
If only it worked that way! It doesn't, of course.
A random walk can lead anywhere in the adjacent landscape. That includes moving up in lethality without moving down in infectiousness. What you have written here is plausible-sounding nonsense; if it were true, the 1918 flu would never have occurred.
The good news is that influenza is almost pathologically mutation-prone, and coronaviruses are not.
- empthought 6y agoThank you for pointing this out.
- freewilly1040 6y agoThe oft-cited theory about 1918 is that WWI upended the traits that were selected for in the virus. Whereas in peace time a more serious case would reduce the mobility of the victim, in war a serious infection would result in the patient (a soldier) being transported off the front lines, spreading the more serious version of the virus more.
- sellyme 6y agoMoving up in lethality while maintaining the same "infectiousness" still results in a real-world decrease in infection rate, as more infected hosts will die (and/or infected hosts will die more quickly), preventing them from spreading it further.
- samatman 6y agoIn the case of COVID-19, which is highly contagious, has a long latency period, and is in fact not especially fatal by the standard of diseases ending in -RS, this might be true on paper, but would be cold comfort in practice.